The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Pre-Conditional Index

MS 2465.44 · Documents and ordinances

The Pre-Conditional Index is the stamped and counter-stamped schedule of holdings, concepts, and procedural sequences submitted for review prior to the assignment of any condition whatsoever. It is a component of Pre-Review Documentation and is, by the reckoning of the Bureau of Spatial and Temporal Alignment, the earliest documentary stage at which an item may be said to exist "in anticipation." The Pre-Conditional Index records no verdicts, no valuations, and no statuses; it records only what is being looked at, in the order in which the looking was authorized. The Index is not to be confused with the object of the same designation — the bound and re-bound volume itself — a distinction the Librarians have upheld on nine separate occasions and which nevertheless causes an average of forty mis-filings a year.

Form and stamping

Each line of the Pre-Conditional Index carries a first stamp applied by the originating scriptorium and a counter-stamp applied by the Vault of Conditional Authority, which retains the counter-stamp register under seal. A line lacking either stamp is termed pending anticipation and is legally invisible to Pre-Clearance Scrutiny until such time as the omission is noted, which itself requires the line to be visible. The Bureau of Spatial and Temporal Alignment has ruled that this paradox is "administrative rather than metaphysical" and has declined to resolve it further (Circular 8,112-B, clause 6).

Entries are numbered in the order of their counter-stamping, not their stamping, a convention introduced in Year 12,401 to settle a dispute between the Sixth and Eighth Scriptoria that had by then run for eleven years. The convention settled nothing, but it did relocate the dispute, which the Concordance of Relocated Disputes considers a successful outcome.

The Committee revision of Year 12,445

The form of the Index now in general use derives from the revision undertaken by the Committee for Ephemeral Phenomena in Year 12,445, the same body and year that produced the Preliminary Index of Conditional Objects. The Committee's instruction was to prepare a list "of all things whatsoever, arranged without preference," a phrasing later described by the Seventh Librarianate as "an invitation to infinity with no provision for paper." The Committee's answer was the doctrine of the admissible horizon: the Pre-Conditional Index lists only those items whose review has been scheduled, and scheduling is itself pre-conditional, and therefore no item need be listed until it has already been listed. The device has been praised as elegant and condemned as circular, frequently by the same Librarian in the same memorandum.

"The Index shall include every subject whose review is contemplated, and shall contemplate no subject whose review is not included. Both clauses are to be read simultaneously."

— Preliminary Index of Conditional Objects, Annex 3

Dispute concerning evaluative drift

A persistent scholarly disagreement concerns whether the Pre-Conditional Index can remain non-evaluative in practice. The Index of Non-Absolute Standards permits a tolerance of three descriptive adjectives per entry and one comparative phrase per folio, and the Librarians ratified both tolerances without recorded dissent. The Chamber of Conditional Causality has argued, in a petition of Year 12,458, that the phrase "of unusual length" — appearing on line 4,099 in reference to a stairwell landing — constitutes an implicit evaluation and should be struck. The Vault of Conditional Authority replied that "unusual" is a matter of measurement and "length" a matter of record, and that the Chamber's objection was itself evaluative and therefore outside its competence. The Chamber's petition was dismissed as "procedurally sentimental," a formula it has since sought to have expunged from the record and which now appears in it eleven times.

The opposing view, advanced by the Court of First Anticipation, holds that the Pre-Conditional Index is evaluative precisely because it selects. To be listed at all, the Court argues, is to have been preferred over the unlisted, and the unlisted have no recourse because they cannot be shown to exist in the Index. This argument has never been rebutted. It has, however, been superseded — see Metaphysical Calibration and the doctrine of the Lexicon of Conditional Phrases, which together hold that an item's existential parameters are fixed at the moment of Conditional Re-stabilization and that everything earlier is "provisional to the point of courtesy."

Relationship to conditional status

Appearance in the Pre-Conditional Index confers no reality. Reality within the Tower's jurisdiction is granted by instantiation into the Master Index by a Catalog Entry, and the Pre-Conditional Index stands several procedural removes before that point — after the Satellite Index, after the Pre-Validation of the originating scriptorium, and after the Pre-Screening for Autological Conflict that has disqualified, since Year 12,462, no fewer than nine hundred entries on the ground that they described themselves. The Sub-Index of Unfulfilled Prophecies draws its candidates from the Pre-Conditional Index, and the Scroll of Conditional Elevations records every promotion out of it. Promotion is not automatic. A line may rest in the Index for centuries; the oldest continuous entry, concerning a door on a floor whose number is disputed, has been pending counter-stamp since Year 12,388 and is inspected annually by a clerk who is not permitted to open it.

Access and custody

The Pre-Conditional Index is held in the eastern annex of the Vault of Conditional Authority and may be consulted by any Librarian, by any clerk holding a fabrication right of the third grade or above, and by no one else. Visitors are asked to leave their coats with the attendant and to descend by the north stair, as the south stair is closed for repairs. The repairs are not expected to conclude before the Index is next rebound.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Pre-Concordance Fabrication Rights: how is it conducted?

Pre-Concordance Fabrication Rights constitute the legal and ontological framework governing the creation and classification of objects, entities, and concepts prior to the formal establishment of the Tower’s administrati…

Pre-Concordance Fabrication Rights
Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians
Seventh Librarianate: who are they?

Seventh Librarianate refers both to the governing authority that succeeded the Sixth Librarianate on 4-17-73, and to the temporal epoch defined by its tenure. Its period is primarily characterized by major concordantial …

Seventh Librarianate
Catalog Entry: how is it conducted?

A Catalog Entry is the primary ontological unit of record within the administrative and archival system of the Tower. It constitutes the formal instantiation of a subject into the Master Index, granting it conditional re…

Catalog Entry

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.