Unwritten Book
MS 6131.95 · Practices and doctrines
The Unwritten Book is a class of holding recognised by the Tower since at least the ninth recension of the shelving ordinances, defined under Concordance 117, Article 3 as a volume that has been classified, coded, cross-referenced and assigned a floor, but of which no copy exists. An Unwritten Book is not a lost book, nor a book destroyed, nor a book merely unread; it is a book that the catalogue asserts and the shelves do not. The distinction is administrative rather than metaphysical, and the Tower has always treated it as the more serious of the two.
Definition and classification
Concordance 117 sets out the definitive criteria in three parts: that the volume be named in at least one extant document; that it be assigned a trinomial code by the Register of Unwritten Volumes; and that no copy stand on any floor between the Aperture floors and the lowest recorded landing. All three must obtain. Volumes failing the third criterion alone are reclassified as misplaced, a lesser category with its own paperwork.
The class is bounded on one side by the Non Book, which fails the first criterion and is therefore not a book at all, and on the other by the Unwritten Page, which is a fragment of a named volume and is filed under its parent code rather than its own. Between these boundaries the Unwritten Books form the largest single body of entries in the Unwritten Index, though the Index declines to state how large.
The Precept and the registration hearing
The operative rule is the Precept of Unwritten Catalogues: a book referenced is a book extant. The Precept is old, undated, and universally applied, and it was under the Precept that the source volume of Echo-770-Gamma-ω was treated as extant on the strength of its reference alone. In practice the Precept means that once an Unwritten Book has accumulated sufficient citation mass — that is, once enough other documents cite it that its absence becomes an inconvenience to the archive rather than a feature of it — a registration hearing is initiated by the Secretariat for Unwritten Protocols. The hearing does not produce a copy. It produces a finding that a copy is unnecessary, which is then entered in the Register and thereafter cited as though it were the volume itself.
The Archivists of the Unwritten maintain the working files for these hearings; the Censors of the Unwritten Word review them and, in the ordinary course, strike anything the hearing has inadvertently written down. The two offices have not spoken formally since the winter of Floor 1,104.
Scholarly disagreement
There is a long-running dispute as to whether an Unwritten Book may be said to have contents. The strict school, citing Concordance 117 in its original recension, holds that a volume without a copy has no text and that any description of its subject matter is a description of its citations and nothing more. The permissive school, citing the Precept as amended in the twelfth recension, holds that a book referenced is a book extant, and therefore that whatever is referenced is in it.
"The question is not what the volume says. The question is what may be quoted from it, and by whom, and under what seal."
— Archivist-Loremaster Valerius, marginal note to Register folio 4,412
The dispute flared badly in the matter of The Unwritten Concordance, whose contents were quoted in three separate rulings before anyone observed that the quotations did not agree. The Lost Chapter of the Unwritten Concordance is the residue of that observation. It is not clear whether the Lost Chapter was lost from the volume or from the citations of it; the two are now kept together.
A related disagreement concerns the blank reason column in the day-book of Curator Althea, which the Curator of Unwritten Reasons has petitioned to fill on the ground that a reason not written down is a reason unnoted, and a reason unnoted is an Unwritten Reason, and an Unwritten Reason is extant. The petition has been pending since the fourth recension. It is the oldest pending petition in the Secretariat and is cited in the training of new archivists as an example of correct patience.
Storage and handling
Unwritten Books are shelved. This is the part of the practice that visitors find least credible and the Tower finds least remarkable. A shelf-mark is cut for the volume, a press-board docket is set against the wall at the correct position, and the space between the dockets is kept clear. The clear space is dusted on the ordinary rota. Nothing is placed in it, including, by a standing instruction of the Floor Stewards issued after the incident of the borrowed atlas, other books.
Handling procedure requires that an Unwritten Book be carried with both hands, as an ordinary volume would be, and returned to its shelf-mark before the end of the shift. The Book of Returns governs what comes back; the Book of Instruments governs what may be used to carry it, and permits a sling, a strap, or the bare hands; the Book of Status governs who may be recorded as having carried it. None of the three books addresses the case of a volume that is not there, and the omission has never been corrected, on the ground that correcting it would require naming the volume in the correction.
The Codex question
The Codex is arranged in three books — the Book of Instruments, the Book of Status, and the Book of Returns — and is distinguished throughout from Book IV — Penalties, which concerns what is done when something has gone wrong. It is a frequent error among junior archivists to suppose that an Unwritten Book, being absent, has gone wrong. It has not. Absence is its correct condition, and a volume found on its shelf-mark and not expected there is a matter for the Stewards, not for Penalties.
For the same reason the arrangement of The Unburdened Step — the Book of Lifting, the Book of Placing, the Book of Forgetting, and an appendix of forms — is considered instructive rather than applicable. The Book of Forgetting is read aloud at registration hearings. The appendix of forms is not used, as there is nothing to sign.
Unwritten Books are not to be removed from the Tower. This is enforced by the ordinary means.
See also
-
MS 1274.94
The Unwritten Index
The Unwritten Index is the location on Floor 11,407-beta at which the Schism of the Unwritten Index is physically sited, and the s…
-
MS 3093.54
Cross-Referenced Appeal
The Cross-Referenced Appeal is the formal instrument by which a petitioner invokes evidence or precedent drawn from two or more no…
-
MS 9065.07
Lost Concordance Faction
The Lost Concordance Faction was a temporary administrative body convened from 892–899 A.S. (After Shelving) to adjudicate the sta…
-
MS 0690.91
The Archive of Unwritten Prefaces
The Archive of Unwritten Prefaces is a classified doctrinal repository and interdimensional annex located on Sub-Level 909-A, admi…
-
MS 3023.07
The Gallery of Unwritten Prefaces
The Gallery of Unwritten Prefaces is a principal location for the collection, stabilization, and preliminary analysis of materials…
-
MS 2855.88
Forms R-1 through R-70
Forms R-1 through R-70 are a classified sequence of seventy archival instruments ratified on Floor 412 during the Winter Recension…
Referenced by
- MS 2601.07 Unwritten Books
- MS 8270.42 Article 5
Readers also asked
Non Book: how is it conducted?
Non Book is the catalogical designation for any volume entered in the Tower's holdings that, by the finding of the Book of Status, is held to possess no leaves, no script, and no bound edge, yet remains subject to the pr…
Non BookCurator of Unwritten Reasons: who are they?
Curator of Unwritten Reasons is an administrative and curatorial title within the Archivists’ Spire responsible for the classification, provisional cataloguing, and metaphysical containment of reasons for actions that ha…
Curator of Unwritten ReasonsRegister of Unwritten Volumes: what does it set out?
The Register of Unwritten Volumes (RUV) is the primary ledger of the Department of Latent Epistemology, located on Floor 451. It is the definitive catalogue of all books whose existence has been conclusively established …
Register of Unwritten VolumesThe Unburdened Step: what does it set out?
The Unburdened Step is a codex of the Pragmatists' League, held in twelve working recensions and one disputed fair copy, to which all practitioners of the League's peripatetic disciplines are required to pledge adherence…
The Unburdened StepPassages cited from this record
-
The question is not what the volume says. The question is what may be quoted from it, and by whom, and under what seal.
Archivist-Loremaster Valerius, marginal note to Register folio 4,412
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 1420.45 Concordance 117, Article 3
- MS 1009.13 Book of Instruments
- MS 5764.72 Book of Status
- MS 9856.44 Book of Returns
Because you consulted