Corollaries
MS 4458.43 · Practices and doctrines
The '''Corollaries''' are the class of derivable statements, objects, and minor architectural features that the Tower produces whenever a holding is catalogued in sufficient formal completeness. They are not invented, commissioned, or requested by any office; they follow. The Tower's position on this is settled and has been since the Forty Third Concordance, whose formal title is "The Concordance of Unwitnessed Occurrences and Their Procedural Corollaries," and which devotes its first four annexes to the proposition that a corollary is not a thing the Tower makes but a thing the Tower necessarily has made.
Practically, corollaries are catalogued as holdings in their own right, on the floor where they arose, under the same number with a lowercase suffix appended. This is the whole of the difficulty. A corollary of a corollary is still a corollary. A corollary of a corollary of a corollary is a corollary, and the archive has no working term for the fifth remove, because until Ardon Vell's dissent nobody had needed one.
The Sub-Index
The Cascade of Unfounded Corollaries governs the reader's understanding of everything in this article, and the article must therefore begin with it. On the 122nd day of Cycle 8,211, cataloguing operations on Floor 712 produced a corollary that had not been introduced by any prior holding; the corollary's own catalogue entry produced a further corollary; the process ran for seventeen days and paralyzed Floors 712 through 715. The incident report filed by Clerk-Archivist Marn remains the fullest account of the first four hours.
The Sub-Index was codified in the wake of the Cascade as a separate register for corollaries generated during cataloguing rather than acquired through ordinary means. It is kept in a different scriptorium from the main index, on a different floor, and its entries are never interfiled. Librarians asked why the two indexes are not merged cite the Third Concordance, which is silent on the subject and therefore decisive.
Standing corollaries and the corollary registry
Not every corollary is a product of crisis. Most are quiet and long-standing. The Guild of Formal Cartographers maintains, as a condition of its Charter of Incorporation, a registry of corollaries that arise from the Guild's own survey instruments; the corridor widening on the fourth landing of the western flight of Floor 408 is the standard example. It was not built. It followed from the survey, in the same way a shadow follows a wall, and is now catalogued as a corollary of the survey, with the standing instruction that it may not be widened, narrowed, or lit. The instruction is posted at both ends.
The Axiomats hold an older position: that the registry is redundant, since every corollary is already implied by the holding it follows from, and the Tower's records are complete by definition or the Tower would not be a complete record. The Librarians have not ruled on the Axiomats' objection. They have ruled on the lighting of the fourth landing.
The implied-corollary dispute
The most durable disagreement in the corollary literature concerns not which corollaries exist but which ones are counted. The Final Tally, following the Cascade, was compiled by a method that counted only corollaries stated in the record. Ardon Vell, Librarian Emeritus, dissented, alleging that the count omitted every corollary that was implied but never stated, and that the omission was not an error of arithmetic but a category error of the kind the Forty Third Concordance exists to prevent. In Vell's phrasing, the Tally had counted the books and not the shelves.
The dissent was echoed at the Post-Cascade Reconciliation and again in Vell's audit of the Great Re-cataloguing. No amendment to the Final Tally has been issued. An informal count of the omitted corollaries was conducted in the margin of the Reconciliation roll and is itself listed in the Sub-Index as a corollary of the Reconciliation, which is understood by everyone concerned to prove Vell's point and to be useless as evidence.
Corollaries in the audits
Corollaries derived from The Theorem of Negational Symmetry are frequently invoked during the Symmetry Audit, and the audit has developed an entire apparatus for them. A corollary of the Theorem is admitted if the negation it implies aligns with the floor's existing numbering, and rejected if the alignment is coincidental. The distinction between alignment and coincidence is not recorded anywhere in the Concordances and is settled by the audit's presiding officer on the day, which the Guild of Precedential Cartographers has twice noted, without success, in its formal remonstrances.
Corollaries are also produced, in a restricted form, by the correction of the first edition of the Third Concordance, whose erratum slip was held in the end to imply a second erratum slip which was never printed and is now catalogued.
Prohibitions and handling
The following are the principal restrictions on corollaries in force, gathered here from the Sub-Index and the Forty Third Concordance:
- A corollary may not be cited against the holding it follows from.
- No corollary may be removed from the floor of its origin, save that a corollary of a stairwell may be climbed. It may not be descended.
- Corollaries arising in the reading rooms are to be reported to the duty clerk, not to a desk.
There is no procedure for a corollary that follows from a person rather than a holding, and the case is not hypothetical. A clerk who worked nine years in the corridor outside the Guild of Phoneticists is listed in the Sub-Index as a corollary of the corridor. The corridor's entry has been amended twice since. The clerk's has not.
See also
Cascade of Unfounded Corollaries Forty Third Concordance Compendium of Unheeded Dissents Third Concordance Sounds of Unwritten Prefaces The Former Principles of Lateral Gravity
See also
-
MS 1325.94
Index of Corollaries
The Index of Corollaries is the Tower's working register of statements derived from held material without having been acquired, co…
-
MS 4151.41
Axiomatic Resonance Chamber
Axiomatic Resonance Chamber is the formal designation of Floor 744 of the Tower, a sealed enclosure in which axiomatic statements …
-
MS 8554.82
Descriptive Plenitude
Descriptive Plenitude is the condition of a catalogue entry whose description admits no further addition — neither clause, qualifi…
-
MS 4696.35
Presumption of Completeness (Cartographic)
The Presumption of Completeness (Cartographic) is a formal axiom of archival practice holding that a map, once sealed and entered …
-
MS 6967.78
Doctrine of Completeness
Doctrine of Completeness is the collective name given to the body of rulings, presumptions, and procedural habits by which the Tow…
-
MS 1523.76
Provisional Authentication
Provisional Authentication is the form of limited standing conferred on a catalogued object whose provenance is accepted as suffic…
Referenced by
- MS 1556.31 Guild of Formal Cartographers
- MS 1698.78 Class A (Architectural)
Readers also asked
Sounds of Unwritten Prefaces: how is it conducted?
Sounds of Unwritten Prefaces are a class of acoustic phenomena catalogued on Floor 14,022, defined as the auditory corollaries to the material held in the Gallery of Unwritten Prefaces. Governed by a contentious intersec…
Sounds of Unwritten PrefacesGuild of Formal Cartographers: who are they?
The Guild of Formal Cartographers is a chartered body within the Theoretical Jurisprudence Guild, formally recognized by the Librarians for the production, verification, and archival maintenance of Cartae Formales – docu…
Guild of Formal CartographersSymmetry Audit: how is it conducted?
Symmetry Audit is the formal, biennial procedure for verifying the precise balance between an archival entity and its designated inverse or counterpart, as mandated by the Symmetry Edicts. Conducted by the Directorate of…
Symmetry AuditCascade of Unfounded Corollaries: what happened?
The Cascade of Unfounded Corollaries was a cataloging anomaly of seventeen days' duration on Floors 712 through 715, characterized by the spontaneous, non-volitional instantiation of corollary statements and objects deri…
Cascade of Unfounded CorollariesReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 8254.36 Clerk-Archivist Marn
Because you consulted