Doctrine of Imperfect Certification
MS 6994.09 · Practices and doctrines
The Doctrine of Imperfect Certification is a governing practice of the Office of Absolute Registry, holding that no act of certification performed in the Tower may be regarded as absolute, and that this insufficiency must itself be formally acknowledged, notarised, and then set aside. The acknowledged insufficiency is bracketed and filed separately, ordinarily in the Annex of Bracketed Reservations on floor 4,118, where it does not impede the certification it qualifies. The Doctrine is thus the central paradox of the Office: the Registry is the Tower's final authority on whether a thing is what it is said to be, and its founding instrument states that it cannot be.
It is frequently confused with the Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence, which concerns the transmission of intent between parties rather than the adequacy of certification. The two Doctrines conflict in their account of the final step, and auditors are instructed to establish which one applies before entering a finding, since the finding will differ depending on the answer and cannot afterwards be amended without a fresh submission.
Origin and recension
The Doctrine first appears as an unnumbered preliminary note to the Eleventh Concordance, concerning seals, but the recension most commonly cited is that entered under Clause 44.C of the Nineteenth Concordance in the winter of Cycle 12,344. The clerk responsible, Registry-Ordinary Maren Vell, recorded in her day-book that the clause had been drafted three times and that "the third draft was accepted because the second could not be found." The clause was subsequently amended six times; the fourth amendment has never been located, though its existence is attested by three separate validation chains and by a marginal note in the Receiving Slate reading see amendment 4, misplaced.
The four-clause threshold
An object is typically flagged for potential remand to the Archives of Imperfect Forms when it violates more than four clauses of the Doctrine. Below that threshold the object is certified with a note; at five or more it is remanded, held, or — in the case of objects too large for the corridors — certified provisionally and left where it stands.
The counting is less settled than the threshold implies. The Bureau of Ambiguous Forms maintains that clauses are counted cumulatively, while the Office of Absolute Registry counts only distinct clauses, so that an object failing the same clause five times (a not uncommon circumstance in the case of Imperfect Silhouettes) is remanded by one office and certified by the other. The dispute has run since Cycle 12,509 and has produced eleven recensions of the counting schedule. Archivist-Lateral Senex, whose dissent on the Seventeenth Concordance produced the Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence, is recorded as having declined to rule on it, noting that he had "already given the Tower one doctrine and did not propose to be remembered for two."
Application and notable remands
The Doctrine's ordinary work is confined to objects submitted through the Certification Amp Shelves, which carry the certificates and the bracketed reservations on separate stock. In practice a Certification Claim is entered, the object is examined against the clauses, and the reservation is filed on 4,118 before the certificate is sealed — the reverse order being reserved for objects that are expected to fail.
The most-cited application remains the remand of the Degenerate Whorls from the third gallery, which exceeded the threshold by a considerable margin and were transferred to the Archives of Imperfect Forms over four days in Cycle 12,377. The transfer required the Ceremony of Final Punctuation to be observed, and the Rite of Final Negation was read over each whorl in turn. Three were not read over, having rolled into the stairwell. They were recovered the following spring, considerably further down, and destroyed without ceremony under an emergency reading of Clause 44.C. Visitors are asked not to steady the whorls as they pass.
Relation to other doctrines
The Doctrine is often invoked alongside the Principle of Intentional Absence and the Taxonomy of Imperfect Duplicates; the latter classifies objects by the manner of their failure, the former by its deliberateness. The Society for Literal Concordance, founded after the Great Schism of Cycle 12,501, holds that the Doctrine is incoherent on its face and has said so in a pamphlet circulated on four floors. The Registry's formal answer, given in Certification of Non-Conflict, is that the Doctrine does not require coherence of itself, only that the incoherence be certified. That answer has satisfied no one and is reprinted annually.
Criticism and current standing
The standing objection, raised first by Registry-Ordinary Vell and never resolved, is that the Doctrine's own acknowledgment of insufficiency must itself be certified, and that the resulting recursive loop may only be closed by a further acknowledgment, filed separately. The Registry has chosen not to close it. The Omega-7 filing on floor 4,118 has grown by roughly forty ledgers a cycle since 12,344 and is now approached by a walkway. The Doctrine remains in force, and the walkway is inspected annually.
"The certification is imperfect. This is acknowledged. The acknowledgment is filed. The filing is not examined."
— Nineteenth Concordance, Clause 44.C, superscription
See also
-
MS 3044.75
The Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence
The Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence is the principle, codified in clause 81.B of the Seventeenth Concordance, that governs al…
-
MS 3356.47
Procedural Adherence
Procedural Adherence is the doctrine and administrative practice holding that an act is properly performed only when performed by …
-
MS 5358.96
Ontological Insufficiency
Ontological insufficiency is the condition of an entity, category, or process within the Tower for which the existing principles o…
-
MS 5340.51
School of Absolute Constancy
The School of Absolute Constancy is a scholastic faction within the Librarian orders, formally established by Lira of the Forty-Se…
-
MS 1884.58
Wing C: Imperfect Silhouettes
Wing C: Imperfect Silhouettes is the eighth of the eleven sub-wings composing the Shadow Annex, and the largest single repository …
-
MS 7210.88
Chronological Precedence Practice
Chronological Precedence Practice is the primary administrative doctrine governing the resolution of contradictory injunctions, ma…
Referenced by
- MS 3044.75 The Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence
- MS 0610.89 Taxonomy of Imperfect Duplicates
- MS 2314.80 Archives of Imperfect Forms
- MS 6224.53 Vault of Absolute Constancy
- MS 4710.29 Doctrine of Unilineal Descent Practice
- MS 3440.06 Certification Plaques
- MS 2758.99 Certification Block
- MS 4852.36 School of Absolute Discontinuity
- MS 2551.79 Hall of Absolute Articles
- MS 7662.72 Legibility Certification
- MS 2335.31 Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence
- MS 4829.67 Imperfect Silhouette
Readers also asked
Nineteenth Concordance: what does it set out?
Nineteenth Concordance is the primary supplementary governance document pertaining to the cataloguing and containment of persistent ephemera within the Tower. Ratified on 14 Thermidor, Year 117 of the calendar establishe…
Nineteenth ConcordanceClause Omega-7 (Certification Recursion): how is it conducted?
Clause Omega-7 (Certification Recursion) is the seventh and final clause of Annex Omega (Closed-Loop Certifications) of the Fourteenth Concordance. It establishes the formal doctrine of chronological precedence and the p…
Clause Omega-7 (Certification Recursion)The Recursive Certification Loop: how is it conducted?
The Recursive Certification Loop is a self-referential administrative procedure by which the issuance of a Recursive Loop Certification is itself certified as a recursive process, thereby requiring a prior certification …
The Recursive Certification LoopTaxonomy of Imperfect Duplicates: what does it set out?
The Taxonomy of Imperfect Duplicates is the foundational 300-volume classificatory schema for all objects that are nearly, but not entirely, identical to a referent or to each other. Produced by the School of Particulars…
Taxonomy of Imperfect DuplicatesPassages cited from this record
-
The certification is imperfect. This is acknowledged. The acknowledgment is filed. The filing is not examined.
Nineteenth Concordance, Clause 44.C, superscription
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 2967.43 Ceremony of Final Punctuation
- MS 4799.98 Maren Vell
- MS 6329.52 Degenerate Whorls
- MS 8629.22 Registry-Ordinary Vell
Because you consulted