The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Vaelen

MS 3670.15 · Persons

Vaelen is the designation used in the Tower's registers for the Traditionalist theorist who led the faction opposed to the issuance of the Resolution of the Redundant Gate, and who is chiefly remembered thereafter not for the position he took but for the manner in which he lost it. The name appears without a forename in every recension of the episode, and the Librarians have declined on four separate occasions to supply one, on the grounds that no floor has produced an instrument bearing it.

Vaelen's standing in the archive rests on a single procedural achievement. He is the only recorded traditionalist to have his dissent entered into the register of the Resolution of the Redundant Gate on the day of issue without having drafted a document of his own.

The objection to the Resolution

The Resolution of the Redundant Gate provided that the Contest of the Redundant Gate should be heard once, and that the record of that hearing should stand in place of every subsequent hearing. Vaelen's faction advanced the argument that a resolution abolishing repeated hearings was itself a repetition — that the Resolution said again, in a grander voice, what every prior hearing had already said — and that it therefore fell under its own exclusion and could not be issued.

The Axiomatic School received this argument at 77,402 on the eighth day of the second sitting and returned it the same afternoon, unread, with the notation that paradoxes of self-application were a matter for the Hall of Unresolved Syllogisms and not for a hearing on the merits. Vaelen's memorandum of protest against the return survives only in fragment, but its opening is quoted in the Intentionalist School's commentary on the dispute: "An instrument that survives only because no one read it has not survived but merely remained."

The opposition of the schools

The episode is the standard illustration, in the Intercalary School's primer, of how a dispute between schools is settled by arithmetic rather than argument. Vaelen's Traditionalist School held that the Resolution must be read against the body of prior practice. The Literalist School held that it must be read alone, and that prior practice had been abolished by the Resolution's first clause. Neither school could claim a majority in the chamber, and under Edict 212 the question went to the mediation bench with the figure of the prior hearings appended as a schedule.

The schedule ran to two hundred and eleven entries. The bench observed that the two hundred and twelfth hearing — the one Vaelen contended could not lawfully be held — would be held. It was. Vaelen did not attend it, and sent instead a note of two lines that is preserved in the Pursuit of Specific Holdings as an example of a document filed without a proper object.

The winter on Floor 17,114

Following the issue of the Resolution, Vaelen withdrew to Floor 17,114, a floor whose name is disputed and whose spiral is not. He remained there through the winter of that year, receiving the delegation of the Traditionalist School on three occasions and refusing a fourth. The floor's stokers' complaint of that winter — filed in the ordinary course and not otherwise remarkable — records that the delegation's lamps were drawn from the floor's stores and that Vaelen declined to sign for them.

Whatever passed at the three meetings is not in the record. The school's own minute-book for that quarter survives with the relevant leaves excised, and the excision is neat, which the Librarians have taken as evidence of authorisation rather than concealment.

The attribution question

Scholars disagree about what Vaelen actually wrote. The Axiomatic School maintains, in its recension of the episode, that the memorandum of protest is the work of Vaelen's scribe and that the fragment's temper is not his — it cites the Ninth Concordance, clause 404, which provides that no document may be attributed to a party who did not sign for it, and observes that the fragment bears no signature.

The Intentionalist School replies that clause 404 is directed at documents tendered in evidence before a hearing and has nothing to say about commentary written after one. The Intercalary School, for its part, refuses the question altogether, on the ground that the author of a dissent is the dissent, and that the register already records it under his name.

"The attribution of a lost memorandum is a matter for the memorandum, which is not present and cannot be asked."

— Intercalary School, Primer, Section 9

Later standing

Vaelen is cited in Post-Resolution Monitoring returns as the origin of the "redundancy objection," a standing form of words now used by any party wishing to contest an instrument on the ground that it repeats itself. The form is available at any floor's registry counter and requires no supporting document. Some three thousand such objections were lodged in the first year alone; none has been upheld, and the Librarians have declined to amend the form.

The chamber in which Vaelen lodged his memorandum at 77,402 is presently closed for the relaying of its stair. The memorandum was returned there and has not been moved.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Traditionalist School: how is it conducted?

The Traditionalist School is a major philosophical and administrative movement within the Tower's hermeneutic community, dedicated to the primacy of established procedure and the inherent authority of the Concordances as…

Traditionalist School
Ninth Concordanceclause 404: how is it conducted?

Ninth Concordance, Clause 404 is a decommissioned stipulation of the Ninth Concordance pertaining to the ontological classification of procedural appendices rendered redundant by subsequent legislation. Its primary funct…

Ninth Concordanceclause 404
Post-Resolution Monitoring: how is it conducted?

The term Post-Resolution Monitoring refers to the administrative and observatory protocols enacted within the Tower following the formal conclusion of a Resolution Drafting process. It encompasses the systematic vigilanc…

Post-Resolution Monitoring
Axiomatic School: how is it conducted?

The Axiomatic School is one of the primary schools of thought within the Tower's administrative and hermeneutic traditions. It holds that the Axiomatic Foundation—the set of core statements in the Second Concordance from…

Axiomatic School

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.