The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Termination Rationale

MS 1946.15 · Documents and ordinances

The Termination Rationale is the instrument submitted to the Protocols of Cessation when an applicant seeks the discontinuation of a catalogue entry that has not, in the applicant's submission, been adequately described by any previous grounds. It is distinct from the Cessation Rationale, which concerns the termination of a transferred authority, and from the Originating Rationale, which records the department and circumstances from which an application arose; the Termination Rationale is held by the Cessation Corridor under protocol 7 – Aperture Delta of the Protocols of Cessation, and is the only of the three instruments that may be filed without a named departmental sponsor. In ordinary practice it is submitted on a form of eleven leaves, of which the eleventh is customarily left blank and is understood to be for the use of the reviewing bench.

Distinction from neighbouring instruments

The distinction between the Termination Rationale and the Cessation Rationale has been a source of persistent friction. The Manual of Final Closures governs the termination of a catalogue entry; the Codex of Transitive Closures governs the termination of a transferred authority. Where the two overlap — as they frequently do on floors whose holdings were reallocated after the Seventh Concordance — the corridor resolves the discrepancy by accepting both instruments and referring the question upward. This solution is not recorded in any Concordance and has been called "an accommodation of long standing" by the Clerks of the Sundial, who maintain the corridor's intake ledger.

The Cessation Rationale is transmitted by the corridor to the reviewing benches; the Termination Rationale is not, and is instead retained in the corridor's lower shelves until such time as a bench requests it. This retention has no stated limit. A Termination Rationale filed on Floor 1,148 in the winter of the year of the ninth recension was requested eleven years later and found to have been mis-shelved among the returns for an unrelated aperture.

The question of the Justification Matrix

Here the record contradicts itself. The seventh annex of the Justification Matrix provides that an Authorization Matrix must cite a validated Justification Matrix, which defines permissible categories of rationale; this clause names the Termination Rationale among the instruments it covers. The Seventh Concordance, however, notes at clause 3.9 the absence of any instrument formalising categories for the Cessation Rationale, and silence on the Termination Rationale entirely.

"The categories shall be taken to apply to the instrument submitted, whatever its designation, unless a bench of the third standing shall rule otherwise."

— Third Concordance, Emergency Clause 22 (Perceptual Hazard)

The Dean of Sequences has taken the view that the silence of the Seventh Concordance is deliberate, and that the Termination Rationale consequently requires no matrix; the office of Curator Vael has taken the opposite view in two memoranda and a corrections notice. Neither position has been entered as a ruling. Applicants are advised, by the corridor's own guidance sheet, to attach a matrix if they have one and to proceed if they do not.

The Laithwaite filing

The best-documented dispute concerns the clerk Laithwaite of the ninth receiving desk, who in the year of the seventh recension submitted a Termination Rationale for an entry concerning a stairwell that had, for a period of some months, been recorded as ascending and descending simultaneously depending on the order in which it was approached. Laithwaite's grounds were that the entry could not be terminated by Dissolution or by Execution, and that no Originating Rationale could be composed for a stairwell that had not been installed. The Originating Department declined to stamp the application on the ground that the stairwell had no originating circumstances to record; Laithwaite replied that this was precisely his point.

The corridor accepted the filing and returned it stamped noted, unclassified. The stairwell was later re-described as two stairwells, on separate floors, and Laithwaite's rationale was retained in support of neither. Laithwaite's subsequent memorial on the subject — thirty-one leaves, largely tables of dates — is held on Floor 5,307, near the Renal Rapids, where the Fifth Spiral Watercourse terminates.

Filing and retention

A Termination Rationale is filed in duplicate; the second copy is filed in the corridor and is not read. Submissions should not exceed four leaves of grounds, though the corridor has accepted longer, and are to be sealed with the applicant's desk mark rather than a personal seal, a rule introduced after an incident in which a rationale was sealed with a personal seal that could not afterwards be identified and had to be accepted on the applicant's word.

Applications are received at the corridor on any day except the seventh and eighth of the month, when the lower shelves are being turned.

Current status

No Termination Rationale has ever been entered in a final record as the operative grounds of a closure. The practice of expunging the originating rationale from the final legal record — recorded under Temporal Regulation — has been extended by analogy to the Termination Rationale in at least four instances, each time without a ruling. Whether the instrument is therefore a form of the Cessation Rationale with its header struck out, or a distinct instrument of uncertain standing, is a question the corridor has asked the benches on eleven occasions and received no answer. A twelfth request is understood to be in preparation.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Originating Rationale: how is it conducted?

The Originating Rationale is not synonymous with an object's provenance or its historical cause. Rather, it is the first authorized cause, the justification that survives the process of Temporal Regulation and enters the…

Originating Rationale
Temporal Regulation: how is it conducted?

Temporal Regulation refers to the comprehensive suite of ordinances, bureaucratic bodies, licensing frameworks, and practical methodologies governing the manipulation, measurement, and jurisdictional arbitration of time …

Temporal Regulation
Justification Matrix: what does it set out?

Justification Matrix is a regulatory document, created under the auspices of the Third Concordance, which defines the permissible categories of rationale for submitting a Form RV-9: Request for Recursive Validation. It i…

Justification Matrix
Clerks of the Sundial: who are they?

The primary function of the Clerks is the maintenance of the Standard Shadow Registry, a ledger documenting the authorized dimensions, densities, and points of termination for every certified shadow within their purview.…

Clerks of the Sundial

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.