The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Acoustic Consistency

MS 8612.10 · Practices and doctrines

Acoustic Consistency is the measure, and the enforcement of that measure, by which the sounds of a floor are held to correspond to the sounds that floor is recorded as having made. It is distinct from auditory consistency, which concerns whether a sound was heard as the class of sound it was entered under, and from acoustic regulation proper, which concerns whether a sound ought to have been made at all. The distinction is old and frequently mistaken. A sound may be perfectly consistent in acoustic terms and wholly irregular in auditory ones, or the reverse; the Office of Acoustic Consistency has maintained since its founding that the two failure modes are never to be entered on the same page, a house rule it traces to Concordance 3, Annex VII, clause 14, though clause 14 as recensed in the year 611 contains no such sentence and is widely held to have lost it.

The standard unit of acoustic consistency is the marlo, defined as the degree of correspondence between a recorded sound and its subsequent occurrence, scaled from zero to one. The scale is named for the practice set out in Marlo's tripartite rule, which the Office of Acoustic Consistency did not originate but has cited more often than its author's estate considers decent.

The scale and its keeper

Readings are taken with echo-sounding apparatus issued under seal by the Office of Acoustic Consistency, which calibrates each instrument against a reference tone sustained in the Sounding Gallery and re-attested every fourth winter. Instruments returned to the Office unsealed are recalibrated at the holder's cost and entered in the register with a note. The Office's standing instruction is that a marlo below 0.4 is to be reported, a marlo below 0.2 investigated, and a marlo below 0.05 referred upward without delay, though the instruction does not say upward to whom, and the Committee for Quantifiable Consistency has declined three times to clarify it.

The Office circulated an unofficial variant of the apparatus, the Mark VI-b, which judged sound at its fullest extent rather than at the point of first registration. The variant was never formally adopted, remains in use on at least nine floors, and produces readings that cannot be compared with readings from the sealed Mark VI. Clerks are instructed to note which instrument was used and to stop corresponding with anyone who does not.

Cross-phenomenal protocols

Where an acoustic anomaly is found to coincide with an anomaly of another class — a distortion of aperture, of chronology, or of name — the Office of Acoustic Consistency cedes immediate investigatory authority to the Office of Metaphysical Consistency for the duration of the cross-phenomenal protocol. Acoustic staff remain present as observers and are not permitted to speak during the handover. This provision was added after the winter of the seventh recension, when a sustained tone on a lower landing was claimed simultaneously by four offices and investigated concurrently by none. The tone has not recurred; the protocol has.

Disputes with the Office of Ceremonial Consistency over the consistency of ceremonial chants are adjudicated by a rotating Logic Auditor, appointed for a single case and dismissed thereafter. The Office of Acoustic Consistency records that it has won eleven of these disputes and lost none, a figure the Logic Auditors' own ledger gives as nine and two. Cataloguing has ruled that both ledgers may stand.

The record and its gaps

The Office keeps an inventory of persistent acoustic anomalies, of which the Thirteen Whispers of Floor 899 is the most cited and least explained. Entries are made in the order in which the sound was first attested, not in the order in which it was investigated, which produces a record that is internally consistent and chronologically useless. The Chamber of Chronological Consistency has objected; the objection is on file.

Not every investigation concludes. The Office of Acoustic Consistency maintains that this is a scandal, and says so in its annual return, in the same words, every year since the practice began. The Consistency of Absence holds the contrary view, that an unconcluded investigation is itself a consistent record of a sound that has not finished happening, and the two offices have agreed to disagree in writing rather than aloud. The Office has also found it prudent to distinguish its work from that of the Bureau of Aperture Consistency, whose holdings are regularly mistaken for its own at the annual collation, and from the Division of Temporal Consistency, whose recensions arrive, on occasion, before the events they describe.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal dispute in the field concerns the direction of the relation. The Office of Acoustic Consistency holds that a floor's sounds are consistent when they match the floor's record; the Department of Environmental Consistency holds that the record is consistent when it matches the sounds. The difference is not academic. Under the first reading, an anomalous sound is a fault in the sound. Under the second, it is a fault in the archive, and the archive is amended. The Self-Consistency Mandate was drafted to settle the matter and instead fixed the reading in force at the moment of drafting, which was the second, for a period of two hundred years or until the next full Formal Consistency Check, whichever came first. The Check has not been held. The Mandate's second reading therefore stands, and anomalous sounds continue to be amended out of the record rather than out of the floor.

"Where the sound and the entry disagree, the entry is to be corrected to the sound, and the correction noted in the margin as a correction of the entry and not of the sound."

— Self-Consistency Mandate, clause 3

A revisionist school, chiefly associated with the clerks of Onomastic Consistency, argues that both readings are consistent and that the disagreement is one of naming only — that "the sound of Floor X" and "the sound recorded for Floor X" denote the same object until an investigator arrives, at which point they cease to, and that this is a property of investigations and not of sounds. The argument is admired and has persuaded no office.

Practical notes

Visiting clerks are reminded that the Sounding Gallery is a working instrument and not a place of resort, that readings taken during the noon sounding are void, and that boots are to be removed at the threshold.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Chamber of Chronological Consistency: who are they?

The Chamber of Chronological Consistency is the principal collegiate body charged with the adjudication of internal temporal paradoxes within the archival holdings of the Tower, operating under the authority of the Depar…

Chamber of Chronological Consistency
Bureau of Aperture Consistency: who are they?

The Bureau of Aperture Consistency is an office of the Librarians situated within Spiral 9, charged with ensuring that designations applied to apertures are applied uniformly across all linked spirals. Its founding instr…

Bureau of Aperture Consistency
Division of Temporal Consistency: who are they?

The Division of Temporal Consistency (DTC) is the primary regulatory body charged under the Third Concordance with ensuring all internal processes, cataloguing durations, and perceived flows of time adhere to Temporally …

Division of Temporal Consistency
Concordance 3: what does it set out?

Concordance 3, formally the Third Instrument of Concordance, is a foundational legal document governing administrative procedures for floors numbered between 14 and 47, inclusive. It is most notable for being the first C…

Concordance 3

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.