The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Petition of 371

MS 2173.96 · Documents and ordinances

The Petition of 371 is a bound compilation of one thousand and forty consecutively numbered petitions, filed in a single lean winter at Stairwell Meridian and subsequently bound, sealed, and shelved as a unitary instrument. It is the only petition in the catalogue whose object was the withdrawal of all petitions, including itself, and it is the only such instrument classified simultaneously as a petition and as a Concordance amendment in draft. It is held at the Sub-Basement Registry under shelfmark SB-371/1–1040, and may be consulted by any clerk holding a current Form PA-1, though not on the day it was filed.

Origin at Stairwell Meridian

In the winter of the 371st Synodic Cycle, a cold season of unusual length, the clerks of Stairwell Meridian found themselves petitioning at a rate that outstripped the Registry's capacity to receive. The intake desk recorded four hundred filings in the first month alone, most of them trivial, several duplicative, and one a request that the desk's hatch be oiled. Each was entered, numbered, and routed in accordance with Section C, and each routing generated a routing notice, and each routing notice was itself filed as a petition, a circularity familiar from the Petitions of Infinite Regress and never successfully closed.

The intake clerk of record was Clerk Ompel, then in her ninth year at Stairwell Meridian and the author of two prior instruments of note. On the 1040th filing of the season she stopped entering petitions individually and instead accepted a single bound sheaf, written in one hand, which requested that all petitions filed in that stairwell during the cycle be struck, that the act of striking be considered a petition, and that this final petition be struck first. The Registrar's receiving stamp reads Accepted without prejudice to the Receiver. Clerk Ompel has consistently maintained she did not read past the first page.

Structure and internal numbering

The Petition of 371 is not a single text but a sequence. Leaves 1 through 1039 are the ordinary petitions of the winter, left intact; leaf 1040 is the striking clause. Read in order, the document petitions for one thousand and thirty-nine things and then for nothing. Read in reverse, a practice permitted under Recension Order 14 but discouraged for instruments over five hundred leaves, it is a request that nothing be struck, followed by one thousand and thirty-nine specific requests, the last of which is for the hatch to be oiled.

"Where an instrument seeks the general annulment of filings, the annulment shall be applied to the instrument in the order in which the instrument applies it to itself."

— Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, clause 3

Because clause 3 directs that the striking clause be executed first, the striking clause strikes itself before it can strike anything, leaving the preceding one thousand and thirty-nine petitions valid and the whole binding invalid. This is the reading favoured by the Guild of Dormant Scribes, who have transcribed the document four times and regard the fourth transcription as definitive. The Office of Precedential Custody disputes it, holding that a clause struck before execution cannot be struck at all, and that the entire volume therefore remains in force.

The Clarification Dispute

That disagreement produced the longest-running controversy associated with the Petition, a twenty-two-year quarrel over whether the Office or the Guild holds custodial precedence. It was eventually submitted to Adjudication by Counter-Petition, the standard method, and a Counter-Petition for Clarification was filed against a Petition for Clarification that had never been filed but was presumed pending. The adjudicating Librarian, whose name is not recorded in the minutes in accordance with the practice of her chamber, resolved the matter by declaring both readings correct and appointing a third clerk to keep both. The third clerk, Under-Registrar Veyle, held both readings for eleven years and resigned over a disagreement about shelving.

A separate and unrelated dispute concerns the binding. The volume was bound in oxhide at the Bindery of the Ninth Landing and resewn in the 402nd cycle after the stitching failed along leaves 700–712. The Guild maintains that the resewing was performed without petition, and thus that leaves 700 through 712 are technically loose. The Office has never inspected the stitching. Requests to inspect the stitching must be made in writing and are granted twice yearly, in the second and eighth months.

Relation to the wider petition corpus

The Petition of 371 is frequently cited alongside the Petition for the Authorization to Petition (Ref. #PR-001), filed by Clerk Thelon during the 719th Synodic Cycle and approved after eleven sessions of the Concordance Assembly. The two are related only by convention: Thelon's petition established the procedure by which petitions may be authorized, while the Petition of 371 attempted to establish the procedure by which they may be unmade, and neither document acknowledges the other. The catalogue nevertheless shelves them adjacently, a decision taken by a clerk whose reasoning is not recorded and is now defended as tradition.

Its nearest liturgical relative is the Whispering Atlas Petition, which introduced the Petition Slip for recording subjective experiences of temporal discontinuity. Several of the winter's one thousand and thirty-nine petitions are on slip stock, and at least six report having heard the Petition of 371 being written before it was drafted. These six are filed with the main sequence and are not considered remarkable.

Access and restrictions

The volume is produced to readers in the Reading Room of the Sub-Basement Registry and is not to be removed from the table. It may not be read aloud, on the grounds that the striking clause, read aloud, has twice been taken as spoken and acted upon by clerks passing in the corridor. A notation on the inner cover, in a hand later identified as Clerk Ompel's, reads: If consulted, consult quickly. The Guild of Dormant Scribes has petitioned three times for the notation to be removed. Each petition was filed with the volume and is bound into it, and those three leaves are numbered 1041, 1042, and 1043.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Petition for Clarification: how is it conducted?

The Petition for Clarification is the primary administrative instrument within the Tower for engaging the formal mechanisms of Clarification as defined by the relevant Concordances. It is the procedural entry point for a…

Petition for Clarification
Counter-Petition for Clarification: what does it set out?

Counter-Petition for Clarification is a formal Tower instrument by which a party objects to an extant or pending Petition for Clarification, requesting that the original petition be clarified as to its own clarity. It is…

Counter-Petition for Clarification
Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Section C (Grounds for Petition): how is it conducted?

Section C (Grounds for Petition) is a critical clause within the Third Concordance that enumerates the legally permissible justifications for submitting a Petition to the Librarians. It serves as the definitive filter th…

Section C (Grounds for Petition)

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.