The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Forms VI-X

MS 4377.33 · Documents and ordinances

Forms VI-X are the five intermediate members of the Ancient Series of Forms, a closed sequence of fourteen documents issued, according to the Series preamble, "in the order in which they became unavoidable." Forms VI, VII, VIII, IX and X bear no individual titles. They are catalogued, cited, contested and revised entirely under their numerals, a convention the Office of Unbuilt Forms has twice proposed abolishing and twice withdrawn.

The Series is held complete in the Repository of Provisional Forms on Floor 233, with a working recension at the Archives of Imperfect Forms. Forms VI-X are the only stretch of the Series for which no complete concordance of drafts survives; the Bureau of Transient Forms reports that the gap has been open since at least the winter of 1147, and that the relevant shelving has been sealed on the authority of Concordance 212: On Sequences Interrupted since 1161.

Placement within the Series

Forms I-V are narrative and short. Forms XI-XIV are tabular and were, by most accounts, composed after the fact to justify the earlier five. Forms VI-X fall between: they are neither narrative nor tabular, and the Bureau of Structural Hermeneutics classifies them as "transitional documents, if the transition is permitted to run in either direction" (Memorandum 88-B, §3). This ambiguity is not incidental. It is the reason the central numerals are the most heavily annotated span of the Series and the least frequently issued.

Only Form VIII is issued routinely, and then only in the provisional recension; the Register of Declared Forms records eleven issuances of Form VIII in the past century, all to offices subsequently consolidated or dissolved. Forms VI, VII, IX and X have not been issued in their settled recensions at any time the archive can confirm.

Contents

The texts of Forms VI-X are brief and largely concerned with procedure for matters the Series elsewhere declines to name. Form VI consists of four clauses and a seal schedule. Form VII consists of four clauses and no seal schedule, a defect the Bureau of Ambiguous Forms has ruled "not a defect but a withholding" (Ruling 311, annex beta). Form VIII comprises a single unpunctuated sentence of some four hundred words, which the Office of Final Forms receives in copy each quarter without reading it. Form IX is blank except for the numeral, and Form X refers the reader back to Form VI.

This last reference is the source of the longest-running dispute in the Series' history. Whether Form X incorporates Form VI by reference, or merely mentions it, determines whether the two forms may be issued together. The Concordance 708 holds that they may; Concordance 212: On Sequences Interrupted holds that they may not; and neither document acknowledges the other. The Bureau of Transient Forms has adopted the practice of issuing neither, which the Office of Unbuilt Forms has described in a marginal annotation as "a third reading, advanced without authority."

The Hildebrand Annotations

The working recension in the Archives of Imperfect Forms carries the annotations of the clerk Hildebrand of the Ninth Landing, who collated Forms VI-X against eleven earlier drafts between 1042 and 1051 and recorded his objections in the margins of the fair copy, in a hand now standard for the Series. Hildebrand's annotations were never entered into the register, and he was not, by the accounts that survive, asked to cease.

His grievance is preserved in a single marginal note beside the fourth clause of Form IX, which is otherwise blank:

"I have been asked eleven times to establish what Form IX does and have been given only the form itself to establish it from. I have written to the Ninth Landing seven times concerning the condition of the north stair between the fifth and sixth turnings. No reply has come, and the stair remains out of service."

— Hildebrand of the Ninth Landing, annotation to Form IX (1047); Archives of Imperfect Forms, MS 44/ix

The Office of Unbuilt Forms has ruled that Hildebrand's annotations possess "interpretive but not declaratory force" (Ruling 402, §7) and may therefore be cited against a form but not in support of one — a distinction the Bureau of Ambiguous Forms has found "operatively real and conceptually empty."

The Doctrinal Question

Scholarly disagreement centres on whether Forms VI-X are original documents at all. The Adherents of Anticipatory Forms hold that the central numerals were interpolated into the Series at a later commission to supply a continuity that never existed, and cite the absence of drafts. The Office of Unbuilt Forms, which notarizes Theoretical Blueprints for unbuilt rooms, argues the opposite: that Forms VI-X are the only members of the Series composed entirely from drafts, and that the drafts were removed because they were final. The Gallery of Resonant Forms has declined to settle the question, noting only that the forms "read alike under recitation" (Gallery Minute 19).

Access

Forms VI-X may be consulted in the antechamber of the Repository of Provisional Forms on Floor 233 from the second bell until the light fails. They may not be copied in their entirety; readers are permitted to transcribe any three of the five numerals per visit, and no more than one copy of any single numeral may exist in an office at a time. Form IX, being blank, is exempt.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Final Forms: who are they?

The Office of Final Forms is the administrative body responsible for the official ratification and archival declaration of a form's transition from conditional or provisional status into its permanent, immutable state wi…

Office of Final Forms
Gallery of Resonant Forms: where is it?

The Gallery of Resonant Forms is the designation properly applied to Floor 14,302 of the Tower, the seat of the School of Resonant Phenomena and the institution's principal hall for the exhibition, examination, and dispu…

Gallery of Resonant Forms
Bureau of Ambiguous Forms: who are they?

The Bureau of Ambiguous Forms is the primary regulatory and custodial body for phenomena which possess definitive structure or outline but lack a correspondingly definitive ontological status. Its mandate, established un…

Bureau of Ambiguous Forms
Repository of Provisional Forms: where is it?

The Repository of Provisional Forms is the Tower's principal depository for documents, instruments, and objects held pending final classification. It occupies the greater part of Floor 233, together with a service mezzan…

Repository of Provisional Forms

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.