The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Phenomenological Inventories

MS 4817.62 · Documents and ordinances

The Phenomenological Inventory is the terminal documentary artefact of The Phenomenological Sequence, the procedure by which a subject is processed and assigned Phenomenological coefficients. Concordance 89 records that the Sequence's final output "must be a validated Phenomenological Inventory" (Concordance 89, Annex 2), a formulation that has been read strictly, loosely, and — on one celebrated occasion — backwards. An Inventory is not a description of a subject. It is a fixed count of what a subject is composed of, expressed in coefficients and lodged with the Phenomenological Spire for validation.

Form and construction

Inventories are drawn on ruled stock in sixteen parts, of which the first is a header bearing the subject's provisional designation and the last is the seal of the draughting office. The intervening fourteen parts are coefficient tables, and it is an old joke among the scriptoria that the tables are short and the header is contested. Each part is initialled separately; an Inventory that is initialled throughout but lacks a stamp is called a walking inventory and may be moved between floors without a completed attestation, a concession granted in the winter of floor 1,104 and never rescinded.

Before an Inventory can be validated it must pass through Phenomenological Calibration, from which a Phenomenological Signature is computed. No Inventory enters the archive unsigned. The Spire's validation desk returns any document lacking a signature with a slip reading, in its entirety: "Unattributed."

Validation and the Spire

The Phenomenological Spire validates Inventories only after calibration, and it validates them in batches on the ninth and twenty-third of each month, except when either date falls on a Quiet Ninth. Applicants who submit on a Quiet Ninth receive their Inventory back unchanged, with the ninth struck through and the twenty-third written above it in red ink by an officer who does not sign.

Validation is not approval. An Inventory may be validated while containing coefficients the Spire considers wrong, and frequently is. What validation certifies is that the document was properly made, not that it is properly true. The distinction was set out at length in Librarian Ossen Vane's memorandum of 4 March, year 991, which concluded: "We certify the vessel. Whether it holds anything is a question for the vessel."

Unfinished Inventories

An Inventory abandoned mid-draught is not destroyed. It becomes one of the Unfinished Inventories, held in the Annex of Partial Compositions on floor 640 until such time as the Annual Reconciliation of Inventories provides a procedural pathway to completion. Some have awaited completion since before the Annex was built. The oldest, designated U-1, is a single ruled line and a header reading "subject indeterminate."

Discrepancies and reconciliation

Where a validated Inventory contradicts a subject's recorded Phenomenological description, the matter proceeds to Phenomenological Reconciliation, an administrative procedure for resolving discrepancies between recorded description and measured coefficients. Reconciliation sheets are reviewed against Concordance 89. A sheet returned unreconciled is stapled to its Inventory and the pair filed under the subject's lowest coefficient, a filing convention that has produced the Tower's largest single holding: the Sub-Baseline Stacks, floor 2.

Scholarly disagreement

Two recensions of Concordance 89 govern Inventory practice, and they disagree on the central question. The earlier recension holds that an Inventory is descriptive — a record of what was found in the subject at the time of processing. The later recension holds that it is constitutive — that the subject is what the Inventory counts, and no more.

"The subject shall be taken as composed of such parts as the Inventory enumerates, and of no others, the remainder being reserved."

— Concordance 89, Second Recension, Clause 14

Under the constitutive reading, a mis-drawn Inventory does not misdescribe its subject; it makes a smaller one. The Bureau of Phenomenological Designations has never ruled on which recension is in force, noting in its bulletin of year 1,003 that "both are in force, in the sense that both are cited." Practitioners have learned to draw the tables generously.

The disagreement produced the Tower's most cited clerical grievance. Clerk Amaranth Dey, draughting on floor 1,109 in the winter of year 1,012, omitted the seventh part of an Inventory through no fault of her own — the stock had been cut short by the Scriptorium of the Lower Ninth — and the subject was subsequently found to be missing a sense of smell, which the Bureau declined to restore on the grounds that no part of the Inventory had provided for it. Dey's appeal, filed in triplicate, argued that a shortage of paper was not a metaphysical instrument. It was dismissed. Her marginal note survives in the appeal copy: "Then I shall order more paper." She did not.

Retention

Validated Inventories are retained indefinitely on the floor of their validation, and may not be removed except to the Sub-Baseline Stacks or to the reading room, and never both in the same year. Phenomenological Anchoring is administered jointly by the Spire and the Office of Anchored Holdings for those Inventories whose subjects have since been lost; the Anchoring keeps the count standing in the subject's absence, which is the only circumstance in which the Tower permits an Inventory to outnumber what it counts.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Annual Reconciliation of Inventories: how is it conducted?

The Annual Reconciliation of Inventories is the statutory process by which the provisional holdings recorded in the Indexers Guild's working registers are formally aligned with the master ledgers maintained by the Librar…

Annual Reconciliation of Inventories
Phenomenological: how is it conducted?

Phenomenological (Adjective) denotes the quality, nature, or characteristic of pertaining to a systemized cataloguing of experiential properties as defined and regulated by The Phenomenological Sequence. Its usage is exc…

Phenomenological
Unfinished Inventories: how is it conducted?

Unfinished Inventories are procedural holdings that have not completed the full cycle of reconciliation and ratification as defined by the Third Concordance. These inventories exist in a state of legal and logistical lim…

Unfinished Inventories
Phenomenological Reconciliation: how is it conducted?

Phenomenological Reconciliation is the administrative procedure by which a discrepancy between a subject's recorded Phenomenological Description and the Phenomenological coefficients subsequently measured for that subjec…

Phenomenological Reconciliation

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.