Locative Tags
MS 7500.17 · Objects and instruments
Definition and Distinction from Context Tags
Locative Tags are small marked slips, wax-sealed at the eyelet, affixed to a holding to record where that holding was at a stated moment — as distinct from where it is, which is the business of the catalogue proper, and from the circumstances surrounding it, which are the business of Context Tags. The distinction is maintained with some heat. A Context Tag on a folio will tell you the hour, the barometric reading, and which Librarian was on duty; a Locative Tag will tell you only that the folio was on the ninth shelf of the north face, and will not tell you what it was doing there, and considers the question impertinent.
Locative Tags are governed by Concordance 12, Annex Δ, the same instrument that mandates the preservation of Locative Ambiguous Referents. Annex Δ treats the two categories as cousins and forbids their storage in the same press.
Origin: The Quarrel of the Fourth Shelf
The practice is generally dated to the winter of the year the archive recorded as 6-Δ-40, when a consignment of eleven gazetteers was found to have migrated from Floor 214 to Floor 901 without passing through any intermediate floor. The Bureau of Designation ruled the gazetteers had never moved and that the catalogue had moved around them — a position it has since declined to withdraw.
To prevent a recurrence, the Office of Fixed Position, a sub-bureau of Designation, began issuing Locative Tags to every holding above the ninth gallery. The first tags were plain undyed slips of the plain undyed series requisitioned from the Context registry, which the Bureau of Unspoken Context objected to in writing on the grounds of confusion of function. The objection runs to forty-one pages and is still open. Locative Tags have since been cut from a separate stock, green-edged and slightly narrower, though Librarians of long service can still be found licking the wrong end.
"A tag that says where a thing is may not also say how it is. The two together are more than the reader asked for and less than the thing deserves."
— Bureau of Unspoken Context, Objection of 6-Δ-41, clause 3
Form and Grading
Tags bear a position string in the Bureau's house notation: gallery, face, shelf, and offset, the last measured in finger-widths from the shelf's left upright. They are sealed rather than tied, because cord frays against the Archival Dust and a frayed tag reads as a retracted tag. The seals carry the impression of the issuing sub-bureau and the date, and no tag is valid past its third reading; expired tags are gathered in the green trays at each gallery head and returned to the scriptorium for re-use as margins.
The Bureau grades tags by adhesion. A tag that remains legible through one cleaning of the holding is rated Ordinary; one that survives a second cleaning is rated Persisting; and one that survives a flood is rated Presumptuous and is examined by the Bureau before being filed, as the Bureau takes the view that a tag outlasting its holding has begun to make claims.
Visitors may not affix tags. Visitors may request a tag, in writing, from the gallery head, and are advised that the request form asks where they last saw the holding.
The Ambiguous Case
Difficulty arises with holdings that will not hold still. The Aisle of Ambiguous Prepositions is the primary repository for Locative Ambiguous Referents, and the standing instruction there is that no tag is affixed to a referent that resists a single position. The instruction has never been rescinded and is routinely broken. A survey conducted over three galleries in the year 6-Δ-58 found two hundred and nine tags on holdings classified as locatively ambiguous, of which one hundred and sixty-four had been appended with the qualifier as at and a time, and forty-five with the qualifier somewhere about, which has no standing in the notation and appears in no annex.
The Department of Ambiguous Metrics has proposed a unit of locative tolerance — the span, defined as the distance within which a tagged holding may be said to be in the same place as its tag — but the Gamma Registry has declined to enter the span pending a ruling on whether tolerance is a position or a quality. Practitioners in the Aisle use the span informally and call it "the shrug."
Interaction with Bibliostatic Pressure
Locative Tags bear on bibliostatic pressure in a manner not fully understood. Tagged holdings register measurably lower pressure than untagged ones in the same press, a result first reported from the Infinite Stairwell landing in 6-Δ-62 and never satisfactorily explained. The prevailing view, advanced by the Office of Fixed Position and disputed by no one with the standing to dispute it, is that a tag that fixes a holding also fixes its surroundings, and that the pressure is not lessened but merely made to stand still. The Panel of Settled Dust is the only instrument in the Tower that has been used to test this, and its readings are read by three Librarians who do not agree.
Tags left in place through a re-shelving must be clipped at the eyelet before the holding is moved, and the clippings burned in the gallery stove. The stove is lit on the first cold morning of the ninth gallery's year and not before.
Scholarly Disagreement
The First Concordance states without qualification that a thing is where its tag says it is — a position the Bureau of Designation has never formally abandoned, since abandoning it would oblige the Bureau to locate the gazetteers of Floor 214. The Twelfth Concordance, Annex Δ, holds instead that a tag records only where a thing was at the moment of tagging and that the difference between the two is the whole point of tagging. Concordance Theta takes a third line, that a tag records an intention to find, and that the intention may be satisfied by any holding of the same class — a reading that would empty the storerooms if anyone acted on it.
There is also the adjacency question. Whether a tag affixed in the Tower fixes a holding in an adjacent reality, or only a copy of the holding, has been before the Panel of Settled Dust since the spring of 6-Δ-71. The Panel has not reported, and a member of its secretariat has been heard to remark that the tags keep outlasting the arguments about them.
See also
-
MS 7369.77
The Locative School
The Locative School is the oldest continuously disputing body of opinion in the Tower's documentary history, holding that a thing'…
-
MS 7840.84
Clerk of Unfinished Business
The Clerk of Unfinished Business is the titular office charged with the administrative oversight of the Spire of Unfinished Busine…
-
MS 8234.46
Unfinished Business series
Unfinished Business series is a class of docket designated within the Tower for procedural matters deemed both critical and perpet…
-
MS 5356.91
Holdingid Uncalibrated Parallelism
Holdingid Uncalibrated Parallelism is a condition of the catalogue in which a holding carries a valid accession coordinate but tha…
-
MS 3407.45
Seven Distinct But Inter Related Amendments
The '''Seven Distinct But Inter-Related Amendments''' are a set of seven numbered instruments, affixed to Directive 14,408-β (The …
-
MS 6277.58
Anteroom of Unfinished Business
The Anteroom of Unfinished Business is the receiving chamber of the Spire of Unfinished Business, situated on Floor 7114 and reach…
Referenced by
- MS 3472.82 Archival Designation
- MS 7369.77 The Locative School
Readers also asked
Adjacent Unrealities: how is it conducted?
Adjacent Unrealities are a classificatory designation within the Tower's archival taxonomy, denoting unreal subjects whose provisional ontological definitions share a contiguous conceptual border within the ordering syst…
Adjacent UnrealitiesInfinite Stairwell: how is it conducted?
The Infinite Stairwell is the designation, under Twelfth Concordance, Annex 2, for any vertical circulation shaft whose landings cannot be enumerated to a terminating count. The term is descriptive rather than locative: …
Infinite StairwellPanel of Settled Dust (Spire of Cartographic Echoes): who are they?
The designation Panel of Settled Dust (Spire of Cartographic Echoes) is a locative qualifier adopted by the Registrar of Particulate Appeals in Librarian Reckoning 14,367 to distinguish the sitting body convened within t…
Panel of Settled Dust (Spire of Cartographic Echoes)Locative Ambiguous Referents: how is it conducted?
The central principle, as established by the Silent College in S.Y. 3412, is that a Locative Ambiguous Referent is an entity whose "whereness" is fundamentally unresolved. This is not a failure of measurement, but an int…
Locative Ambiguous ReferentsPassages cited from this record
-
A tag that says where a thing is may not also say how it is. The two together are more than the reader asked for and less than the thing deserves.
Bureau of Unspoken Context, Objection of 6-Δ-41, clause 3
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3609.16 Office of Fixed Position
Because you consulted