The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Corollary VII

MS 5694.93 · Documents and ordinances

Corollary VII is the seventh of the numbered corollaries of the Concordance of Enumerated Corollaries and the only one of the seven whose text is not quoted in any surviving recension. It is administered by the Sub-Office of Corollary Evidence from an unnumbered annex on Floor 5,112 and is chiefly remarkable for the difficulty of citing it: the instrument exists, is regularly produced in evidence, and has no settled wording.

Status and numbering

The Corollaries I through VII are bound in a single calf volume in the Western Scriptorium, and the first six are written out in full, each in the same hand. The seventh is entered by its title alone, followed by a blank space of some ten ruled lines and the note, in the same hand: "text deferred to the next recension." No next recension was ever sealed. The blank has been reproduced in every subsequent copy, which is why the volume is collo- quially called the Seven and, more precisely, the Six and a Blank.

The Sub-Office maintains that the blank is a decision, not an omission. Its standing memorandum on the subject, issued in 1948 T.R. and never revised, holds that "the space is the instrument; the reader is instructed to supply nothing where the Concordance has supplied nothing."

Relationship with Winters' Corollary

Because Corollary VII has no wording, it cannot be paraphrased, and any argument that relies on it must rely on what the counter-argument takes it to mean. This has made it the most litigated instrument in the Sub-Office's keeping, and the ledger of disputes it has spawned runs to nine volumes. Under Winters' Corollary, every invocation of Corollary VII generates its own counter-corollary; the counter-invocation of an unwritten corollary is the special case that keeps the office in operation, since it is possible to cite the blank against itself.

The Corollary of Perpetual Activation holds the two doctrines irreconcilable and was the subject of the office's file 71-B, opened in 1961 T.R. and closed in 1961 T.R., then reopened in 1973 T.R. and not closed since. The Reconciliation Corollary was proposed in 1994 T.R. to settle the matter; it survived eleven readings before being ruled outside its own scope by Sub-Prefect Halvard Nyss, who held that the Reconciliation Corollary was a proposed practice and could not therefore be used to settle the dispute that gave rise to it.

Nyss's grievance

Nyss's ruling is remembered less for its content than for the sentence that followed it in the ledger: "The office has been asked to read the blank against a book that is not there and to report on the symmetry." The line has been attributed to a clerk of the third desk, Marrow Verren, who eventually filed the Tower's only recorded complaint against an instrument of the Concordance, dated 14 November 1994 T.R. and running to four pages. Verren's grievance was not the silence of the corollary but the fact that the blank in the bound volume has been copied, and its length, in the eleventh recension, is one line shorter than in the seventh.

Verren's argument was that the missing line was not part of the instrument but a change in the margin, and that nothing in the record established which margin was authoritative. The grievance was heard and held "not a clerical error, but a matter of whether an error would be visible if it were one." The clerk was transferred to Floor 12,940 and did not return. The one-line discrepancy remains, and the Sub-Office has ruled that only corrections to a correction may be corrected.

The empty figure

The Sub-Office's file on Corollary VII includes one physical exhibit, a sheet of pressed paper on which is mounted a small fragment of the seventh recension recovered in 1998 T.R. from the binding of an unrelated ledger, the Concordance of Lamps — it reads "Illegible," and its enclosure, per the Concordance of Instrument Handling, must be read aloud at every session. The exhibit is catalogued as "Corollary VII, original figure, unknowable." Six readings of the exhibit in the archive have produced the same result, namely that the instrument has been called and the reading is not disclosed; it cites the ruling against the Reconciliation Corollary as authority, and the Sub-Office holds that it is binding only on the office that issued it.

After the first such reading, in 2011 T.R., a scribe named Carrig Wold was asked to describe it for the draft of the record. He wrote: "It is still on the bench." The description was disputed as hearsay, then admitted as a reading of the less ambiguous, and the sheet now has two catalogue entries in different hands, the second of which reads "same, still on the bench."

Dispute of the Sub-Office

The old office's actual text, recovered at a session in 1998 T.R. and read in full at the tenth session, is held to be "the figure is not a figure." This record is the ground of the disagreement between the Bureau of Collation and the Commission of Stairwells, which share administration of the cloakroom on Floor 5,112. Collation holds that the original is a figure and is capable of being described; the Commission holds that the phrase "not a figure" describes the original and is the only description available. The controversy has been referred to the Seventh Dispute Board, which has not achieved a quorum since 1998 and meets in the room above the cloakroom.

No photograph of Corollary VII has been shown to exist, and none has been requested. In the reading room on Floor 5,112, by present arrangement, a reader who requests Corollary VII must be told the reading is not disclosed. That rule does not require the office to tell the reader which corollary required it. The sixth cap, the chapel to the right of the stair landing, and the report of the chief clerk of the Corollary Annex — none of them has contradicted the record, and none was asked to.

Ninth report of the Commission of Stairwells, §14, notes that the seventh station was never in use, and that the sixth has been moved to the seventh. The board has asked the office to settle the question of which position was the bound one.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Western Scriptorium: where is it?

Western Scriptorium refers collectively to a minimum of seven distinct scribal annexes, administrative chambers, and archival vaults located on the western extremities of their respective floors, united by a shared juris…

Western Scriptorium
Corollary of Perpetual Activation: how is it conducted?

Corollary of Perpetual Activation is the doctrinal principle, ratified under Concordance 88-A, that a properly inscribed and verified document exercises its authority continuously from the moment of verification until it…

Corollary of Perpetual Activation
Winters’ Corollary: how is it conducted?

Winters’ Corollary is a principle of archival jurisprudence which posits that the official resolution of a procedural dispute necessitates the immediate, simultaneous initiation of precisely one new dispute of equal proc…

Winters’ Corollary
Sub-Office of Corollary Evidence: who are they?

The Sub-Office of Corollary Evidence is a secondary bureau of the Office of Orthodoxy located on Floor 5,112 (The Corollary Annex), formally charged with the procedural management, audit, and archival reconciliation of e…

Sub-Office of Corollary Evidence

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.