The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Archive of Precedented Conclusions

MS 3987.02 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Archive of Precedented Conclusions is a holdings body of the Tower, distinct from but administratively adjacent to the Archive of Provisional Conclusions, and is the only archive in the vertical city whose accessions are required to have happened before. It occupies the western third of Floor 88, between the Aperture of Unspoken Conclusions and the service stair designated S-88-West, and reports upward, in the manner of all Floor 88 holdings, to the Archive of Provisional Holdings. Its founding instrument, Concordance 212, is dated to the winter of the year the Tower records as 3,118, though the floor number assigned to the archive at that time was not 88 and has since been reassigned twice.

The Archive's remit is narrow and absolute: it receives only conclusions that can be shown to have been reached already. A conclusion reached for the first time is not eligible. It may not be made eligible by waiting. Clerks unfamiliar with the archive's charter frequently attempt to redate a fresh conclusion to an earlier session and lodge it through the western intake; the intake returns these with a stamp reading NO PRECEDENT ESTABLISHED and a note of the calendar day on which the attempt was made.

Founding and the dispute over the third winter

The archive was established by the ruling of Ottoline Vesh, then of the Scriptorium of Prior Findings, following a dispute with the Bureau of Premature Conclusions that had run for eleven years. The Bureau argued that any conclusion, once written down, had in a defensible sense been reached before the ink dried, and was therefore precedented; Vesh held that this was a claim about language and not about the Tower, and prevailed.

The reckoning of the founding date remains contested. Concordance 212, Annex 4, fixes the founding to the year 3,118. Concordance 249, however, in its third recension, records that the archive was founded in the same winter but two years earlier, and adds that "the discrepancy is immaterial to the holdings and shall not be raised at intake" (§11). The discrepancy is raised at intake on average four times a year. A marginal note in the western ledger, in Vesh's hand, reads simply: "Both. Say no more of it." The note has the status of an ordinance by precedent of citation, and is cited roughly as often as either Concordance.

Method of accession

A candidate conclusion is presented to the archive in the form of a slate: a single sheet bearing the conclusion, the date it was first reached, and the floor on which it was first reached. Dating is checked against the Index of Unspoken Conclusions, which maintains a reverse register by floor, and against the Provisional Inference Ledger maintained on Floor 38-Delta-9. Where the two registers disagree, the Index governs for conclusions first reached above Floor 40 and the PIL governs below it — an arrangement set out in Concordance 331 and described by its own drafter as "regrettable but load-bearing."

Accepted slates are copied twice. One copy is shelved in the western stack in order of the date the conclusion was first reached; the other is shelved in order of the date it was presented. The two stacks have not agreed on an accession since 4,006, and the archive maintains both, having concluded that a single ordering would privilege one kind of precedence over the other. The western stack is closed to visitors on the first day of each month for dusting. Visitors are asked not to reshelve.

Relationship with neighbouring holdings

The archive shares a corridor with Buffer Sigma-7, which separates it from the Repository of Conditional Conclusions and beyond that the Archive of Unwritten Prefaces. Relations are formally correct and practically tense. The Prefaces hold material that has not been written; the Archive of Precedented Conclusions holds material that has not been duplicated; both consider the other to be doing, in a sense, nothing. The Hall of Postponed Conclusions has twice proposed a joint reading room, and both times the proposal was tabled by the archive on the ground that a joint room would be a new arrangement, and therefore without precedent.

The archive also maintains a standing easement through the Spire of Tacit Conclusions, granted in 3,140, allowing clerks to carry slates between the western stack and the Index without passing the Symphony of Unfinished Conclusions during rehearsal hours. The easement is not otherwise described in the Concordances and no one has been able to determine what precisely it obliges.

Notable holdings

The archive's most cited holding is Slate 14, the conclusion that the northern face of the Tower cannot be seen from the southern face, first reached on Floor 61 in 2,904 and presented to the archive in 3,201. It is cited in eleven Concordances and contradicted in four. A small permanent exhibition of six slates, drawn from the western stack, is mounted on the landing beside stair S-88-West; the sixth was added in 4,410 after a long dispute over whether a conclusion reached simultaneously on two floors could be said to have been reached before itself. The archive ruled that it could not, and then accessioned it anyway under a reservation recorded in the margin as "for the convenience of the stack." The reservation has since been cited in the Basement of Unspoken Conclusions and in the Bay of Receding Conclusions, and is the origin of the phrase convenience accession, now used across the Tower for any holding that has been adjudged ineligible and shelved regardless.

Clerks and the western intake

The archive has been served by a single line of intake clerks since 3,119, the post passing by nomination of the outgoing holder. The most recent, Clerk Amund Tress, held the post from 4,388 to 4,462 and is remembered for the memorandum of 4,401, in which he objected that the archive was being used as a place to put conclusions that other floors did not wish to defend, and that this was not what "precedented" meant. The memorandum was answered by the Archive of Provisional Holdings in one line, which Tress kept pinned above the western intake until his retirement: "The word is doing its work."

The intake desk is staffed from the second bell until the fourth, except on days when the western stack is being dusted.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Bay of Receding Conclusions: how is it conducted?

The Bay of Receding Conclusions is a specialized archival repository occupying the westernmost annex of Floor 5,712, established under the Ordinance for the Prevention of Premature Conclusions and formally designated the…

Bay of Receding Conclusions
Spire of Tacit Conclusions: what is it for?

The Spire of Tacit Conclusions is a tapered shaft of grey aggregate and iron, 41 storeys in height and 9 metres across at its base, raised against the northern face of the Archive of Provisional Conclusions on Floor 88 b…

Spire of Tacit Conclusions
Bureau of Premature Conclusions: who are they?

The Bureau of Premature Conclusions is a sub-entity of the Division of Terminal Verifications mandated by Ordinance 4 (the Ordinance for the Prevention of Premature Conclusions) to intercept, assess, and reroute conclusi…

Bureau of Premature Conclusions
Provisional Inference Ledger (PIL): what does it set out?

The Provisional Inference Ledger (PIL) is a bound register maintained on Floor 38-Delta-9 of the Archive of Provisional Conclusions, in which inferences that have been admitted to the archive but not yet assigned a perma…

Provisional Inference Ledger (PIL)

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.