The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Unsummation Doctrine

MS 4034.12 · Practices and doctrines

The Unsummation Doctrine is a procedural doctrine governing the treatment of objects whose properties cannot be totalled. It holds that certain artifacts exist in a state of "procedural potentiality," in which measurement samples rather than collapses their state: a thing measured on Thursday may be measured again on Friday and yield a different figure without any intervening event having occurred. Proposed by the clerk Gareth of the Ninth Ledger in the winter of the floor numbered 112, the doctrine was condemned twice, formally suspended once, and is presently in force. Its authoritative statement is the Treatise on Potential Quantification, assembled posthumously from Gareth's working notes by the Scriptorium of Deferred Accounts.

Origins on Floor 112

Gareth's difficulty was a counting-room problem before it was a philosophical one. The floor inventory of 112 included forty-one crates of a grey alloy that resisted tally. Each crate weighed, on successive weighings, 12.4, 12.4, 11.9, and 12.4 stone, and the crate itself had not been opened. Gareth's initial response was to schedule the weighing four times and record the reconciling figure, a procedure the Board of Weights and Reconciliations disallowed in a ruling of the following spring. The note accompanying the ruling is often quoted:

"A number obtained by discarding three honest measurements in favour of a fourth is not a measurement. It is a preference. The Board has no authority to license preferences, and cannot afford them."

— Board of Weights and Reconciliations, Ruling 112/9, annex 2

Gareth accepted the point and reversed his reasoning. If the measurements were honest, he argued, then the object's weight was not a fixed quantity that the inventory had failed to capture; it was a range that the inventory had, in fact, captured correctly on every occasion. The failure lay not in the scale but in the assumption that a scale closes a question. On this reading the grey alloy was not badly catalogued. It was unsummed — a term Gareth coined in a marginal note and never defended in writing.

The Treatise and its recensions

The Treatise on Potential Quantification appeared in the year following Gareth's death, in three recensions over eleven years. The Second Recension, which is the one cited in practice, sets out the doctrine's central distinction: between an object's ledger value, which is whatever the most recent valid measurement returned, and its procedural potentiality, which is the range within which valid measurement may legitimately return. Only the first may be entered in a tally. The second belongs in the margin, in a notation the Treatise calls the bracket, and may not be summed, averaged, or carried forward.

The Third Recension added the constraint for which the doctrine is now best known: that a prospective measurement may not be designed with a preferred outcome in view. Gareth's original apparatus — four weighings, then a preference — is precisely what the Third Recension forbids. The Doctrine of Incompletability is often invoked alongside this passage, though the Treatise itself declines to say whether unsummability is a species of incompletability or merely mistaken for one by careless readers.

Doctrinal dispute

Opposition formed almost immediately, and from a direction Gareth had not anticipated. The Alpha Purists, a body of certifying clerks who hold that every artifact carries exactly one true ledger value and that any failure to produce it is a failure of method, condemned the doctrine in the Alpha Purist Assize of the following decade as heretical. Their position is stated without qualification in the Assize:

"An object that will not weigh is not an object in potential. It is an object badly weighed. The doctrine inverts the order of correction, excusing the balance by slandering the stone."

— Alpha Purist Assize of the ninth session, article 3

The Purist objection has never been answered to their satisfaction, largely because it cannot be tested: the grey alloy of floor 112 was consumed in a fire in the Lower Bracket Storerooms in the same year, and no replacement stock has been located. Purists argue that this is convenient. Practitioners argue that the fire is simply the strongest available demonstration of the doctrine, since the crates' weight is now recorded in four honest figures and no others.

A second dispute runs within the doctrine's own supporters. The Doctrine of Implicit Containment would treat procedural potentiality as a property of the object, contained within it and disclosed by measurement; the Doctrine of Implicit Resolution would treat it as a property of the record, an observable consequence of the order in which measurements were taken. Both are cited in the Treatise as equally acceptable readings, a latitude the Librarians have never resolved. The Doctrine of Anticipatory Resonance was devised to bridge the two and has instead become a third position.

Administration in practice

The doctrine is administered by the Office of Marginal Notation, established for the purpose in the year after the Assize. The Office rules on which objects may be bracketed and which must be reduced to a single ledger value before certification. Its determinations are recorded in a register that is itself bracketed as to its own length, a matter raised by the Doctrine of Sufficient Paperwork and quietly dropped.

The Office's guidance is not written as procedure but has settled through casework. A stair railing on the floor numbered 340, whose length returned three different measures over a single afternoon, was granted a permanent bracket; a consignment of sealed inkwells on floor 87 was refused one on the grounds that their variation was traceable to a broken hinge, and that the bracket exists to accommodate objects, not maintenance failures. In the second case the Office noted only that the hinge was replaced and the figures settled. Certification of bracketed objects proceeds under the Doctrine of Imperfect Certification, which has grown a substantial and highly technical literature on how one certifies an object whose recorded properties do not agree.

Bracketed objects may be lent to other floors. The borrowing floor is required to return the object along with a fresh measurement, on pain of the loan being converted to an annexation under the Vell Doctrine.

Relation to other doctrines

During Textual Alignment, the doctrine is consulted chiefly by way of the Doctrine of Coincidental Preservation, which determines which of an object's recorded measurements survives alignment with a later register. Its operation alongside the Doctrine of Administrative Silence is common and uneasy: an object measured and then left unmeasured for eleven years may acquire a potentiality that no living clerk has verified. The Doctrine of Unstable Foundations is often confused with the Unsummation Doctrine by junior cataloguers, and the confusion is correctable by the simple test of whether the object has been weighed at all.

The doctrine's most persistent difficulty is not philosophical but clerical. Brackets are entered in the margin, and margins are trimmed at rebinding. The Office of Marginal Notation maintains that no bracket has ever been lost, and the rebinding register of floor 112 records one that was.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Doctrine of Implicit Containment: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine of Implicit Containment is a legal-theoretical framework within the Codicils of Containment which posits that certain phenomena are fundamentally and irrevocably contained by the act of their designation and…

Doctrine of Implicit Containment
Textual Alignment: how is it conducted?

Textual Alignment is the standardized, post-hoc calibration of newly discovered information to fit the existing catalogic descriptors of an archived subject. Governed by Principle of Textual Immanence, the practice is th…

Textual Alignment
Alpha Purists: how is it conducted?

The Alpha Purists are a sub-faction of the Purist Faction whose central doctrine holds that any formal system of designation, classification, or procedure must originate from and recursively reference a singular, axiomat…

Alpha Purists
Doctrine of Anticipatory Resonance: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine of Anticipatory Resonance is a practice-doctrine of the Anticipatory School governing the procedure by which Proemists attempt to match orphaned prefaces to main texts not yet received, not yet written, or n…

Doctrine of Anticipatory Resonance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.