The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Bureau of Phenomenological Designations

MS 5736.83 · Guilds, orders and offices

## Bureau of Phenomenological Designations The Bureau of Phenomenological Designations is the office responsible for assigning designations to phenomena that have been observed but not yet described with sufficient stability to be catalogued under any other heading. It is a sub-body of the Bureau of Singular Designations, which retained jurisdiction over its findings after the reorganisation of 1304 on the ground that a phenomenon that cannot be described is, by definition, one that cannot be written without a solidus. The Bureau occupies Floors 218 and 219, though only Floor 219 has a door; the earlier floor is reached from within the later one and is counted separately for the purposes of moveable furniture. Its work is distinct from that of the Phenomenological Spire, which issues Phenomenological Signatures, and from the Phenomenological Calibration office, which adjusts instruments. The Bureau of Phenomenological Designations does not measure phenomena and does not verify them. It gives them a working name so that other offices may discuss them without the conversation becoming unmoored. ## Origins and the winter of 1306 The Bureau was constituted by Fourth Concordance, Annex 6, in response to the so-called Matter of the Unnamed Corridor on Floor 40, a passage that was reliably reported to be longer in the afternoon than in the morning. Sixty-one persons attested to the fact. No instrument corroborated it. The Bureau of Spatial Designations declined the case on the ground that the corridor's dimensions were not in dispute — only its conduct — and the matter was referred upward. The Bureau's first act was to issue the designation P-1: the Elongating Passage, and its second was to record that the designation carried no admission that anything had elongated. The distinction between a designating name and a descriptive one has governed the office ever since. A designation issued under this head is a handle, not a finding. ## Method and the order of filing Designations are assigned alphabetically within bands, beginning at P-alpha and continuing through P-omega before the prefix advances; the Bureau has never advanced beyond P-gamma. A provisional designation is filed on Whisperwood with the Bureau of Appointments Sub-Division for Provisional Designations, pending integration into the Principal Register of Designations maintained by the Paradox Control Bureau. Integration proceeds at the discretion of the receiving office, which has not exercised it since 1411. The Bureau's filing practice has been the subject of prolonged rebuke. Its former secretary, Ovin Marrack, kept the P-alpha band in a locked cabinet to which he retained the only key after his retirement, and continued to attend the office three mornings a week for eleven years to retrieve it himself. The Bureau of Aperture Consistency recorded the cabinet as a vestibule in 1499 under a designation issued by the Bureau of Vestibule Nomenclature, on the ground that it was entered and left and had a number. The designation has not been withdrawn. Deliberations on the floor proceed by a rule that speakers describe the phenomenon and never the designation, so that no one becomes attached to a name. The rule was introduced after a designation acquired a partisan following and had to be retired. ## The Directivity Dispute The Bureau's principal doctrinal disagreement concerns whether a designation may describe a phenomenon's tendency, or must describe only its appearance. Third Concordance, Annex 2 holds that a designation "names what is seen, and nothing past it." Seventh Concordance, Annex 9 holds the opposite, that a designation "shall carry the tendency, or it shall mislead the next observer." The dispute crystallised in P-gamma-4: the Returning Rain, a phenomenon observed on Floor 172 between 1470 and 1487. The designation was amended four times to remove and restore the word returning, and the recorded recensions differ, so that later summaries of the case disagree about what the rain in fact did. The Bureau of Composite Designations has since been consulted and holds that the word Returning in the designation occupies the position of adjacency rather than description, which does not settle the matter. Office of Designation Harmonization has not ruled. The Bureau of Retained Designations would ordinarily absorb the disputed file, but that Bureau has not met since its reduction, and correspondence on the subject sits in the office of the Bureau of Volitional Acts. ## Later history Between 1502 and 1509 the Bureau undertook a review of all live designations under the Department of Metrical Harmony's programme of Phenomenological Inventory, and reported that of forty-nine designations then open, thirty-one named phenomena that had not been observed again and nine named phenomena that had never been observed at all. The report was received without comment and filed under P-alpha. In 1612 the Bureau was directed, under Clause 5, to state for each designation what would count as disconfirmation. It complied. For P-beta-2: the Slight Delay at the Turn of the Stair, the condition recorded is that a person descending the stair should arrive at the same time as a person descending beside them. The Bureau's clerk noted that this had happened twice, and appended a request for guidance that remains unanswered. The Bureau has issued no designations since 1644. It continues to hold its three weekly sessions and to receive reports. Visitors are asked not to name the phenomena they describe, and not to take the lift from Floor 219 while a designation is being read aloud.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Principal Register of Designations: what does it set out?

The Principal Register of Designations is the authoritative, non-circulating record of all Designation statuses, superseding all subsidiary indices and personal ledgers. Maintained in a dedicated vault on Floor 412 (the …

Principal Register of Designations
Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Phenomenological Inventory: how is it conducted?

Phenomenological Inventory refers to the complete, calibrated set of Phenomenological coefficients ascribed to a single non-existent subject within the Tower’s archives, following its passage through The Phenomenological…

Phenomenological Inventory

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.