The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Repercussive Desk

MS 1069.45 · Objects and instruments

The Repercussive Desk is a sound-bearing desk held on Floor 214-r since at least the ninth recension of the floor registers. It is not a correspondence desk in the manner of the Desk of Lateral Correspondence; correspondence passes through the Repercussive Desk without being read, logged, or in any sense answered. The desk exists to receive an utterance and return it, at a measured interval, in a voice not the speaker's own. Everything else it does it does by consequence.

The desk is a field-oak trestle of the third standard pattern, 1.9 metres by 0.8, the top scored in eleven places where the returns have been unable to leave it. It has no drawer. Desk Gamma derivations of the same pattern are supplied with a ledger, provisional stamps, and a Desk-Fern; the Repercussive Desk is supplied with none of these, and the omission is not treated as a defect in any surviving recension.

Construction and the interval

The desk was assembled with its recessed panel set facing inward, a single error of the joiner's square at the time of its making. The error has never been corrected, and the Concordance on Unfinished Repairs (clause 7) forbids its correction, on the grounds that a desk which has already begun returning sound will not survive the disturbance of being made correct.

The interval between utterance and return is not fixed. Measured returns range from eleven minutes to just under four years, and the desk's wardens maintain that the interval lengthens in proportion to how much the speaker would prefer not to hear the reply. This claim has never been tested to the satisfaction of the Desk of Sigillary Verification, which points out that the four-year case involved a clerk who had died in the interim. The return was sealed and filed unopened, as is proper.

The Wardenship and the Winter of the Long Echo

The desk is tended by a wardenship of two, one of whom must be present whenever the desk is in receipt. The requirement dates from the winter of 1188, when the Repercussive Desk returned a single sentence continuously for nine days. The sentence was an inventory item — "six chairs, one short" — spoken by a visiting Desk of Concrete Referents auditor on the afternoon of the first day. By the fourth day the wards on Floor 214-r had been cleared and the adjacent stairwell closed; by the ninth the return had lost its consonants, and the wardens recorded the sound as "wind through slats."

The auditor, Mira Skeld, petitioned for the return to be stopped. Her petition was refused under the Standing Order on Desks That Answer, which holds that no desk may be silenced by petition. Skeld's subsequent memorial to the Second Analytic Desk is the fullest eyewitness account of the incident and is stored, per standing arrangement, alongside the logs of its associated Desk-Fern.

"The desk returned my sentence in a voice I recognised as mine and knew could not be mine, and went on returning it after I had left the floor, and went on returning it after I had left the stairwell, and I was told this was correct."

— Mira Skeld, memorial to the Second Analytic Desk, 1189

Disputed status as a derivative

A long-running disagreement concerns whether the Repercussive Desk is a derivation at all. The Desk Fern Taxonomy of places it in the same working group as Desk Delta and Desk Epsilon, on the evidence of its trestle dimensions alone. The Desk-Fern Controversy has since muddied this: if the taxonomy's working groups are to be read as provisional (7-F), then the Repercussive Desk's placement is provisional in the same degree, and the desk may be reclassified at any review.

The opposing school holds that the desk is not derivative but adjacent — that it stands to the derivations of Desk Alpha roughly as Desk Omega stands to the analytic desks, functionally distinct and considered administrateral. This reading has the merit of explaining why the Repercussive Desk has never been issued with a derivation number, and the demerit of having no documentary support whatsoever. The Concordance of Adjacent Fixtures was drafted to settle the point and was amended twice before it was read.

Interaction with other desks

Utterances made in the presence of the Repercussive Desk are held to bind the speaker for the term of their return. Clerks working the desk are accordingly trained to speak only in complete sentences and to name the date aloud before saying anything else, so that a late return arrives already dated. A return that arrives undated is referred to the Receding Reference Desk for jurisdictional determination; the The Case of the Receding Reference Desk remains the leading authority on such referrals, though it concerned a quite different desk and has been extended to the Repercussive Desk only by analogy.

The desk's returns are not evidence. They are, however, admissible as testimony, and the distinction has cost the First Analytic Desk considerable correspondence, since requests for the recorded returns are forwarded from that desk to the Second Analytic Desk, which stores the logs and will not release them without the seal of the Desk of Sigillary Verification. Visitors are asked not to lean on the desk. The prohibition is stamped on the floor's lintel in two places.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Desk Omega: what is it for?

Desk Omega is the institutional designation for the primary consultative nexus of the Omega Truss, located at the apex of Spiral Staircase Omega on Floor -7 of the West Administrative Quadrant. It serves as the primary i…

Desk Omega
Desk Epsilon: what is it for?

Desk Epsilon is a stationary inquiry platform located within Annex Epsilon, designated for the processing of questions pertaining to the concept of "midpoint." Its establishment was formalized under Clause 17.4 of Annex …

Desk Epsilon
Desk Delta: who are they?

Desk Delta is a second-analytic bureau within the Delta Council charged with the reconciliation of contradictory procurement forecasts and the maintenance of equilibrium in the Bureau of Acquisition's logistical flows. I…

Desk Delta
Desk Alpha: what is it for?

Desk Alpha (designation -θ-1), also known historically as the Aethelred Primarius, is the primary standard unit of administrative measurement and procedural calibration within the Tower's central bureaucracy. It defines …

Desk Alpha

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.