The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Registry of Mutable Forms

MS 5124.27 · Practices and doctrines

The Registry of Mutable Forms is the Tower body charged with the identification, custody, and periodic revision of forms that are acknowledged to change while remaining, for administrative purposes, the same form. It is one of the oldest continuous offices in the middle reaches, first attested on Floor 1140 the Anteroom of Second Drafts in the winter of the year recorded as 3-M-1140, and it holds concurrent jurisdiction over the Mutable Stacks, the Mutable Gregorian, and the protocol designated V-Δ. Its seal is a rectangle drawn twice, the second outline offset from the first and the overlap left unshaded.

Unlike the Office of Absolute Registry, which maintains static ledgers for forms declared Final, the Registry keeps no final text of anything. Its central doctrine — that a form may be amended without being superseded, and superseded without being amended — was settled early and has not been revisited since.

Mandate and jurisdiction

The Registry's authority is set out most fully in Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, which assigns it "the keeping of forms whose terms alter in the ordinary course, together with all questions arising from the alteration" (Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, cl. 2). In practice this has meant that the Registry answers not only for what a mutable form says but for what happens to it while it is saying something else.

Administration of the Mutable Stacks is shared with the Office of Volumetric Integrity, an arrangement codified in Sixth Concordance after some decades of dispute over whether the Registry's interest lay in the text of a form or in the shelf that held it. The compromise, which neither office has ever described as satisfactory, divides the Stacks by dimension: the Registry speaks to what a holding is, the Office to how much room it takes up. Custody of the Mutable Gregorian is held jointly on the same terms. The Registry also claims oversight of the Stacks' "medium", a term it has never defined in writing and has twice declined to define when asked by the Office of Volumetric Integrity.

Within the Mutable Atlas Complex — the collective designation for the Stacks — the Registry's direct hand falls chiefly on Chamber IV, where fragments of the deprecated Mutable Gregorian exhibit shifting month lengths and marginalia. Amendments to those fragments are entered by Registry clerks and countersigned by the Office. A clerk who countersigns in the wrong order is required to enter the amendment again.

The Mutable Gregorian and the Marginalia

The Registry adopted the term "Mutable Gregorian" in Seventh Concordance, Annex 1, and shares administrative responsibility for it with the Office of Volumetric Integrity. The designation itself is a Registry coinage, and the Registry has defended it against at least four proposed alternatives, the most persistent of which was "the Provisional Months".

Alterations to the Gregorian's marginalia are governed by the ordinances of the Marginalia Registry, which distinguish a primary form (the entry as originally made) from a secondary form (the entry as it is presently read). Registry procedure requires both forms to be logged, even where they are identical, and this requirement has accounted for the greater part of the Registry's copying labour since the ordinances were consolidated. The static archival UUIDs for these holdings are kept in the Chronicles of the Mutable Atrium; the Registry does not maintain its own index and refers all enquiries there.

"Where a form is both primary and secondary at the hour of entry, the clerk shall enter it twice and note the coincidence in the margin. The note is not to be counted as marginalia."

— Marginalia Registry, Ordinance 14(b)

Protocol V-Δ

Protocol V-Δ, jointly overseen by the Registry and the Office of Volumetric Integrity, governs the handling of mutable forms whose alteration cannot be attributed to any recorded amendment. The protocol is short — eleven clauses, of which nine concern stationery — and is invoked perhaps four times a year. Its most notorious invocation followed the Mutable Gregorian fragment designated IV-88, which was found in the spring of a year the Registry records only as 41-M-2 to have gained a thirty-second day. No amendment accounted for it. The protocol required the fragment to be sealed, witnessed, and left in place; it was left in place, and the day remains in the record.

The Registry's position, stated in a memorandum of that year and never withdrawn, is that the thirty-second day is "held rather than counted". The Office of Volumetric Integrity has declined to endorse the phrase, and the disagreement is the most frequently cited example of the two offices' differing views of the same shelf.

Dispute with the Office of Volumetric Integrity

The long quarrel between the Registry and the Office of Volumetric Integrity turns on whether a mutable form's substance belongs to its text or to the space it displaces. The Registry holds that the Office measures forms it cannot read; the Office holds that the Registry reads forms it cannot measure. Both positions are supported by Concordance. Fifth Concordance, Annex 3, cl. 7 assigns the Registry "all questions of substance", while Sixth Concordance, Annex 2, cl. 1 assigns the Office "all questions of extent, including extent of substance". The two clauses have never been reconciled, and citations of either are accepted in Registry proceedings without prejudice to the other.

The dispute has a named grievance. Clerk Adelinde Voss, who served the Registry from 41-M-2 to 57-M-2, petitioned three times to have the phrase "extent of substance" struck from the Sixth Concordance on the ground that it settled nothing. Her third petition was granted in part: the phrase was retained, but a note was added recording that it had been questioned. Voss left the Registry the following winter and is remembered chiefly for the note.

Records, seals, and current practice

The Registry's working records are kept in the Forms VI-X and Forms XI-XV ledgers, with earlier material dispersed among the holdings catalogued as Forms I-V. Entries are made in duplicate, sealed once, and amended in the presence of a second clerk. The Preceptual Registry maintained by the Form Genesis Division supplies the Registry with its blank forms; the Registry has complained since 33-M-9 that these arrive already partly filled in, and the Division has never explained why.

Petitioners seeking amendment of a mutable form present themselves at the Anteroom of Second Drafts on any day the stair is running. They are asked to bring their own pen. The Registry supplies ink, seals, and witnesses, but not pens, and the rule has been enforced without exception since a petitioner in 48-M-2 attempted to borrow one and was entered, by mistake, as an amendment.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Sixth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…

Sixth Concordance
Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…

Seventh Concordance
Forms VI-X: what does it set out?

Forms VI-X are the five intermediate members of the Ancient Series of Forms, a closed sequence of fourteen documents issued, according to the Series preamble, "in the order in which they became unavoidable." Forms VI, VI…

Forms VI-X
Forms XI-XV: how is it conducted?

Forms XI-XV are the five terminal members of the Ancient Series of Forms, a closed sequence of fourteen documents of which Forms VI-X constitute the intermediate members. They are held in recension at the Repository of P…

Forms XI-XV

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.