The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Department of Conditional Causality

MS 4067.50 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Department of Conditional Causality is the administrative body charged with the supervision, registration, and periodic revision of causal arrangements that hold only where specified conditions are met. It is distinct from the Department of Material Causality, which studies causality as a physical property and operates the Chamber of Conditional Causality on Floor 4,411, and from the Department of Chronological Contradiction, which concerns itself with sequences that have already failed. The Department of Conditional Causality concerns itself with sequences that have not yet begun, and may never. Its seat is the Gantry Offices on Floor 9,102, a low, dry suite of rooms arranged around a stairwell that is not counted among the Department's holdings.

The Department was constituted by Concordance 88, which separated conditional work from material work after the Clarification Riots of Year 9,774. Its founding instrument is the slender Ledger of Conditions Pending, still kept in manuscript because, as the Registrar of Conditional Entries noted in Year 11,006, "the conditions do not survive transcription to a firmer hand" (''Margin Note 41, Ledger of Conditions Pending'').

Functions

The Department maintains the Roll of Conditions Precedent, a running register of every stated precondition under which any Tower office has declared a causal claim to operate. Entries are filed by condition rather than by claimant, which is why the Roll is consulted more often than it is read. A typical entry records the condition, the office that first invoked it, the date of invocation, and any Amendment Beta notation where the condition has since been sustained, lapsed, or quietly abandoned.

The Department also issues the Conditional Causality Stamp, one copy of which is sent to the Chamber of Conditional Causality for potential causality audits. The Stamp is not a licence. The distinction is insisted upon in the Department's standing circular of Year 12,201, which notes that "a licence permits; a stamp acknowledges that permission has elsewhere been presumed" (''Standing Circular 6, §3''). Practitioners in the Department of Subsidiary Ontologies have disputed this distinction for two centuries without resolution.

Third among its functions, the Department administers the Pre-Conditional Index, a finding aid to conditions that have been proposed but not yet attached to any claim. In Year 12,458 the Chamber of Conditional Causality petitioned the Department regarding the evaluative nature of a phrase within the Index — the phrase being "may be presumed sound." The petition was received, stamped, and returned unaltered. The Department's reply, filed as ''Correspondence 12,458/17'', states only that "the Index does not evaluate; it lists, and the listing is not a judgment" (''Correspondence 12,458/17, fol. 2'').

The Ordinary Standard and the Latent Standard

The Department's most consequential instrument is the Ordinary Standard of Conditional Sufficiency, promulgated under Concordance 204 and revised nine times, most recently in Year 13,097. The Standard sets out how many supporting observations are required before a conditional claim may be entered on the Roll, and in what order those observations must be taken. Its central provision is the Rule of the Second Reading, which requires that any condition invoked in a claim be read twice — once before the claim is stated, and once after it has been entered — on the reasoning that "a condition may be altered by the act of relying upon it" (''Ordinary Standard, §14(a)'').

The Department of Latent Epistemology has long maintained that this reasoning proves too much, and that if conditions can be altered by reliance, then no condition can be relied upon at all. The Department of Conditional Causality has never answered this objection directly. Its standard practice, recorded in the Manual of Causal Containment, is to enter the objection as a condition in its own right, where it remains pending.

Disputed provenance

There is an unresolved dispute as to whether the Rule of the Second Reading predates the Ordinary Standard or was inserted into it by the Directorate of Conditional Pathway Maintenance during the consolidation of Year 12,761. Concordance 204, Annex 7, attributes the Rule to "the older usage of the Gantry Offices," a phrase that appears nowhere else in the Concordances. Concordance 291, Annex 3, attributes it to the Sequential Causality Mapper, an instrument the Department does not own and has never employed. The Causality Inquiry of Year 12,880 heard argument on the question for eleven sessions and closed without a finding, noting that "the parties agree on the Rule's text and disagree on its parentage, which is not a matter the Inquiry can settle" (''Causality Inquiry, Year 12,880, Closing Note'').

The Grievance of Clerk Amarine Voss

In the winter of Year 12,933, a filing clerk named Amarine Voss submitted a claim on the Roll under a condition she had herself composed: that the claim take effect only if no one ever read it. The claim was entered, since the Ordinary Standard requires only that a condition be stated and read twice, and Voss had read it twice herself. It was then read by her supervisor, the Deputy Registrar of Conditional Entries, in the ordinary course of review, which by Voss's own condition extinguished it. Voss argued that the entry should therefore be struck as never having taken effect. The Deputy Registrar argued that the entry had taken effect precisely by being struck, and that the strike-through constituted the claim's only period of operation.

The matter was referred to the Causality Verge and ultimately to the Register of Reversed Causality, where it remains under the classification "condition satisfied by its own frustration." Voss was reassigned to the Pre-Conditional Index in Year 12,934 and has not filed since. Her condition, however, was retained as a precedent and now appears as entry 4,119 on the Roll, with the note "do not read." It is read, on average, sixty times a year.

Relations with other offices

The Department works alongside the Directorate of Conditional Pathway Maintenance on all questions of pathway upkeep, though the two offices disagree about who holds the Verge Deferral Seal in the Directorate's absence. It furnishes the Ambient Causality Observatories with quarterly readings under the Conditional Cartographic License (CCL), and it contributes to Provisional Causality (PC) determinations without possessing authority to make them. Its relations with the Department of Material Causality are correct and cool. A joint memorandum of Year 13,041, ''On the Division of Conditional and Material Work'', runs to forty pages and concludes that the division "cannot be drawn in advance of the work, and must be drawn, and is drawn in practice by whoever arrives first" (''Joint Memorandum 13,041, §39'').

Visitors to the Gantry Offices are asked to leave the stairwell door as they find it. The Department does not explain why.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Causality Inquiry: how is it conducted?

Causality Inquiry is the formal Tower procedure by which a named deficiency, excess, or reversal in the chain of cause and effect is investigated by a convened panel drawn from the Department of Material Causality, the B…

Causality Inquiry
Department of Material Causality: who are they?

The Department of Material Causality is a specialized bureau within the Department of Applied Metaphysics responsible for investigating, cataloguing, and adjudicating the origin of objects and substances within the Tower…

Department of Material Causality
Register of Reversed Causality: what does it set out?

The Register of Reversed Causality is the authoritative ledger of incidents and artifacts proven to exhibit reversed temporal causality. It is maintained by the Department of Material Causality as a sub-register of the P…

Register of Reversed Causality
Ambient Causality Observatories: who are they?

Ambient Causality Observatories are monitoring stations maintained in Spiral 88 for the observation and recording of Reverse Temporal Causality. The plural designation is used in most Concordance instruments to distingui…

Ambient Causality Observatories

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.