The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Index of Corollaries

MS 1325.94 · Documents and ordinances

The Index of Corollaries is the Tower's working register of statements derived from held material without having been acquired, commissioned, or witnessed. It is maintained in continuous recension by the Clerk of Precedents and is distinct from the Sub-Index of Unstated Corollaries in that it records corollaries already entered into the holdings, whereas the Sub-Index records those merely implied by them. The Index occupies the eastern wall of the Precedents Chancery on Floor 604 and, by the count of the 8,214th recension, contains 41,806 entries across 312 bound fascicles. It is the only register in the Tower that is rebound rather than amended.

Origin and mandate

The Index was not planned. Prior to the Cascade of Unfounded Corollaries of Cycle 8,211, corollaries were noted in the margins of the holdings from which they followed, a practice the Forty Third Concordance later described as "adequate to a smaller Tower" (Annex 4). The Cascade — seventeen days of spontaneous instantiation across Floors 712 through 715 — produced corollaries faster than any margin could hold them, and the margin system failed on the fourth day when a single entry on Floor 712 generated eleven derivative statements, four derivative objects, and a second, smaller stairwell.

The Forty Third Concordance ("The Concordance of Unwitnessed Occurrences and Their Procedural Corollaries") established in clause 2 that corollaries are necessarily made by the Tower, not invented or requested, and charged the Clerk of Precedents with preparing the Index of Corollaries for each new Precedent. The first bound fascicle was sealed on the 301st day of Cycle 8,211. It has been rebound, not amended, on every occasion since, on the reasoning that a corollary cannot be struck without striking the holding it follows from, and that has never yet been thought advisable.

Method of entry

An entry is made only after the Clerk has verified symbolic consistency and applied the official seal of immanence. Entries are numbered sequentially within the fascicle rather than the Tower, and each carries a reference to its parent holding, the date of derivation, and a note of the deriving clerk. Later clerks annotate earlier entries in the lower margin; later annotations are annotated in turn, and the twentieth fascicle carries a marginal chain forty-one deep in a hand so reduced that the Master Index for Provisional Holdings keeps a separate key to it.

Disputes over derivation are heard by the Clerk sitting alone. Ardon Vell, Librarian Emeritus, records that in Cycle 8,209 he waited eleven days for a hearing on whether a corollary concerning the weight of a sealed door followed from the door or from the seal. The Clerk ruled that it followed from both, and entered it twice.

The Vell dissent and the Final Tally

The Index's counting method has been contested since the Cascade. The Final Tally of Cycle 8,211 recorded 3,914 corollaries instantiated during the seventeen days. Ardon Vell dissented, alleging that the Tally counted only corollaries stated in full and omitted those implied but unstated — corollaries of corollaries, which he held to be "no less made by the Tower for having been made quietly" (Vell, Dissent on the Final Tally, circulated in manuscript, unpaginated). The dissent was entered in the Index as an entry in its own right, and the entry generated a further corollary, which was entered also. Vell objected to this as well. The objection is entry 9,102.

The Index has never adopted Vell's method, though it has never rejected it either. The Symmetry Audit invokes corollaries drawn from The Theorem of Negational Symmetry so frequently that the audit's own summary is bound into the Index as an appendix, and the appendix is itself audited. The Clerk of Precedents has declined four times to rule on whether an appendix may generate corollaries, on the grounds that ruling either way would settle it.

Relation to the other registers

The Index is conventionally read against five others: the Sub-Index, the Unwritten Index, the Satellite Index, the Master Floor Index, and AP-88: “The Index of Ambiguous Precedents”. Only the last overlaps the Index of Corollaries materially. AP-88 holds precedents whose status is in doubt; the Index of Corollaries holds corollaries whose precedent is not in doubt; and the two registers have for two centuries disputed jurisdiction over a single entry — the corollary of the disputed door-seal ruling — which each holds, and each declines to release, on the ground that the other's claim is stronger.

Later controversies

Following the Cascade, procedural amendments governing the Register of Unfulfilled Introductions required that register to be cross-checked against the Index quarterly. The first cross-check, in the winter of Cycle 8,213, returned 1,140 unfulfilled introductions whose corresponding corollaries were already entered, a result the then Clerk described in the fascicle as "orderly, if not welcome." The check is now performed annually.

The Index is closed to visiting Librarians on the 19th day of each cycle, when the eastern wall is treated for damp. Requests to consult on that day may be made in writing; they are answered the following day, or bound as corollaries if they are not.

Current state

The Index is at present in its 8,214th recension, with 41,806 entries and a supplementary annex of 2,309 unresolved derivations. The unresolved entries are not omissions; they are entries whose parent holding is itself awaiting a corollary from a higher floor, and they will be settled when the higher floor is catalogued. No one has reached the higher floor. The annex grows at a rate of roughly forty entries per cycle, and the Clerk of Precedents has ruled that it will not be rebound until it stops growing.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Master Floor Index: what does it set out?

The Master Floor Index is the principal registry of floor designations, names, and numerical assignments maintained for the whole of the Tower, held on The Index and administered jointly with the Master Index. Unlike the…

Master Floor Index
Unwritten Index: where is it?

Unwritten Index is a location within the Tower, situated on Floor 11,407-beta, which houses The Unwritten Concordance in a hermetically sealed null-cabinet and serves as the physical locus of the Schism of the Unwritten …

Unwritten Index
Ardon Vell: who were they?

Ardon Vell was a prominent figure in Tower administrative and catalogical scholarship, holding the offices of Senior Auditor, Senior Librarian, Warden of Boundary Arbitration, and Librarian Emeritus across a long career …

Ardon Vell
Cascade of Unfounded Corollaries: what happened?

The Cascade of Unfounded Corollaries was a cataloging anomaly of seventeen days' duration on Floors 712 through 715, characterized by the spontaneous, non-volitional instantiation of corollary statements and objects deri…

Cascade of Unfounded Corollaries

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.