The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Twelfth Revision Concordance

MS 6246.75 · Documents and ordinances

The Twelfth Revision Concordance is the master instrument of the Seventh-Spiral Registry, enacted on the 3rd day of the Second Spiral, 781, and since amended in a manner no single office has ever agreed to describe in the same way twice. Its scope is the Registry itself: the winding and reading of seventh-spiral holdings, the credentials of the spirallers who perform both, and the reconciliation of the Registry's floor-ledgers with the Annex of Perpetual Revision. It should not be confused with the Twelfth Concordance, an instrument of entirely separate origin and partly overlapping numbering, nor with the Twelfth Citing Concordance, which cites this document more often than it cites any other and has never once cited it correctly in full.

Enactment and Schedule

The Concordance was enacted in eleven chapters. The original vellum carries each chapter heading in the same hand, and the same hand in the margin beside each heading a small numeral that no later reader has been able to correlate with anything. Scribes of the Fourth Corridor reproduce the numerals out of piety. The Bureau of Perpetual Revision has ruled twice (Opinion 331, then Opinion 331 bis) that they are decorative and once (Opinion 339) that they are not.

Chapter IX, the schedules, has been abolished and restored fourteen times. At present it is restored but suspended, which is to say that the schedules continue to be consulted while no party is permitted to claim they are in force. Clerk Hestram has argued in an unpublished minute that this arrangement persists because no one wishes to be the clerk who abolished the schedules a fifteenth time.

The Ambiguous Calipers

The Concordance's most-cited provision is its standardization of the Ambiguous Calipers, instruments whose jaws may be read as either of two measures and which return different readings on successive application without ever appearing to move. Chapter IV fixed the calipers' tolerances, their storage (wrapped, oiled, and laid north-south), and the formula by which a disputed reading is to be averaged. The formula was amended in 789 after the Averaging Incident on Floor 2,208, in which a caliper dispute was resolved by averaging and the mean proved to belong to no scale in use anywhere in the Tower. Auxillary Pendulum observers were called in to adjudicate. Their finding — that the mean had been "correct, but in the wrong direction" (Pendulum Report 41) — was accepted by all parties and understood by none.

Calipers are not to be carried on the moving stairs. The prohibition appears in Chapter IV, note 3, without explanation, and is enforced by the porters of the Second Spiral with a consistency the Concordance itself does not enjoy.

Clause 7.9 and the Question of Ash

Clause 7.9 is the ash-rendering provision: an archival act is complete only when its administrative shadow has been rendered to ash. The Concordance does not define the administrative shadow, and three successive recensions have declined to define it on the ground that definition would itself require a shadow. The Twelfth Concordance retains the clause in identical words, so that both instruments now supply the same rule and neither supplies a meaning for it.

In practice the clause is discharged at the Ash Terrace on Floor 704, where the shadow of each monthly return is burned before witnesses. The terrace accepts returns on every day the bell is rung before noon. Returns arriving after the bell are held overnight and burned with the following day's, and their clerks are recorded as late and do not dispute it.

Relationship to the Third Revision

Much of the Concordance's present administrative life consists of its relationship to its own successor. The Twelfth Concordance supersedes the earlier text in all matters except those reserved to Section 17, which the Revision left untouched and which remains the most litigated article in the Registry. The Revision was ratified on the 14th day of the Fourth Spiral, 806, by a vote of eleven to four with two abstentions. Clerk Hestram observed at the time that the ratification was "irregular in form though not in effect." The remark was entered in the Concordance of Lingering Impressions Third Revision Spiral 22, where it has since been cited forty-one times and overruled never.

Contradiction Among the Revisions

The principal scholarly dispute concerns which text governs. Seventh Concordance, Revision 12 supersedes Seventh Concordance, Revision 4, and by an argument advanced at the Collation of 812 and never answered, does so in a manner that also supersedes the schedules of the Twelfth Revision Concordance, which had purported to supersede the Seventh. The Registry's answer is that a Concordance cannot be superseded by a document younger than itself. The Bureau's answer is that it can, provided the superseding document is amended first. Neither answer has been entered as an Opinion, since the Bureau has learned what happens when it enters Opinions about itself.

The reading room keeps three copies of the Concordance: the enacted vellum, a working copy annotated by four generations of clerks, and a clean copy that is not to be written in. The third copy is the only one anyone is permitted to read aloud in session. It differs from the vellum in eleven places. The Librarians regard this as an ordinary property of clean copies.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Twelfth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Twelfth Concordance is a core administrative document governing the classification and containment of subjects possessing non-Euclidean properties, the reconciliation of dimensional anomalies, and the protocols for L…

Twelfth Concordance
Ambiguous Calipers: what is it for?

Ambiguous Calipers are a class of precision instrument, standardized under the Twelfth Concordance, designed to provide multiple, often mutually exclusive, measurements of a single object. Their primary function is not t…

Ambiguous Calipers
Bureau of Perpetual Revision: who are they?

The Bureau of Perpetual Revision is the primary operational and procedural body responsible for the administration of all revisions to the Concordances and their ancillary texts. It is a sub-bureau of the Office of Perpe…

Bureau of Perpetual Revision
Seventh-Spiral Registry: who are they?

The Seventh-Spiral Registry is the primary administrative ledger, reference document, and procedural body responsible for the documentation of all phenomena and entities classified under the seventh-spiral designation. W…

Seventh-Spiral Registry

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.