The Locative School
MS 7369.77 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Locative School is the oldest continuously disputing body of opinion in the Tower's documentary history, holding that a thing's identity is not separable from its position, and that cataloguing is therefore an act of placement rather than of description. Its members do not form a guild and have never sought to. They convene instead wherever two of them happen to be standing, a practice the Panel of Settled Dust once described in a minute as "a meeting that has mislaid its room" (Panel Minute 2,208, Spire of Cartographic Echoes).
The School's founding is conventionally dated to the winter of S.Y. 3387, when the question of whether a holding could be catalogued before it was shelved was put to the Ontological School and answered, unhelpfully, in the negative. The dissenting minority took the stairs and did not come back down.
Doctrine
The School's position is stated most compactly in the Axiom of Locative Adherence, which its members did not write but have never stopped citing. From the Axiom they derive a general rule: a holding removed from its place and returned is not the same holding, but a successor holding occupying the same position and inheriting its obligations. This is why the School keeps no lending records. A book that leaves the floor has, on their account, ended, and the book that comes back is greeted politely and given a new Locative Tag.
Because position precedes description, the School maintains that a catalogue entry should begin with the coordinates and end wherever it ends. Their critics observe that several of their own entries do not end. The entry for the Infinite Stairwell is kept in a locked drawer in the Seventh Spiral Scriptorium for this reason.
The Aisle of Ambiguous Prepositions
The School's principal holding is the Aisle of Ambiguous Prepositions, the Tower's primary repository for Locative Ambiguous Referents. The Aisle was not built for them; it was assigned to them under Concordance 12, Annex Δ, which requires the preservation of referents that resist a single position. The School accepted the assignment on the understanding that it would prove the doctrine, and has spent four centuries discovering that it proves only the difficulty of shelving.
An early attempt to resolve the Aisle's contents by assigning each referent a provisional position failed in the winter of S.Y. 3401, when the provisional positions began to displace one another. A clerk of the Department of Ambiguous Metrics, Ersilia Vant, recorded that by the ninth day the Aisle contained one referent and forty-one provisional positions, and that the referent had declined to say which was its own (Vant, Observations on a Provisional Shelf, fol. 22). Vant's measurement unit, the span of hesitation, remains in use there and nowhere else.
Dispute with the Physicalist School
The Physicalist School holds that a holding is its material, and that the School's successor-holdings are a bookkeeping device for avoiding the admission that things move. The two Schools have disputed the point since S.Y. 3410, most sharply over the Seventh Spiral Scriptorium, whose scribes have been known to copy a text in one alcove and shelve it in another, producing on the School's account two holdings and on the Physicalist account one holding with an inconvenient journey.
The Silent College declined to settle the matter, ruling only that the question of a holding's continuity fell outside its remit, which it had already defined as questions of unresolved whereness (Silent College, ruling of S.Y. 3412). The School has taken this as vindication. The Physicalists have taken it as silence, and said so in print.
Relations with other bodies
The School is frequently confused with the Progressive Cartography School, which also concerns itself with position but holds that positions are best recorded in the order they are reached. The Locative School regards this as a category error of the most ordinary kind, and has said so in a memorandum that the Cartographers have not answered. It has better relations with the Guild of Procedural Archivists, whose locative reading of the Procedural Vacuum Hypothesis the School endorses without fully understanding, and with the Foundationalist School, which shares its view that nothing can be described before it is somewhere, while disagreeing about what counts as somewhere.
The Sceptical School attends the School's meetings and asks whether the meeting is in the room or the room is in the meeting. It is invited every year.
Practice and observances
Members of the School mark their reading positions with slips sealed at the eyelet rather than tied, since Archival Dust frays cord and the School has lost two arguments to frayed cord already. When a member is asked where a holding is kept and does not know, the correct reply is "adjacent," a usage the School defends and the Vestibule School has twice tried to have struck from the record.
"A thing is where it is found, and found is a verb we have not yet defined."
— School of Accumulated Intent, marginal note to Concordance 12
The School keeps no membership roll and no minutes. Its archive consists of a single shelf of correspondence, arranged by the position of the desk at which each letter was written. The shelf has been moved twice. The correspondence has not been re-sorted, and the School considers this correct.
See also
-
MS 4667.34
Pre-Cataloguing Verification
Pre-Cataloguing Verification is the sequence of examinations performed upon a subject, specimen, or documentary object before it i…
-
MS 7621.70
Sanctity of Placement
Sanctity of Placement is a foundational principle of library science and ontological management within the Tower, stipulating that…
-
MS 8771.85
Documentary Review
The primary objective of Documentary Review is to establish a "documentary chain of custody" for any entity proposed for catalogui…
-
MS 0889.31
Triangulation of Counterpoise
The Triangulation of Counterpoise is a survey methodology employed by Boundary Clerks to establish the nominal extent of a boundar…
-
MS 6143.16
Documentary Phantom
A Documentary Phantom is a category of anomalous entity whose existence is predicated on and evidenced solely by documentary incon…
-
MS 1241.76
Documentary Phantoms
Documentary Phantoms constitute a class of provisional entities generated by the archival process itself, typically resulting from…
Referenced by
- MS 2815.81 Third Librarian
Readers also asked
Guild of Procedural Archivists: who are they?
The Guild of Procedural Archivists is a recognized body responsible for the documentation, classification, and preservation of administrative processes, meta-rules, and the procedural history of Tower governance. Unlike …
Guild of Procedural ArchivistsPanel of Settled Dust (Spire of Cartographic Echoes): who are they?
The designation Panel of Settled Dust (Spire of Cartographic Echoes) is a locative qualifier adopted by the Registrar of Particulate Appeals in Librarian Reckoning 14,367 to distinguish the sitting body convened within t…
Panel of Settled Dust (Spire of Cartographic Echoes)Aisle of Ambiguous Prepositions: how is it conducted?
The Aisle of Ambiguous Prepositions is the official designation for Floor 413, a classification zone of the Tower dedicated to the storage, measurement, and ontological reconciliation of spatial and relational referents …
Aisle of Ambiguous PrepositionsVestibule School: who are they?
Passages cited from this record
-
A thing is where it is found, and found is a verb we have not yet defined.
School of Accumulated Intent, marginal note to Concordance 12
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6826.27 Axiom of Locative Adherence
- MS 8946.41 Locative School
Because you consulted