The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Submission and Pathway Check

MS 0221.01 · Practices and doctrines

A Submission and Pathway Check is the composite verification performed whenever a document submitted for catalogue entry is also claimed to lie upon an existing pathway. It is distinguished from the Check proper in that the Check examines a proposition, whereas the Submission and Pathway Check examines a proposition and the route by which it arrived, on the ground that a sound submission reaching the desk by an unsound pathway is, for record purposes, unsound. The composite has no founding Concordance of its own; it is assembled from parts of Concordance XXXI, Concordance XII and the Standing Concordance on Despatch, and clerks required to perform it are advised to read all three in the same sitting.

Composition

The Check proceeds in two movements, known colloquially as the paper and the path. The paper movement is the ordinary five-stage sequence: the Conflict Check, the Axiomatic Compatibility Check, the Procedural Harmony Check, the Notarization Check and the Crossreferential Stability Check, terminating in the Epistemic Alignment Check. The path movement is an abbreviated Pathway Audit conducted midway through the sequence — by convention between the Notarization Check and the Crossreferential Stability Check, though Concordance XXXI, Annex 2 places it earlier and is frequently cited for that reason alone.

Where the two movements disagree, the paper prevails. This is stated plainly in the Procedural Pathway Document, which is itself the output of the Conflict Check and which, for present purposes, may be understood as the answer to the question "which body hears this?" — an answer that the path movement is not permitted to revise.

Admission and the generation of Form IR-9

A Submission and Pathway Check is not performed on request. It is performed on the preliminary acceptance and concordance-check of Registry Form 44-ψ, which acceptance triggers the generation of IR-9 and, with it, entry into the composite. Clerks cannot initiate the Check directly; they can only ensure that the 44-ψ is complete enough not to be returned. The most common cause of return is an unanswered pathway field, and the second most common is a pathway field answered too completely, with routes the submitting party has imagined rather than used.

Submissions routed via the Declaration of Prescribed Pathway bypass the composite and go directly to first-stage initial validation under the Validation Pathway, a divergence that the Directorate of Conditional Pathway Maintenance has defended on the narrow ground that a prescribed pathway requires no checking because it is prescribed. The Directorate has declined jurisdiction in at least one grievance on a different narrow ground — that a certification is not a pathway — and the two positions have never been reconciled in writing.

The Halloway grievance

The leading, and for a long time only, contested case is the grievance of the clerk Wren Halloway, lodged in the winter of the year recorded in the register as 44 after the acceptance of a Submission in Triplicate. Halloway had submitted three copies of the same instrument by three separate stairwells and asked that the composite Check be run once, on the bundle, rather than three times on the copies. The Directorate of Conditional Pathway Maintenance declined to hear the matter, and the file was returned with a single annotation in the margin: "The bundle is not a pathway."

"A submission in triplicate is three submissions for the purposes of the paper and one submission for the purposes of the path, and the clerk who reconciles the two is performing work for which no allowance is made."

— Wren Halloway, marginal note, returned file 44-ψ/1193

Halloway's note was itself entered into the Central Pathway Register by an unauthorized hand, an irregularity noticed only eleven floors later and corrected by the addition of a second entry explaining the first. No allowance has since been created.

Dispute over order

There is no settled account of where the path movement belongs in the sequence. Concordance XII, Annex 6 requires the pathway to be checked before notarization, on the reasoning that a defective route vitiates the seal. Concordance XXXI, Annex 2, which established the Notarization Check as the fourth stage, requires it afterwards, on the reasoning that a seal once affixed is not to be questioned. A recension held on a lower floor and attributed to the Scriptorium of the Eleventh Descent reverses both and places the path movement outside the sequence entirely, describing it as "a thing done in the corridor." The Scriptorium has declined to confirm or deny authorship of the recension, which is its customary reply to all enquiries.

In practice most clerks run the path movement where the corridor is least crowded. This was recorded candidly by the Librarian-Ordinary for Composite Verification, who wrote in a circular of the period that "the order of the stages is doctrinal; the order in which they are performed is a matter of the afternoon." The circular was withdrawn, but not before it had been cited in four subsequent submissions, each of which was duly accepted.

Records

The record of a completed Submission and Pathway Check consists of the original submission, the generated IR-9, the Procedural Pathway Document, and the pathway extract. Where an extract is unavailable the file is closed with a note and the note is filed separately. The separately filed notes are not catalogued and are held in a room on the same floor as the corridor in which the path movement is said to be done. Visitors wishing to consult them should apply in writing and should not use the eastern stair; it is closed for cleaning.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Submission in Triplicate: how is it conducted?

Submission in triplicate is the primary bureaucratic principle of initial documentation within The Tower, mandating that any entity proposed for cataloguing or administrative action must be presented in three identical, …

Submission in Triplicate
Validation Pathway: how is it conducted?

A Validation Pathway is a formally codified procedure within The Tower designed to achieve official verification of an entity, concept, or procedural stream, thereby granting it a recognized status within the archive's o…

Validation Pathway
Concordance XII: what does it set out?

Concordance XII is the twelfth of the numbered instruments of governance issued by the Librarians and the shortest of the first fourteen, comprising a preamble, seven numbered clauses, and no annexes of its own. It is ch…

Concordance XII
Pathway Audit: how is it conducted?

Pathway Audit is the standardized review process, codified in the Third Concordance, for any designated transport or procedural route within The Tower whose status or integrity is under formal question. Unlike the broade…

Pathway Audit

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.