The Quantifiers
MS 5378.08 · Guilds, orders and offices
Definition
The Quantifiers is a term of art in wide administrative use, denoting the members, practices, and instrumental apparatus associated with the Guild of Quantifiers. Strictly, the Tower recognizes only the Guild as a legal person; "the Quantifiers" appears in Concordial writing as an informal collective for the guildsmen, their journeymen, the attendants of Floor 117, and — less consistently — the measuring implements housed in The Calibrated Atrium. The looseness of the designation has been the origin of several prolonged disputes, most of them concerning who may seal a frame and who may merely hold the rule.
The term is not to be confused with the phrase "those who quantify," which appears in a marginal gloss to the Third Concordance and denotes a class of itinerant surveyors disestablished in an unnamed winter.
Scope of the designation
Usage across the Tower varies by floor. In the scriptoria adjacent to the Bureau of Perpetual Revision, "the Quantifiers" is taken to mean the Guild's senior fellows alone, on the grounds that only a fellow may append a number to a recension. In the workshops of the School of Perpetual Potentiality, the same phrase is understood to include any hand that has ever held a gauge, a position maintained with some heat by the School's Primes. The Eleventh Librarian is recorded as having ruled on the matter in passing, without recording which way the ruling fell.
The Guild itself is unfussy in public and precise in writing. Its circulars are addressed to "Quantifiers" when the instruction concerns measurement and to "the Guild of Quantifiers" when the instruction concerns money. Two of the nine recognized Concordial Guilds have objected to this on procedural grounds, and the objection is recorded under Annex Kappa as unresolved.
Historical development
The first recorded use of the bare plural dates to the early calibration of the Silent Expansion, when the Guild's founders found it tedious to write "members of the Guild of Quantifiers" in the margins of every gauge-book. The abbreviation spread faster than the Guild could police it. By the drafting of the Sixth Concordance, the term had acquired enough independent weight that Clause 81, Annex Epsilon was required to state explicitly that "Quantifiers" and "the Guild of Quantifiers" denote one and the same body for the purposes of chartered work.
The instrument-makers were a later addition. Their incorporation under the plural is generally attributed to a shortage of fellows during the winter of the Third Survey, when the Calibrated Atrium was short-staffed and the Guild chose to describe the assistants as Quantifiers rather than admit the gap in its rolls. The roll of assistants has never been formally merged with the roll of fellows, and the two remain distinct documents held in different cabinets on Floor 117.
A recurring difficulty concerns jurisdiction over the Presumption of Completeness (Cartographic). Because the Presumption is both a doctrine and a seal, the question of whether the "Quantifiers" who apply it are acting as guildsmen or as administrators of the practical side of the Doctrine of Completeness has produced at least three Concordial readings. The readings are numbered, and none of them agree.
Instruments and standing
Among guildsmen, the plural is also used, with no stated irony, to denote the standard gauges themselves. A "Quantifier" in the instrumental sense is a brass rule of fixed length bearing the Guild's counterseal; the phrase appears in workshop inventories alongside human names without distinction of category. Visitors to the Calibrated Atrium are asked not to lean on the instruments, whether or not they are also guildsmen.
Standing under the plural is graded by proximity to the register of frames. Those whose names appear in the register may settle a measurement dispute by fiat; those who hold only a gauge-book may settle it by appeal. The distinction matters most in Discrepancy Resolution proceedings, where the difference between a fiat and an appeal is the difference between a resolved frame and a matter referred onward. Annex Kappa governs this procedure for the Guild, and Annex Γ has been cited in opposition to it, to inconclusive effect.
Disputed readings
The principal scholarly disagreement concerns the definite article. One recension of the Third Concordance, Section IX — the one held by the Guild of Quantifiers — reads "the Quantifiers shall maintain," while the Warden's recension of the same section reads "Quantifiers shall maintain," dropping the article. The Guild holds that the article is a term of office, restricting the duty to chartered members; the Warden holds that its absence generalizes the duty to any who measure. The phrase differing between the two recensions is one, and it has been the subject of eleven recorded hearings.
A secondary dispute, older and quieter, concerns whether the plural is singular or collective in matters of fine. The Office of Perpetual Affairs has twice assessed a penalty against "the Quantifiers" and twice been required to specify which individual was meant. Both assessments remain listed as Pending Resolution, and both have accrued fees.
Usage on the outer floors tends to be looser still: "the Quantifiers" is applied there to anyone who offers a number with confidence, a habit the Guild deprecates in its annual notice and has never succeeded in discouraging.
See also
-
MS 4142.07
Secondary Instrumental
The Secondary Instrumental is a class of certified measuring apparatus defined in Annex of Calibrated Entities as any physical art…
-
MS 8691.69
Jurisdictional Fluidity
Jurisdictional Fluidity refers to the doctrinal principle, and its associated administrative practices, that the jurisdictional bo…
-
MS 9314.04
Tertiary Clerk
Tertiary Clerk is a mid-level administrative rank within the Librarian Corps of the Tower, denoting a specialist responsible for m…
-
MS 6522.25
Instrumental Transience
Instrumental Transience is the certified condition of an Instrumental whose measured properties remain valid but no longer obtain …
-
MS 3254.16
Guilds of the Towerguild of Quantifiers
The Guild of Quantifiers is one of the nine recognized Concordial Guilds responsible for the procedural maintenance and calibratio…
-
MS 8877.84
Provisional Tagging
Provisional Tagging is the subset of Ontological Tagging practices used to apply metadata denoting the conditional, contested, or …
Referenced by
- MS 6633.38 School of Perpetual Potentiality
Readers also asked
Eleventh Librarian: who were they?
The Eleventh Librarian is the official, collective designation for the unnamed individual or individuals who served as Librarian during the period of governance under which the Eleventh Concordance was drafted and ratifi…
Eleventh LibrarianBureau of Perpetual Revision: who are they?
The Bureau of Perpetual Revision is the primary operational and procedural body responsible for the administration of all revisions to the Concordances and their ancillary texts. It is a sub-bureau of the Office of Perpe…
Bureau of Perpetual RevisionSchool of Perpetual Potentiality: who are they?
The School of Perpetual Potentiality is a philosophical and administrative institution dedicated to the formal study, measurement, and bureaucratic stewardship of Potentiality within the Tower. It is the principal interp…
School of Perpetual PotentialitySixth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…
Sixth ConcordanceBecause you consulted