The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Retroactive Integration

MS 1652.34 · Practices and doctrines

Retroactive Integration is the procedure by which a document, structure, or person that has been established to have always existed is formally received into the holdings of the Retroactive School as though it had been catalogued at the time of its (revised) inception. It is distinguished from Retroactive Adjustment in that the latter concerns the correction of sequence, whereas Retroactive Integration concerns the correction of record — the insertion of a card into the catalogue where previously there was only a gap and a faint indentation.

The practice is administered under Clause 3, whose Annex Δ is the standing authority for its most serious consequence, and is taught to entrants alongside the Retroactive Numeracy curriculum during their second winter on the Intermediate Floors.

Definition and scope

Retroactive Integration is not the same as the adoption of a found object. An object carried into the Tower by an expedition is catalogued on arrival, with the date of arrival, and is thereafter merely an object. The subject of Retroactive Integration is something that was never carried in at all, and whose presence in the Tower is discovered only after the fact by the discovery of an effect it must have caused.

The distinction is drawn sharply in the Bureau of Pre-Integration's circular of 3 Pluvium (Floor 1,412, Reading Room C), which holds that the question is not "does this item exist?" but "does this item have a past in this building?" A stairwell on Floor 2,208 that was measured at four hundred and eleven steps in the survey of 9 Brumaire and at four hundred and nineteen steps in the survey of 11 Brumaire was not enlarged, the circular notes; it was Integrated, and the eight steps it had always had were given their card. The stairwell is now listed at four hundred and nineteen steps in every recension, and the earlier survey is retained in the archive as the shortened version.

Procedure

Integration proceeds in three movements, of which the second is the most frequently disputed. The first is attribution: the newly apparent subject is assigned a date of origin earlier than the date of discovery, on the evidence of the effects it must have produced. The second is consequence: the clerks must then identify everything that has occurred since the assigned date which could not have occurred had the subject not been there, and re-describe it accordingly. The third is sealing: the revised description is sealed under a Concordance number and the original description is moved to the Retroactive Anomalies register, where it remains available for reference.

The second movement is where the practice fails. In the winter of 934, the Retroactive Drift Assessment office reported that an unattributed reading room on Floor 3,076 had been Integrally received with an original date of 712, and that four hundred and three entries downstream of that date required correction, including the fire of 728, which the reading room had apparently prevented. The Bureau of Pre-Integration declined to amend the fire, on the ground that the rooms had not been occupied. The fire remains in the record as an event that has been retroactively suppressed. Persons consulting the fire of 728 are asked to read it in the lower case.

Contamination and the Annex Δ question

Because Retroactive Integration alters the record of a period rather than the period itself, it is a recognised route to Retroactive Contamination. Retroactive Alignment is the practice used to reconcile the timelines of Retroactive Anomalies to the primary timeline, and an Integration that is not followed within three movements by an Alignment of the affected band will produce a second, unsealed description of the same band. Annex Δ of Clause 3 formally documented Contamination in the aftermath of the Corvane Integration of 878, in which fourteen distinct original dates were assigned to a single bell and the bell was subsequently heard in all of them.

The Doctrine of Retroactive Standing holds that the contaminated description has standing only if the sealing movement is repeated, and that the repetition need not be documented in the register. The Bureau's position is that the repetition must be documented twice.

Disputed doctrine

The two positions are irreconcilable and are cited against one another in nearly every dispute over the practice. The Manual of Resonant Integration holds, at section 9, that "an Integration unsealed is not an Integration but a hope" — a formulation attributed to the Manual's third reviser, and disputed by the Retroactive School's own readers as a misreading of the On Retroactive Precedence tradition, which treats sealing as a courtesy extended to the archive rather than a condition of the instrument.

Contemporary practice favours the Manual, except on Floor 5,101, where the Bureau's caseload is such that the courtesy cannot be extended in the same season, and the practice is accepted. The local variation is known as the slow seal and was last acknowledged in writing in 941.

"The record of a thing is not a second thing. It is the thing, in the form in which it is permitted to be consulted."

— Manual of Resonant Integration, Section 9

Inventory of Integrated holdings, 934–939

The following is the Bureau's standing summary of Integrations completed in the five-year period, retained in the original form:

  • Floor 1,412 — four cupboards, one corridor, seven visiting cards (for a clerk who had not yet been appointed).
  • Floor 2,208 — the eight eastern steps of the eastern stairwell, with their original census entries.
  • Floor 3,076 — the unattributed reading room, and the fire of 728 (suppressed).
  • Floor 4,003 — the bell, in fourteen dates, one of which is audible from the stairwell by the water closet.
  • Floor 5,101 — the slow seal, itself Integrated in 936, together with the note that preceded it.

Items marked suppressed remain in the catalogue and may be consulted by appointment. Bells are not to be rung.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Manual of Resonant Integration: what does it set out?

— Preamble, Manual of Resonant Integration, 4th Edition

Manual of Resonant Integration
Retroactive Alignment: how is it conducted?

Retroactive Alignment is a theoretical state of administrative closure in which all previous irregularities, contradictions, and unauthorized variances within a given catalogical domain are resolved by the backdating of …

Retroactive Alignment
Retroactive School: how is it conducted?

Retroactive School refers to a minor but persistent tradition of pedagogical methodology within the Tower, which operates on the principle that the acquisition of certain knowledge can render that knowledge retroactively…

Retroactive School
Bureau of Pre-Integration: who are they?

The Bureau of Pre-Integration is a preparatory office of the Directorate of Concordant Integration, charged with the assessment of materials, persons, and floors that have been proposed for integration but not yet admitt…

Bureau of Pre-Integration

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.