The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Secondary Instrumental

MS 4142.07 · Practices and doctrines

The Secondary Instrumental is a class of certified measuring apparatus defined in Annex of Calibrated Entities as any physical artifact or formally designated phenomenon whose accuracy is traceable, through an unbroken chain of comparison, to a Primary Instrumental. The class is governed by the practice of First Order, which fixes the conditions under which a working standard may be said to descend from a primary rather than merely resemble one. Secondary Instrumentals are the instruments actually used in the Tower's daily work; the Primary Instrumentals they descend from are, for practical purposes, kept in cases.

The category is distinguished from the Instrumental Locus by function rather than pedigree. An Instrumental Locus anchors an entity by its usefulness; a Secondary Instrumental measures it while remaining unaware, in the technical sense, of what it is being used for. The Ordinance of Standard Measures gave the class its canonical examples, designating Calibrated Resonators as Secondary Instrumental for temporal intervals and Derived Cubit Rods as Secondary Instrumental for length; the Annex of Calibrated Entities supplies the certification procedure by which any later artifact may join them. A Second Order entity is calibrated against a Secondary Instrumental and may not itself certify anything.

Certification and the Transience Question

A Secondary Instrumental holds its standing only so long as its certification remains in force. Here the class runs into the long difficulty of Instrumental Transience: the observed tendency of certified instruments to drift from their primaries at rates that no recension of the Ordinance of Standard Measures has satisfactorily predicted. The Office of Instrumental Ratification issues transience certifications; the Instrumental Office contests roughly a third of them, on grounds that have not changed materially since the dispute was first minuted.

The dispute turned bitter in the winter of the 41st Concordance, when a survey party on a low unnamed floor found that a batch of Derived Cubit Rods had all shortened by the same fraction in the same season — a coincidence the Instrumental Office argued proved nothing, and the Ratification Office argued proved everything. The School of Instrumental Realism has since held that the batch was measuring a genuine contraction in the floor beneath it, a position that no subsequent survey has confirmed and none has quite put aside.

"An instrument that agrees with its primary on the day of comparison is a Secondary Instrumental. An instrument that agrees with its primary on every day is a Primary Instrumental that has not been told."

— Instrumental Office, Minute on Transience, Article 9

Register of Notable Secondary Instrumentals

The following are the instruments most frequently cited in the working literature, arranged as the catalogue lists them.

The Polyhedron Dispute

The Crystalline Polyhedron of Autonomous Sorrow was admitted to the register late and never comfortably. Its ratifying clerk, Overseer of Measures Halloway Rennt, recorded that the Polyhedron had been certified against a primary "not presently producible," an entry now cited in every argument about documentary sufficiency. The Instrumental Office holds that a certification with an unproducible primary is no certification at all; the Ratification Office holds that the primary's absence is itself evidence that the Polyhedron has replaced it, and that the class of Secondary Instrumental must therefore admit succession as a route into First Order. Neither office has moved since the Second Recension of the Annex of Calibrated Entities, and the Polyhedron continues in survey use, returning figures that are accepted without comment by everyone except the two offices.

Handling and the Margin Protocol

Because many Secondary Instrumentals are used in the examination of states that change under examination, their handling is largely governed by the Margin Measurement Protocol, which codifies the position that direct examination of a Secondary State alters it and lists the approved instrumental tools by which indirect measurement may proceed. The Protocol's schedule names the Harmonic Gauge and the Crystalline Polyhedron of Autonomous Sorrow specifically, and excludes any tool certified after the Protocol's own last recension — a circularity the annexes acknowledge but do not resolve.

Practical handling is otherwise a matter of local practice. An instrument carried above the floor of its certification must be re-sealed on arrival, and instruments are not to be lent across a spiral. The Series of Standard Intervals governs the waiting period between comparison and re-certification; an instrument compared before the interval has elapsed is re-examined from the beginning, an expense borne by the requesting floor.

Relation to the Primary Class

The class boundary is maintained, as the Ordinance of Standard Measures maintains it, by a single rule: a Secondary Instrumental may be compared to anything, including its own primary, but only the primary may be compared to nothing. The Instrumental entry treats this as the definitional sentence of the whole apparatus; the Phenomenological Spire's readers have argued for years that it is a scribal error and should read "compared to nothing else," and have been refused a hearing four times. The Secondary Oscillator, a close relative of the Resonators, has never settled which reading its own certification rests on, and its guardians prefer not to ask.

The Mercurial Standard Gauge hangs in the entrance hall of the Office of Instrumental Ratification as a reminder of the class's fragility, being the only Secondary Instrumental on record whose transience certification was permitted to expire without contest. It measures nothing now. Visitors are told not to touch it, and the instruction is observed.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Instrumental Ratification: who are they?

The Office of Instrumental Ratification is a chartered body of the Tower, seated on Floor 212 and empowered to issue, withhold, and revoke certificates pertaining to Instrumental Transience. It is the registrar of record…

Office of Instrumental Ratification
Phenomenological Spire: who are they?

The Phenomenological Spire is a secondary administrative and classificatory structure designated for the generation and oversight of phenomenological coefficients, a numerical system used to quantify the secondary and te…

Phenomenological Spire
Crystalline Polyhedron of Autonomous Sorrow: what is it for?

The Crystalline Polyhedron of Autonomous Sorrow is a unique, architecturally integrated device, designated an Instrumental Cartography Unit (ICU-44), located within the Salt Grottoes of Floor 44. It functions as an activ…

Crystalline Polyhedron of Autonomous Sorrow
Second Order (Tertiary Referents): how is it conducted?

The Second Order (Tertiary Referents) is the class of referents calibrated not against a primary or secondary instrument, but against a Tertiary Holding Cell whose own calibration has itself been certified against a refe…

Second Order (Tertiary Referents)

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.