Preservation of the Justification Matrix
MS 0301.28 · Practices and doctrines
Definition
The Preservation of the Justification Matrix is the set of standing obligations under which the Justification Matrix is copied, verified, sealed, and transmitted between the offices that hold it. It is not itself a document; the phrase appears in the Third Concordance as a heading and has been treated ever since as though it were a body of law. The Preservation is administered jointly by the Chamber of Recursive Justification and the Academy of Recursive Jurisprudence, whose respective claims over the matter have never been reconciled. The Preservation exists because the Justification Matrix is amended more often than it is read. Each amendment renders existing copies provisional, and a provisional copy cannot be cited in a Factual Matrix. The practical consequence is that the Tower maintains a rolling programme of recension, under which the authoritative text of the Matrix is reissued at intervals and all lesser copies are recalled.Recensions
Four recensions of the Justification Matrix are recognised. The First and Second are held in the scriptoria of the Chamber and are not consulted. The Third was struck under the Third Concordance itself and remains the operative text. The Fourth was attempted twice and abandoned both times. The First Recension is notable for having been copied correctly. This is recorded as an irregularity, since no subsequent recension has been; the incident is discussed at length in Cross-Reference Matrix P-V/2 without any conclusion being reached. The Fourth attempt, conducted in the winter of the Long Corridor, failed when the copyists discovered that clause 4 of the Third Recension had been transcribed twice in their exemplar and not at all in the source. The discrepancy was reported to the Academy, which ruled that a clause copied twice is still one clause, and that a clause missing entirely is merely absent. The Fourth Recension was accordingly declared complete and then withdrawn the following week.Sealing and transmission
A sealed copy of the Justification Matrix bears the mark of the office that produced it, a date, and a count of its clauses. The count is the disputed element. The Chamber maintains 341 clauses; the Academy maintains 342, including a clause on the admissibility of clause counts, which the Chamber holds to be a marginal note and not a clause. Both figures appear on sealed copies currently in circulation. Copies move between floors in the care of the office of the Under-Curator of Slips, whose runners are permitted to carry no more than four sealed codices at a time. This limit was imposed after an incident in which a runner descending to the archive annex produced eleven copies from one satchel, none of which matched each other or the exemplar. The runner was not disciplined; the copies were. Visitors to the scriptoria are admitted on the second and sixth days of the week and may not touch a wet seal.The disputed authority
The Academy of Provisional Knowledge holds that the Preservation of the Justification Matrix is an operational matter falling within its remit as defined by the Matrix itself, and therefore that it may set the intervals of recension without reference to the Chamber. The Chamber holds that the Matrix cannot define the terms of its own preservation, since a document governing its own custody would need to be preserved before it could govern, citing The Problem of Infinite Regress. The Authorization Matrix has, at various points, cited both positions in support of the same authorization. This is not considered an error. Under the Second Concordance, an Authorization Matrix may cite a validated Justification Matrix; under the Fourth Concordance, it may cite the office that validated it. The two Concordances were never harmonised, and both readings remain in use.Notation and citation
Preserved copies of the Justification Matrix are cited by recension, clause, and seal. Example: Third Recension, clause 212, seal of the Chamber, 19th of the Frost Quarter. Citations omitting the seal are treated as citations of no document at all, a rule that has generated more correspondence than any other provision of the Preservation. The Notification Matrix is used to announce new recensions. Notices of the Fourth Recension were issued and then withdrawn, but the withdrawal notices themselves were sealed under the Third Recension's numbering and therefore remain technically in force. The offices receiving them have been instructed to ignore them, in writing, twice. A full inventory of currently sealed copies is maintained as an annex to Preservation Directive 889 and updated quarterly. The annex currently lists 1,406 copies. The scriptoria hold 1,409.See also
-
MS 1825.60
The Justification Matrix
The Justification Matrix is the regulatory schedule, maintained under the Third Concordance, that fixes the categories into which …
-
MS 1115.39
Form RV-9: Request for Recursive Validation
Form RV-9: Request for Recursive Validation is the standard instrument by which a party asks that a holding be validated, and simu…
- MS 7448.39 Recursive Dependency Matrix
-
MS 7271.70
Comparative Matrix
The Comparative Matrix is a working instrument of the Librarians' cataloguing order, produced as the direct outcome of Comparative…
-
MS 4371.83
Standard Authentication Matrix Sam
The Standard Authentication Matrix (universally abbreviated SAM, and never "the SAM" in formal citation) is the prescribed instrum…
-
MS 8745.48
Adjacency Matrix
The Adjacency Matrix is the sole authoritative registry of navigable connections within the Tower, maintained under the terms of R…
Referenced by
- MS 1901.61 Superintendent of Permissible Exceptions
- MS 2526.77 Standard Authentication Matrix
Readers also asked
Justification Matrix: what does it set out?
Justification Matrix is a regulatory document, created under the auspices of the Third Concordance, which defines the permissible categories of rationale for submitting a Form RV-9: Request for Recursive Validation. It i…
Justification MatrixAcademy of Provisional Knowledge: who are they?
The Academy of Provisional Knowledge is a statutory body established by the Fifth Concordance, Annex VII, Clause 3, to administer the principle that all definitive knowledge arises from a preceding state of qualified unc…
Academy of Provisional KnowledgeFourth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…
Fourth ConcordanceChamber of Recursive Justification: who are they?
The Chamber of Recursive Justification is a procedural facility on Forty-Seventh Floor dedicated to the adjudication of petitions where the validity of a Recursive Validation itself is placed in question, thereby initiat…
Chamber of Recursive JustificationBecause you consulted