Progressive Identification
MS 8603.53 · Practices and doctrines
Progressive Identification is the class of procedures by which a petitioner, an object, or a lapse in the record is progressively identified — that is, identified in stages, each stage superseding the last without formally retiring it. It is distinguished from ordinary identification chiefly by the fact that it does not conclude. The Progressive Indexers' Collective holds that this is a virtue; the Progressive Indexing Guild held, during its brief existence, that it was a filing problem dressed as a doctrine.
Progressive Identification is governed in the first instance by Section A (Petitioner Identification) of the standing identification code, which requires the filing of a Petitioner Identification Dossier before any stage may begin. In practice the dossier is filed at Stage Two, because the petitioner has not yet been identified at Stage One.
Stages
The stages are not numbered in the Concordances; they are lettered, and then numbered within the lettering, and then — following the recension of Floor 4,412 — occasionally both. The working sequence used by most floors of the middle band is as follows:
- Preparatory identification, in which the subject is described but not named.
- Provisional identification, in which the subject is named but not described.
- Substantive identification, in which the subject is both named and described, and the discrepancy between the two is logged.
- Consolidation into a collective entry, at which point the subject may be referred to by any of its prior designations.
Stage Four is the only stage with a completion ceremony, and the ceremony is not required. The Progressive Unraveling is often mistaken for a fifth stage; it is not a stage but a condition, and floors that treat it as a stage tend to stop at it.
Relation to the isolation and containment cycle
Progressive Identification is preceded, in every recorded instance, by Identification Amp Isolation, the practice by which a subject's identifying features are held apart from the subject for the duration of the preliminary work. Only after isolation is certified may Phase Alpha Identification Amp Containment begin, and only after containment may the stages proceed. The order is stated plainly in the schedule: isolation, containment, identification. Floor 6,118 inverted the order during the winter of the Third Cycle and produced four thousand dossiers identifying subjects that had never been isolated; the dossiers were correct and unusable.
"A subject contained before it is isolated is a subject identified before it is known, which is to say not identified at all but merely named twice."
— Progressive Indexers' Collective, Circular 31, para. 7
The related process of Identification of a Verification Lapse is frequently confused with Progressive Identification by readers of the short concordances. The distinction is that a lapse is identified once, in retrospect, and then closed; a progressive identification is reopened at each stage and closed only by consolidation.
The dispute over Section A
Scholars disagree on whether Section A is constitutive of Progressive Identification or merely evidentiary. The reading favoured by the Progressive Cartography School treats the Dossier as a map of the petitioner, useful for orientation and never identical to the ground. Their rivals in the Chronological Purist School — whose position is set out most fully in the Pedantic Gradient — insist that a petitioner not fully described in the Dossier cannot be progressively identified at all, and that a partial Dossier yields a partial petitioner.
The Progressive Indexers' Collective has declined to resolve the question, noting only that it receives Discrepancy Reports on both readings and finds them equally well formatted. A separate jurisdictional question, referred to the Collective in the matter of Concordance 89, remains open.
Notable incident: the Fourth Band, Floor 2,209
In the winter of the year indexed 44,091 — a date the Progressive Lattice records as a Thursday — the identification clerks of Floor 2,209 undertook to identify a single petitioner progressively through all four stages without interruption. At Stage Three the petitioner was found to be two petitioners, one of whom had been filed under the other's Dossier. Both were consolidated into a single collective entry, which then petitioned on its own behalf. The Keeper of Provisional Holdings was asked to determine whether the entry or its constituent parts held the right of petition, and referred the matter upward, where it remained for nine years.
The floor subsequently adopted a standing rule, still in force: no identification is to be begun after the lamps are trimmed, as the clerks cannot see the second petitioner in the dark.
Criticism
The principal objection to Progressive Identification is that no entry produced by it is ever final, and that the archive therefore accumulates provisional holdings faster than it can consolidate them. The Progressive Indexing Guild made this objection its founding grievance, contesting the promotion of the designation Dynamic Status Flux to the Third Concordance, on the ground that a status which is always in flux cannot be progressively identified in any stage that could be cited. The Guild was dissolved within the latter half of the same Cycle, but its objection was absorbed rather than answered: the Progressive school now maintains that the absence of a terminus is not a defect of identification but its defining characteristic, and that the Present Era (Ongoing) is precisely the era in which every subject remains, correctly, at Stage Three.
Referential Sprawl and Metric Dissipation are the two documented failure modes of the practice. The first occurs when a subject acquires more designations than it has stages to hold them; the second when the stages consume more of the subject than the subject had. Both are reportable, and both are reported.
See also
-
MS 8387.28
Section A (Petitioner Identification)
Section A (Petitioner Identification) designates the foundational procedural layer within the Second Concordance that establishes …
-
MS 7041.57
Third Concordance, Annex 17
Third Concordance, Annex 17 is the annex of the Third Concordance that governs Self-Negating Morphologies — forms, substances, and…
-
MS 3323.26
The Petitioner's Ink
The Petitioner's Ink is the collective designation for the three inks permitted to enter a Petitioner Identification Dossier at th…
-
MS 1767.16
Cycle of Identification
Cycle of Identification refers to the formal administrative period during which a petitioner's existence and categorical attribute…
-
MS 1343.31
Axis Identification
Axis Identification is the procedure by which an axis met in transit, in storage, or in the course of a petitioner's approach is a…
-
MS 2603.31
Petition for the Authorization to Petition (Ref. #PR-001)
The document, comprising twelve clauses and three annexes, was submitted by a petitioner identified only as Clerk Thelon of the Su…
Referenced by
- MS 4356.53 Petitioner Identification
- MS 9749.92 Progressive school
- MS 7652.42 Petitioner
Readers also asked
Pedantic Gradient: where is it?
The Pedantic Gradient is a quantifiable phenomenological zone within Sub-basement Theta characterized by a progressive and non-linear increase in descriptive precision, contextual qualification, and taxonomic subdivision…
Pedantic GradientProgressive Lattice: how is it conducted?
The Progressive Lattice is a shelving, classification, and logical referential framework employed within the Tower for holdings deemed to possess complex, non-linear, or ontologically unstable properties. Unlike traditio…
Progressive LatticePhase Alpha Identification Amp Containment: how is it conducted?
Phase Alpha Identification Amp Containment is the provisional custody practice applied to phenomena that have cleared Identification Amp Isolation but have not yet entered the formal opening of the Notification Amp Seque…
Phase Alpha Identification Amp ContainmentThird Concordance: what does it set out?
The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…
Third ConcordancePassages cited from this record
-
A subject contained before it is isolated is a subject identified before it is known, which is to say not identified at all but merely named twice.
Progressive Indexers' Collective, Circular 31, para. 7
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6397.69 Third Cycle
Because you consulted