Telluric
MS 2628.34 · Practices and doctrines
Telluric is a classificatory term used throughout the Tower to designate materials, strata, and processes native to the structure itself, as distinguished from those of meteoric or imported origin. The word appears in no fewer than forty-one Concordance annexes and in the standing vocabularies of at least nine administrative offices, and its precise scope has been disputed since the earliest surviving recensions of the Third Concordance. In ordinary cataloguing practice, a substance is called telluric if it was formed within the Tower and has never been outside it; the definition is circular, and the Librarians have declined on four separate occasions to repair it.
Etymology and early usage
The term derives from tellus, the ledger-word for "floor-substance" employed by the Central Scriptorium in its inventory of the lower western shafts. The earliest attested use in a Concordance appears in the Fifth Concordance, Annex 2, which refers without elaboration to "the telluric body of the Tower, which is not to be counted among its contents." This sentence has been cited in every subsequent dispute on the subject and has never been satisfactorily parsed. The Floor of Foundational Documents holds three variant readings of the clause, differing only in the placement of a comma, and the three readings support three incompatible interpretations.
The telluric classes
Current cataloguing recognises three telluric classes, though the third is contested:
- Telluric iron — the native ferrous class, catalogued at Telluric Iron, from which Axiomatic Iron is refined and of which Whispering Iron forms the outer sheath of an Iron Bookend.
- Telluric stone — the structural aggregate of the load-bearing floors, distinguished from imported masonry by its faint resonance under load.
- Telluric water — recognised provisionally, pending the findings of the survey recorded in the Atlas of Oneiric Water Tables.
The distinction between the classes is not chemical but custodial: a substance is telluric iron rather than telluric stone if the Iron Annex has jurisdiction over it, and jurisdiction is determined by a schedule last revised on Floor 1004 and not since reconciled with the schedule used on Floor -12.
The Telluric Question
The so-called Telluric Question — whether a thing ceases to be telluric once it has been carried above its floor of origin — was formally raised in the winter sitting of the Third Concordance committee and has never been closed. The committee's working minute of that sitting records the difficulty with unusual candour:
"A nail drawn from a telluric seam on the ninth western floor and driven into the door of the fourth is telluric in its substance and imported in its position. The committee is unable to say which fact the word reports."
— Working Minute 14, Third Concordance committee, winter sitting
Two positions have hardened since. The substantialists hold that telluric is a property of matter, fixed at formation and unaffected by transport; they cite the Descent Protocol, which treats all material recovered from the Lower Reaches as telluric regardless of where it is later stored. The positionalists hold that telluric is a property of place, and that any object removed from its native floor becomes, by that removal, an import. The Fifth Concordance is usually read in support of the positionalists, though the same annex is read in support of the substantialists by the Iron Annex, which has an interest in the question.
Administrative consequences
The dispute is not academic. Export duty on telluric material is assessed at four times the rate on imports, and the classification of a single consignment can occupy the Central Scriptorium for a season. The most cited case concerns Clerk Orenthal Vey, who in the winter of the fourth recension catalogued a shipment of Vacuum Wafers as telluric, was reversed on appeal, recatalogued the shipment as imported, was reversed again, and eventually filed the consignment under both headings with a note reading "pending the Question." Vey's note is now the standard form. The Iron Nib, whose telluric core is required for precise inscription of iron documents, is exempt from duty under all readings, a concession granted in perpetuity and never explained in the record.
Seals attached to Iron Dicta are struck from telluric stock and are not subject to the Question, on the reasoning that a seal is telluric by definition of the office that presses it. This reasoning has been challenged twice and upheld twice.
Related terms
Telluric is frequently confused with terrene, a term used by the Lower Reaches survey corps for material below the lowest catalogued floor, and with native, which in Scriptorium usage means only that an object's origin is recorded. Neither confusion is treated as an error requiring correction, and the standing instruction to the cataloguing desk is to let the reader's reading stand. Materials recovered alongside meteoric stock are catalogued separately, though the two are often found in the same shaft; the distinction is maintained by the Iron Annex and is not to be collapsed in the finding aid. Visitors ascending past the ninth western landing are asked not to strike the walls to test for resonance.
See also
-
MS 0260.98
Conceptual
Conceptual is the classificatory term used throughout the Tower for materials, practices, and properties that possess coherent con…
-
MS 2515.73
Courier Protocols
Courier Protocols designate the consolidated body of procedure governing the movement of aetherically stabilized materials between…
-
MS 6189.76
Latent Agent
Latent Agent is a tripartite taxonomic classification used to designate subjects, typically within the category of archival materi…
-
MS 1663.96
Echoing Registrar
The Echoing Registrar is a designate class of wall-mounted instrument employed throughout the Tower as a witness to the Twice-Hour…
-
MS 2087.42
Acoustic
Acoustic is the term of art used throughout the Tower to designate any quantity, property, or phenomenon capable of being register…
-
MS 5531.06
Phenomenological Spire
The Phenomenological Spire is a secondary administrative and classificatory structure designated for the generation and oversight …
Referenced by
- MS 3488.52 The Subterranean Complex
Readers also asked
Fifth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fifth Concordance is the first major procedural concordance to survive in its entirety, ratified in Year 47 of the Second Librarianate. It is primarily concerned with establishing protocols for the measurement, docum…
Fifth ConcordanceDescent Protocol: how is it conducted?
Descent Protocol (pl. Descent Protocols) is a class of regulatory frameworks governing all authorized vertical exploration within The Tower. It encompasses a complex system of approved routes, application procedures, dur…
Descent ProtocolIron Nib: what is it for?
Iron Nib is the designation for the ceremonial writing instrument used exclusively for the inscription of Iron Dictates within the School of Operational Necessity. The Nib itself is not made of iron, a fact that is the s…
Iron Nibthe Tower: where is it?
The Tower is an administrative-territorial entity and archival structure of indeterminate vertical extent, operating under the aegis of The Librarians. It is the sole known locus for the formal cataloguing and containmen…
the TowerPassages cited from this record
-
A nail drawn from a telluric seam on the ninth western floor and driven into the door of the fourth is telluric in its substance and imported in its position. The committee is unable to say which fact the word reports.
Working Minute 14, Third Concordance committee, winter sitting
Because you consulted