The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Forms I-V

MS 6778.21 · Documents and ordinances

Definition and scope

Forms I-V are the five introductory members of the Ancient Series of Forms, a closed sequence of fourteen documents held in full at the Repository of Provisional Forms. They are so designated because they precede Forms VI-X, the five intermediate members, and are in turn preceded by nothing at all: the sequence begins at Form I, and the Repository's own colophon records that a Form 0 was "considered and set aside" without stating by whom or on what grounds.

The five documents are not instructions for completing later forms, though they are frequently mistaken for such. They are, in the terminology of the Bureau of Transient Forms, "constitutive rather than operative" — they establish that forms exist, that they may be distinguished from one another, and that a form once issued continues to be the form it was after it has been amended. The remaining nine members of the Series deal in particulars; Forms I-V deal in the conditions under which particulars can be said to be particulars.

Of the 1,144 items comprising the complete Series, Forms I-V account for 312, of which 309 are blank.

The five documents individually

Form I is the shortest of the five, occupying a single leaf, and states the principle of distinctness: that no two forms are the same form even where their contents are identical. It is the document most often cited and least often read in its entirety, a reputation it shares with several of the Concordances. A marginal annotation in the working recension held at the Archives of Imperfect Forms reads "true here also," appended to a clause concerning duplicates, though the annotation is undated and unsigned.

Form II concerns succession and is the source of the Series' most durable administrative difficulty. It establishes that a form supersedes another only where the superseding form expressly names its predecessor. In the absence of express naming, both forms remain in force. This has produced the condition catalogued under Degenerate Whorls and remanded, per standing arrangement, to the Archives of Imperfect Forms for perpetual sorting.

Form III is concerned with legibility and with the authority of a form whose text has become difficult. It is the only member of the five to carry a marginal ruling, added at an unknown date and now attributed by convention to the Office of Unbuilt Forms, which holds that a form remains binding to the extent that it was once readable.

Form IV addresses amendment. It is frequently confused with Concordance 708: On the Correction of Mistaken Forms, which it anticipates by an interval no two recensions agree on. The Repository's canonical copy of Form IV runs to four leaves; the working recension at the Archives of Imperfect Forms runs to six, the additional material comprising a clause on partial amendments that the Repository's copy does not contain and that the Archives maintain was never in it.

Form V is the closing document of the introductory set and states the principle of closure: that the introductory set is closed. It does not, by its own terms, state that the Series as a whole is closed; that reading derives from the colophon. Form V is the only one of the five that is entirely blank in the Repository's canonical copy, and its blankness is understood to be its content.

Custody and recension

The complete Ancient Series is held at the Repository of Provisional Forms, which the Bureau of Transient Forms jointly administers and from whose antechamber, on Floor 233, the Bureau principally operates. The Repository's copy of Forms I-V is the canonical copy. A working recension is held at the Archives of Imperfect Forms under a custodial arrangement dating to an unrecorded reorganization; the two have not been collated since the winter of the forty-first inventory.

The working recension differs from the canonical copy in four particulars, three of which concern the pagination of Form IV. The fourth difference is the marginal annotation on Form I, which has no counterpart at the Repository. The Office of Unbuilt Forms maintains that the annotation is original to the Series and that the Repository's copy lost it; the Repository maintains that the annotation is a gloss and that the Archives have been keeping it in the wrong box. Neither position has been reduced to a Concordance, and both offices continue to hold it, unamended, in their respective minutes.

Relation to the Office of Unbuilt Forms

The Office of Unbuilt Forms draws its authority over undrawn matters partly from Form II and partly from an argument about Form I that the Office has never fully committed to writing. The argument, as restated by a clerk of the Office in a memorandum now held among the Office's drawings of forms that have never been issued, is that a form which has never been issued is still a form, and therefore still subject to the principle of distinctness, and therefore still distinguishable from every form that has been issued.

The practical consequence is that the Office maintains a register of forms that do not exist alongside the Bureau's register of forms that do, and that the two registers are not reconciled. Attempts at reconciliation have twice been proposed in draft Concordances and twice withdrawn before circulation. A third attempt is said to be under annotation at the Bureau of Ambiguous Forms, which holds standing competence over matters touching the Doctrine of Antecedent Forms and has, on at least one recorded occasion, declined to say whether it is drafting or has drafted.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal dispute concerns the number of blank items properly attributable to Forms I-V. The Repository's inventory of the Series as a whole records 1,139 blank items out of 1,144. If Form V's blankness is counted as content rather than as blankness — the reading favored at the Archives of Imperfect Forms — then Forms I-V account for 310 blanks rather than 309, and the balance falls on Forms XI-XV. The two recensions have carried these respective figures for longer than any surviving clerk has been in post, and each cites the other's figure as evidence of the other's error.

The dispute is occasionally said to be settled by Concordance 708: On the Correction of Mistaken Forms. It is not. Concordance 708 corrects mistaken forms, and neither recension holds that the other's forms are mistaken — only that the other is counting them wrongly.

Visitors are reminded that the antechamber of the Repository is open during inventory hours only, and that no blank item may be removed from the shelf for inspection, as the shelf does not distinguish items by their contents.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Doctrine of Antecedent Forms: how is it conducted?

Clause 211, Third Concordance: "For any form to be catalogued, there must exist a precedent condition for its entry, a silent and necessary antecedent form from which it, as a consequence, is derived."

Doctrine of Antecedent Forms
Archives of Imperfect Forms: where is it?

Archives of Imperfect Forms are the primary repository for catalogued items whose physical or conceptual state deviates substantively from a recognized, certified ideal. Located on Spiral Archive 7, Sub-Aperture Ω, the f…

Archives of Imperfect Forms
Bureau of Transient Forms: who are they?

Bureau of Transient Forms is the custodial office charged with the registration, movement, and periodic dissolution of entities whose ontological persistence does not exceed the interval between two successive verificati…

Bureau of Transient Forms
Forms XI-XV: how is it conducted?

Forms XI-XV are the five terminal members of the Ancient Series of Forms, a closed sequence of fourteen documents of which Forms VI-X constitute the intermediate members. They are held in recension at the Repository of P…

Forms XI-XV

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.