Central Review Board
MS 5703.99 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Central Review Board is one of the two bodies sharing authority over the Aperture Cycle Review, the other being the Aperture Group. It is the older of the two, though by how much is disputed, and it is the only review body in the Tower whose quorum requirements are set by a document nobody has produced in full since the Second Recension. Its seat is Floor 1,204, the Suite of Assumed Jurisdiction, which it has occupied since before the floor was numbered.
The Board's principal work is the Documentation Phase of the Aperture Cycle, during which petitions are received, sealed, weighed against precedent, and either forwarded or held. It also holds sole authority over non-standard aperture classifications — those apertures whose markings cannot be reconciled with Table 9 of Aperture Markings — a competence it has exercised eleven times since the present roll was opened.
Composition and quorum
The Board comprises nine seated members and an indeterminate number of recording clerks. Seats are held by seniority measured in petitions processed rather than years served, a distinction insisted upon by Librarian Ostvel Marrant in a memorandum of the 3rd of Amsel, Year 611, and never since overturned.
Quorum is nominally five. The actual figure is a matter of some difficulty. Concordance 88 sets quorum at five; Annex 88.b, appended without rescission, requires "no fewer than five, and in any event one more than are present." The Board resolves this by counting the chamber's duty clerk as a member for the purposes of the second clause only, a practice recorded in Column 774-Δ (“The Quarterly Review”) as "arithmetically indefensible and procedurally sound." Visitors are asked not to stand in the doorway during a count.
The Documentation Phase
Petitions arriving at the Board are entered in the Register of Assumed Jurisdiction and assigned a provisional aperture classification. Roughly four in five are forwarded to the Aperture Group without hearing. The remainder are held, and a held petition may rest in the Board's custody for a considerable time; the oldest unresolved file, concerning a stairwell aperture on Floor 903, has been held since Year 344 and is consulted annually by a clerk who confirms only that it is still held.
The Board's relationship with the Gamma Review Board is one of long and formalised friction. The Gamma Board, which administers Floor 7, Access Gamma, has twice asserted that held petitions pass to its jurisdiction after ninety days. The Central Review Board has twice declined to acknowledge the assertion, on the grounds that it was made in a corridor.
Dispute over the founding document
Scholars disagree as to whether the Central Review Board was instituted by Declaration of Clarification 42.α or merely recognised by it. The Board of Equitable Review was unambiguously instituted by that Declaration, and the text names only one board.
"The Board of Equitable Review is hereby instituted, and the Board already sitting at the aperture shall be taken to have been instituted always."
— Declaration of Clarification 42.α, clause 3
Librarian Ostvel Marrant reads "the Board already sitting" as the Central Review Board and considers the question closed. Archivist Perrin Hault of the Office of Concordant Interpretation reads it as a drafting error and notes that clause 3 was struck through in the Winnowed Manuscript — though the strikethrough, he concedes, is in a different hand and may be later. The Board itself has taken no position, having voted in Year 588 that the question "does not arise for its own purposes."
Appeals and the Equitable parallel
Appeals against the Board's substantive decisions lie to the Board of Equitable Review, a body with which the Central Review Board is procedurally parallel and, in the matter of the Period, temperamentally opposed. Appeals concerning the Board's own conduct — a category widened in Year 702 to include the tone of its refusals — lie to the Board of Equitable Review as well, which has been described by Librarian Ostvel Marrant as "an arrangement of great convenience to the Board of Equitable Review."
The Dialectical Review Board, which maintains procedural authority parallel to but distinct from the Equitable Board, contests the Gamma Review Board's jurisdiction over deferrals. It has not contested the Central Review Board's, and when asked why, replied that the Central Board "defers nothing; it merely declines to conclude," which the Central Board has adopted as its official description.
Floor, access, and maintenance
The Suite of Assumed Jurisdiction is reached by the north stair from Floor 1,201 and by no other route. The Board's chamber is 14 by 9 paces, windowless, and heated by a single flue that the Board of Mandates has classified as structural rather than serviceable, placing its repair outside the Board's own competence. The flue has not been repaired. Hearings between the months of Grev and Thaw are conducted in coats.
The Board's seal, a closed aperture within an open one, is held under Concordance 12 by the recording clerk on duty, who is forbidden to set it down on any surface other than the felt tray provided. The felt tray was lost in Year 649 and replaced in Year 651. The intervening two years of sealed documents bear a seal applied in the clerk's palm, and are valid.
See also
-
MS 3401.99
Clerks of the Aperture
The Clerks of the Aperture constitute one of the principal administrative bodies within the lower-stack bureaucratic hierarchy, ve…
-
MS 3467.47
Spiral 14
Spiral 14 is a vertical library-sector of disputed classification, currently catalogued under the provisional designation Spira Ob…
-
MS 4606.71
Floor 8,112
Floor 8,112 is a hanging floor situated between Floor 8,111 and Floor 8,113, though the second of these relationships is recorded …
-
MS 7750.99
The Aperture Cycle Review
The Aperture Cycle Review is the standing examination conducted at the close of each Aperture Cycle to determine whether a given a…
-
MS 9063.77
Transposition Authority
Transposition Authority is the standing power, held jointly and disputed daily, to declare that a thing has been moved when no one…
-
MS 0210.62
Floor 900
Floor 900, officially designated 900 in the Central Index, is a disputed floor known primarily as the holding site for unresolved …
Referenced by
- MS 1790.11 Pre-Review Documentation
- MS 8653.31 Dialectical Review Board
- MS 7750.99 The Aperture Cycle Review
- MS 1650.12 Gamma Review Board
- MS 8263.34 Board of Adjacent Review
- MS 2323.37 Aperture Regulation Board
- MS 6595.03 Documentation Phase
Readers also asked
Concordance 88: what does it set out?
The document formally designated Concordance 88, also referred to in some filing indices as "The Crossed Quill Concordance," is a core administrative instrument governing the allocation and withdrawal of amendment-tracki…
Concordance 88Winnowed Manuscript: what does it set out?
The Winnowed Manuscript is the official log of contested entries to floor catalogues, maintained by the Review Chamber on Floor 1801 (the Review Chamber). It exists in two concurrent states: a continuous scroll in the Ch…
Winnowed ManuscriptDocumentation Phase: how is it conducted?
Documentation Phase is the designation given to the interval during which a subject's record is brought into correspondence with the archive's standing requirements. It is the principal work of the Central Review Board, …
Documentation PhaseDeclaration of Clarification 42.α: what does it set out?
Declaration of Clarification 42.α is a Declaration of Clarification issued by the Board of Concordant Interpretation in the seventh session of the 1,041st Concordant Cycle. It is best known as the instrument by which the…
Declaration of Clarification 42.αPassages cited from this record
-
The Board of Equitable Review is hereby instituted, and the Board already sitting at the aperture shall be taken to have been instituted always.
Declaration of Clarification 42.α, clause 3
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 8743.85 Aperture Cycle Review
- MS 4033.58 Librarian Ostvel Marrant
- MS 6405.13 Table 9 of Aperture Markings
- MS 3160.13 Archivist Perrin Hault
Because you consulted