The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Observational Attenuation

MS 0132.81 · Practices and doctrines

Observational Attenuation is the class of attenuation practised upon observations themselves rather than upon the phenomena observed. Where Primary Attenuation reduces the amplitude of a resonance and Procedural Attenuation reduces the authority of a procedure, Observational Attenuation reduces the intensity with which a subject is permitted to be seen — its brightness, its recurrence, and, in closely regulated quantities, its apparent importance. It is administered jointly by Tier Gamma and the standing officers of the Attenuation Galleries, and its hazards are catalogued at length in Title III: On Observational Hazards.

The distinction is one of object, not of method. An Attenuator working Observationally employs the same instruments as any other — the Attenuation Lens, the Axis of Attenuation, the settling tanks of Archival Dust — but directs them at the record of a sighting instead of at the sighting's physical source. A tone that would be attenuated to one Standard Attenuation (SA) in the Attenuation Galleries is attenuated, Observationally, to no more than a remembered tone, and thereafter to the fact that a tone was heard, and thereafter to a marginal note.

Origin and the First Recension

The practice originates in the aftermath of the Great Dimming, when the transfer of predecessor Luminary portraits to the Galleries for contextual attenuation produced an unforeseen surplus: the portraits dimmed, but the volume of testimony concerning their brightness did not. Third Concordance established a committee to consider the difficulty and, as is its habit, established a second committee to consider the first. The eventual instrument, the Ordinance of Diminished Regard (Concordance 14, Annex 2), provided that observations might be attenuated "without prejudice to their having occurred," a formula still recited at the opening of every Observational session.

"An observation attenuated is not an observation retracted. The Tower keeps its sightings; it merely keeps them more quietly."

— Ordinance of Diminished Regard, preamble

Procedure

Work proceeds under the Standing Ordinances of the Attenuation Galleries, which fix seven stages for physical attenuation and permit Observationally a reduced sequence of four: registration, reduction, re-registration, and filing. Reduction is measured against One Standard Attenuation (SA), though Observational work uses the modified scale, 1 SA-O, defined in the Schedule of Observational Scales as the point at which a sighting can still be corroborated by one witness who does not much care for the matter.

The instruments are shared with the Galleries, and the sharing is a chronic grievance. The Attenuation Lens requires bi-weekly polishing, but Observational sessions leave a fine film on the lower element which the Galleries' cleaners refuse to accept as their responsibility. A memorandum of the winter of 14.2, circulated by Under-Clerk Vannic, records that the film "is not dust, is not permitted to be called dust, and has therefore no place in the schedule of cleaning." Vannic's memorandum is appended to nothing and is preserved only because it was filed in the wrong drawer.

Dispute: two standards or one

Whether Observational Attenuation is a distinct practice or merely Resonance Attenuation applied to a delicate subject remains unresolved. The Ninth Concordance treats Observational Attenuation as procedurally continuous with Primary Attenuation and cites the Axis of Attenuation as common instrument; the Eleventh Concordance, at Annex 6, refuses the continuity and asserts that "a sighting has no frequency and cannot be tuned." The Tier Gamma Observational Committee has adjudicated the question four times and reached a different holding on each occasion; its rulings are collected as the Four Settlements and are cited in the alternative, never singly.

The practical consequence is jurisdictional. Observational Attenuation of a phenomenon that also has a physical source requires both offices to sign, and where the offices disagree the signature is held in the Aperture Registry until it lapses. The record of lapsed signatures for 9.7 through 9.9 fills two shelves on Floor 41,012.

Relation to Stabilization and Withdrawal

Observational Attenuation is distinguished from Observational Stabilization, which holds a phenomenon steady rather than reducing it, and from the Enactment of Observational Withdrawal, which removes a subject from view entirely and is reserved to grave cases. Attenuation sits between them and is preferred wherever withdrawal would be read as a judgment. It is also distinguished from Contained Attenuation, which confines a phenomenon spatially; Observational Attenuation confines nothing, and its subjects remain exactly where they were, seen less.

All work in this class is conducted with regard to Observational Neutrality, though the Committee has twice found that attenuating an observation is itself a position taken, and once found that it is not.

Recorded effects and standing notices

Extended subjection to Observational Attenuation produces the effect known as Paling, in which a sighting becomes difficult to describe without the describer qualifying every clause. Paling is monitored under Ongoing Monitoring of the Attenuation Galleries and is not considered harmful. A secondary effect, Benign Recurrence, causes attenuated observations to reappear at intervals of no less than one hundred and forty days and no more than one hundred and forty-two, always at the same hour.

Visitors to Observation tiers are asked not to describe what they have seen until they have left the floor, and not to describe it twice.

The Attenuation Zones bordering the Galleries are excluded from Observational work, as are the Eastern Attenuation Conduit and any stairwell in which a portrait has been hung within the previous year.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Ongoing Monitoring of the Attenuation Galleries: how is it conducted?

Ongoing Monitoring of the Attenuation Galleries refers to the continuous, multi-spectral observation regime mandated by Concordance 33 for the Attenuation Galleries on Floors 88–91 and 112. Its primary function is to det…

Ongoing Monitoring of the Attenuation Galleries
Contained Attenuation: how is it conducted?

Contained Attenuation is the practice of performing Attenuation within a sealed boundary such that the attenuated subject, and everything displaced from it, remains inside the boundary for the full duration of the proced…

Contained Attenuation
One Standard Attenuation (SA): how is it conducted?

One Standard Attenuation (SA) is the base unit of attenuation magnitude adopted by the Seventh Concordance (Annex 12) and reaffirmed, with material amendment, by the Eleventh Concordance. It is defined as the reduction i…

One Standard Attenuation (SA)
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.