The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Verification of Non-Collisions

MS 0677.39 · Practices and doctrines

The Verification of Non-Collisions is the procedure by which the Tower certifies that two holdings, bodies, or floor-designations which resemble one another sufficiently to alarm a reader have in fact never touched, overlapped, or been mistaken for each other in any register. It is distinct from Ontic Verification, which concerns whether a thing exists, and from Verification of Absence, which concerns whether it has stopped. The Verification of Non-Collisions concerns only the negative relation: the certified proof that the resemblance between two entities is a resemblance and nothing further. The procedure is administered jointly by the Department of Contradictory Citations and the Office of Spatial Reconciliation, though each maintains that the other holds the seal.

Origin and jurisdiction

The procedure was first set down in the wake of the Precedence Edict Protocol, compiled by the Directorate of Institutional Collisions after the considerable disorder of the 4,108th recension, when the office formerly styled the Bureau of Like-Named Things was found to have been issuing certificates of distinctness to entities that were, on inspection, the same entity listed twice by different clerks. The resulting scandal — Floor 14,201 still keeps the ledger — produced the Third Concordance, Annex 9, which established that distinctness is not presumed but is to be demonstrated:

"No two holdings shall be held apart unless an officer of the Tower has walked between them and returned with a note."

— Third Concordance, Annex 9, clause 4

The wording of "walked between them" has been the subject of no fewer than forty-four interpretive rulings, of which Verification Ruling 4117-γ remains the most cited and the least obeyed. That ruling held that the walking need not be literal provided the officer's route is recorded in the same ink throughout. Subsequent practice has drifted toward the literal.

The three certificates

A completed Verification of Non-Collisions issues one of three certificates, each bearing the three-letter suffix generated by the Infinite Stamp when the residual identifier of either party has previously been used:

  • Certificate Alpha — the parties are distinct and have never met in any register.
  • Certificate Beta — the parties are distinct, but have met once, inconclusively, and the meeting has been struck from both registers.
  • Certificate Gamma — the parties are distinct under Contextual Reading, but would not be under any other reading, and the certificate is therefore valid only on the floor on which it was issued.

Certificates Alpha and Beta are transferable between floors by courier. Certificate Gamma is not, and on three recorded occasions a Gamma carried upward has been read as an accusation of Taxonomic Collapse and its bearer detained by the Verification Cadres until the ink faded. The Cadres have declined to apologise, noting in their defence that the bearer had, in fact, collapsed two taxonomies on the stairwell.

Procedure

The verifying officer — drawn from the roster maintained under Procedural Verification — begins by laying both registers side by side and marking every point at which the two parties are described in identical terms. These marks are the points of alarm. A party with fewer than three points of alarm is exempt from the procedure entirely and may be certified by post. A party with more than thirty must be the subject of a full Catalogical Verification Process, since a resemblance that dense is treated, provisionally, as a confession.

Between those limits the officer proceeds through the Calibration Vaults to compare the fingerprints the two parties have left on the doorframes of their respective floors. Fingerprints that differ are conclusive. Fingerprints that agree are not, because the Vaults are cold and the ink behaves badly there; in such cases the officer must return and count the parties again, which is where most of the delay in the procedure originates. A recent amendment requires that officers not count after the fifteenth hour of a shift, following the so-called Long Afternoon, in which a single clerk on Floor 14,201 counted a holding as two, then as none, then certified all three.

Points of scholarly disagreement

The principal dispute concerns whether the Verification of Non-Collisions can ever be completed for parties that share a name. The Doctrine of Coincidental Names holds that shared names are, by their nature, coincidental and require no further proof of distinctness. Against this, the Taxonomic Purist School maintains that a coincidence is itself a collision of a subtle kind, and that every Verification of Non-Collisions performed on like-named parties has been "a certificate of the fog describing the fog" (as the School's petition of 6,162 puts it). The Causal Verification Bureau has twice attempted to settle the matter by voiding the disputed audits under the third Precept; both voidings were themselves voided, the Bureau having failed to observe the third Precept in the act of invoking it. The matter is currently before the Office of Ontic Verification, which has asked for time.

A lesser dispute concerns the status of Implied Fauna. Two parties may be certified distinct while the space between them is found to be inhabited, and it is unresolved whether the inhabitants count as a third party requiring its own certificate. The standing instruction of the Office of Spatial Reconciliation is that the inhabitants are to be asked to move, firmly, and that if they decline the matter is to be recorded as an implied holding and left for the next recension.

Records held

Completed certificates are held in the annex beneath Master Index of Non-Sequential Gaps, indexed not by party but by the distance walked between them, in paces, rounded down. Certificates for parties found to occupy the same floor are stored separately in a locked cabinet. The cabinet has no key. Inquiring officers are advised that the cabinet is not to be forced, and that any officer who forces it must obtain a Sigil of Passage before descending, which is issued on the floor above.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Master Index of Non-Sequential Gaps: how is it conducted?

The Master Index of Non-Sequential Gaps is the primary instrument for registering Taxonomic Gaps, maintained in perpetuity by the Verification Cadres of Division III. It is a bound register, presently in its two hundred …

Master Index of Non-Sequential Gaps
Contextual Reading: how is it conducted?

Contextual Reading is the regulated practice by which a subject catalogued in the Tower is consulted in accordance with its established framing, as determined by the Division of Contextual Anchoring (DCA) and the offices…

Contextual Reading
Calibration Vaults: what is it for?

Calibration Vaults are high-purity, non-resonant chambers designated for the verification and alignment of primary measurement artifacts and standards used throughout the Metrological Vaults and affiliated domains. They …

Calibration Vaults
Doctrine of Coincidental Names: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine of Coincidental Names is a foundational principle of Librarian taxonomy, codified in the Third Concordance, which asserts that shared designations between distinct holdings or entities within The Tower imply…

Doctrine of Coincidental Names

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.