The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Sealed Submission

MS 5791.02 · Practices and doctrines

Sealed Submission is the class of Submission in which a document is deposited in a closed state — folded, wrapped, or glazed — such that its contents cannot be read by the receiving office at the moment of deposit, and are not read by that office at any later moment either. It is distinguished from the open forms catalogued elsewhere (Declarative Submission, Documentary Submission, and their sub-forms) not by the secrecy of its contents, which is incidental, but by the fact that the sealing is itself the submission. What is submitted, in strict doctrine, is the seal.

The practice is administered under the Sealed Aperture Registry, which records seals by impression rather than by content, and which has never in its history recorded a single document's text. Clerks of the Registry are appointed for their inability to describe what they handle; the appointment is tested at the sentiment trials on the seventh floor, and roughly one candidate in nine fails by volunteering an opinion.

Origin and the Aperture Ruling

Sealed Submission arose from an administrative embarrassment rather than a doctrine. In the winter of the year recorded as 4,112 by the Registry's own count, the receiving hall of the ninth aperture accepted some six hundred documents in a single week and, owing to a fire in the adjoining scriptorium, could not read any of them. Rather than return the documents — return being forbidden once a document has crossed an aperture threshold under the Third Concordance, Annex 2 — the duty clerk, one Ovin Marsh, sealed the lot unread and issued receipts describing each as "received, contents intact, contents unknown."

The receipts were challenged. The challenge failed. The Aperture Ruling of 4,113 held that a submission is complete upon crossing the threshold and does not depend on the receiver's comprehension, a finding that resolved the immediate dispute and created, unintentionally, a valid and popular form.

"The document having passed the aperture is submitted. Whether it is understood is a matter for the aperture, which does not read."

— The Aperture Ruling of 4,113, clause 6

Approved seal formats

Seals are regulated by impression, weight, and closure, not by content. The Registry recognises four formats, and a fifth is under consideration and has been under consideration since 4,388.

  • Format A — the plain fold, wax at the crease, one impression.
  • Format B — the wrapped packet, cord and seal, no crease.
  • Format C — Submission Glass, for documents to be housed rather than folded.
  • Format D — the double seal, in which the outer seal encloses a second seal that is never reached.

Format D is the subject of the longest-running dispute in the Registry's records. The Ordinance of Double Closure holds that the inner seal is not submitted until the outer is broken, and that the outer may not be broken. The Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, holds the opposite, that the inner seal is submitted at the moment of the outer's impression and the outer seal is therefore redundant. The two have never been reconciled; both are cited daily; documents are sealed under both, in the same wax, by clerks who do not raise the question.

The unread copy and the Triplicate question

Sealed Submission is frequently confused with Submission in Triplicate, since both require a copy that is not read. The distinction is one of scope. Under Submission in Triplicate, two copies are read and one is not; under Sealed Submission, no copy is read and there is only the one. Practitioners of the triplicate form have argued for centuries that a triple submission with all three copies sealed should count as both forms simultaneously and discharge both fees. The Ordinance of Triplicate Mean declined to settle the point, observing only that "the fee is not discharged by doubt."

A related confusion attaches to Sequencing Submission, which requires that a number be submitted before the document to which it refers. Sealed Submission permits the number to be sealed with the document, so that the sequence is preserved in an unread state and may be verified by weight. Verification by weight is accepted in the Registry and rejected by the Office of Ordered Records, which has refused to weigh anything since 4,201.

Interaction with other forms

Sealed Submission may accompany Petitionary Submission, provided the prayer is spoken aloud before sealing; a prayer sealed unspoken is void and is returned, which is the only circumstance in which the Registry returns anything. It may precede Archival Submission where the holding is to enter the permanent catalogue without inspection, a route taken by an estimated eleven per cent of holdings and disputed by the Office of Ordered Records, which maintains that an uninspected holding is not a holding and has maintained so in writing forty-one times.

Sealed Submission may not be combined with Sequencing Submission in its strict form, with Re-application, or with any proceeding under Submission and Pathway Check. It is compatible with Maintenance Submission only where the maintenance is itself unreadable, a condition the Registry describes as common.

Practical notes

Seals are impressed at the aperture and not before. A seal impressed in the corridor is refused and the bearer is asked to step back. Wax is supplied by the aperture and may not be brought from another floor, a rule introduced after the Incident of the Borrowed Wax in 3,907, in which a sealed submission was opened by the receiving clerk in the belief that it was his own lunch. The clerk was not disciplined. The seal was re-impressed and the submission stands.

Sealed submissions are stored by weight, in stacks of not more than forty, in the closed bays of the Registry. They are not opened on request. They are not opened on order. They are opened once, at the end of the Tower, by the Final Reader, whose appointment is recorded but whose name is not, and who has not yet been required to attend.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Archival Submission: how is it conducted?

Archival Submission is the formal procedure for introducing a new holding into the permanent catalogue of the Tower. Governed primarily by Clause 3 of the Third Concordance and further codified by General Administrative …

Archival Submission
Form DRS-44a: Submission of Personal Sentiment for Official Consideration: what does it set out?

Form DRS-44a: Submission of Personal Sentiment for Official Consideration is a standardized declaration used to file an individual's affective or evaluative response for inclusion within the Tower's official holdings. It…

Form DRS-44a: Submission of Personal Sentiment for Official Consideration
Sequencing Submission: how is it conducted?

Sequencing Submission refers to the formal process by which a procedural sequence—whether for calibration, validation, archival logging, or operational sigil activation—is presented to the Sequencers for official review,…

Sequencing Submission
Documentary Submission: how is it conducted?

Documentary Submission is the formal act by which a person, office, or undetermined entity surrenders a document to the Tower's cataloguing apparatus for entry, revision, or disposal. It is distinguished from ordinary fi…

Documentary Submission

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.