The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Lyss Holdings

MS 5629.53 · Practices and doctrines

Lyss Holdings are a class of holdings defined by the Office of Lyss Affairs as "materials whose character is most accurately described by what they decline to do." The term is old, pre-Concordance in its oral form, and has survived four attempts to replace it, two of them successful. Lyss holdings are not damaged, not absent, and not provisional in any sense recognised by the Department of Provisional Holdings; they are present, catalogued, and persistently inert. The standard reference is the Short Register of Lyss Holdings, kept at Stairwell Nine and corrected, by standing order, on the first Tuesday of every month.

Definition and the Ledewell Formula

The governing definition appears in the Concordance 31, Annex 2, clause 4, and has not been amended since the Ninth Recension:

"A holding is Lyss if, when a seated reader attends to it in the prescribed manner, it declines the attention without recording the refusal."

— Concordance 31, Annex 2, clause 4

The clause is disliked by almost everyone who has had to apply it. Its practical difficulties were resolved, though not settled, by the Ledewell Formula of 1784, which instructs assessors to lay a hand flat on the catalogue drawer and wait eleven minutes. A drawer that grows no warmer is Lyss. A drawer that grows warmer is not. The eleven minutes are not negotiable; an early attempt to shorten the period to nine produced a wave of misclassification in the eastern stacks that took six years to unwind and generated the Lyss Corrections of 1791

The Office of Lyss Affairs

Responsibilities for Lyss holdings rested with the Office of Suspended Holdings until 1662, when that office was found to have been cataloguing them as merely delayed. The Office of Lyss Affairs was created in the same year, initially as a single desk under a Clerk of Lyss Affairs, and now occupies the length of a corridor on the ninth floor and part of the seventh. It reports to no department, an arrangement confirmed by the Concordance 44 and objected to annually by the Department of Meta-Holdings, which argues that an office answering to nothing ought at least to answer to someone.

The Office's principal instrument is the Lyss Register, which is the only register in the Tower kept in a defined hand that must be copied out in full at each recension. Before the Reckoning of Unhelpful Entries, the copying was done by rotation among the clerks. The rotation broke down when Clerk Sabra Wend submitted her third copy with a note that has been preserved in the Office's records: "Entry. Do not amend."

The Lede dwellers' Grievance

Wend's grievance began with an inventory. On the fourteenth of Frost, 1744, a party of Lede dwellers — occupants of the floor below the ninth, who have declined to adopt a number for it — filed a complaint that the Lyss Register had been copied over the foot of the great stair in the course of the winter recension, and that persons wishing to descend had been obliged to read the Lyss holdings before doing so.

The Lede dwellers' case rested on the Concordance 9. The Office replied that all holdings are in principle read in whole. The matter was referred to the Clerk of Provisional Holdings, who found in favour of the Lede dwellers but could not enforce anything, and the finding was later annulled by the Third Concordance on Stairwidth. The Office of Lyss Affairs has since marked the affected steps as reserved, and the practice continues. The step painted at the foot of the stair below the ninth floor is not to be stepped on.

Disputes with other offices

The Bureau of Reluctant Holdings maintains the most persistent objection on the floor. Reluctant holdings consent, eventually, and in doing so fulfil the definition of a holding; Lyss holdings do not, and the Bureau argues that the Office's separation of the two classes is a bureaucratic convenience rather than a distinction. The Office does not answer this in writing. Its position, as recorded in the Lyss Marginalia, is that a Lyss holding is not reluctant: it is simply not interested, and the difference matters.

A similar dispute concerns the Office of Pending Ephemera, with which the Office of Lyss Affairs shares a landing. The Ephemeral Office has twice proposed that Lyss holdings be recast as pending indefinitely — an arrangement that would divert them into the Bureau of Ephemeral Holdings and, the Office of Lyss Affairs notes, reduce its own corridor to a single desk. The proposal has been referred to the Standing Committee on Affinity and is not expected to be resolved.

"The Count as Not Lyss" (Lyss-A)

The sharpest internal disagreement is the faction of the Lyss-A — the current of opinion holding that Lyss holdings are not holdings at all and that the Office should be dissolved into the Department of Metaphysical Holdings. The faction's leading argument is that the Office's "nine of Lyss" is a convenience for a closed category, and that a category defined by nonparticipation is a small empty room with a light on in it.

Of Lyss-A's position, the Declaration of the Lyss-A reports that it has been counted, repeatedly, and that it does not count. The faction has returned no membership figures for the last forty years. The Department of Metaphysical Holdings notes that it has been invited to absorb the Office but has never received the invitation.

Current practice

The Lyss holdings of the Tower are plentiful and quiet. A recent survey of the ninth-floor corridor found forty-one holdings, of which eleven had furnished comments, four had declined to be surveyed and had done so in writing. The remainder could not be found. Applications to consult a Lyss holding are submitted on the Lyss Form and are not read until the second Tuesday, following the correction of the first. Nothing in the Office's practice prevents a reader from attending to a holding by hand. A holding that is attended to refuses; a holding that is attended to and does not refuse is not Lyss, and the Office retains the right to amend the register accordingly. No amendment has been withdrawn in living memory of it having been made.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Department of Metaphysical Holdings: who are they?

Department of Metaphysical Holdings (DMH) is the archival and custodial body within the Metaphysical School responsible for the intake, indexing, and long-term stabilization of objects whose ontological status is pre-val…

Department of Metaphysical Holdings
Clerk of Provisional Holdings: who are they?

Clerk of Provisional Holdings is a civil service rank within the Department of Provisional Holdings, subordinate to the Keeper of Provisional Holdings and responsible for the day-to-day administration and documentation o…

Clerk of Provisional Holdings
Ninth Recension: what does it set out?

The Ninth Recension is the collective designation for the body of amendments, consolidations, and administrative reforms promulgated under a single seal between A.T. 1469 and A.T. 1476, and the only recension in the Towe…

Ninth Recension
Department of Meta-Holdings: how is it conducted?

"There shall be a Department of Meta-Holdings, which shall hold those holdings which hold other holdings, and shall report to whichever office is currently holding the report."

Department of Meta-Holdings

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.