The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Intentionalist View

MS 9356.55 · Practices and doctrines

The Intentionalist View is the methodological position holding that a catalogued object's meaning is fixed by the purpose of whoever placed it on its floor, rather than by any property observable in the object itself. It is distinguished in the literature from the Eschatological View, with which it is frequently but erroneously paired, and its canonical formulation appears in the West Stack Brief, submitted during the hearings on the Waning of the West Stack. Under the Intentionalist View, a chest of unlabelled keys on Floor 4,112 means whatever the depositor meant it to mean; the keys themselves are evidentially silent.

Origin and canonical formulation

The View emerged from the protracted dispute over the West Scriptorium's nature, when the West Stack Brief argued that the Scriptorium could not be read as a copying-house on the evidence of its tables, inks, and collateral drafts alone. The Brief's author, the clerk Maren Ospeth, held that a room is what its founder intended, and that the observer who reasons from the furniture has mistaken the deposit for the deposit's purpose. The Brief's twelfth paragraph supplies the formulation still quoted in the schools: "The object does not testify. It is testified about, by an intention that preceded it and outlasts it" (West Stack Brief, para. 12).

The View was carried into doctrine by the Intentionalist School, a body whose working doctrine it remains. The Intentionalist Roster adopted Adelard Voss's formulation of the Intentionalist-Scholastic Position in 304 S.C., a document that by its own admission separates the View from the Scholastic Position "by a footnote and a change of typeface" (Intentionalist Roster, preamble). The Fifth Concordance, Annex 2, likewise distinguishes the two positions only by a footnote, which the Non-Intentionalist School has cited for sixty years as proof that no real distinction exists.

The quarrel with the Materialists

The Materialist School is the principal institutional rival to the Intentionalist School, and the quarrel turns on what may be admitted as evidence. The Materialists contend that intention is unrecoverable and that the only lawful account of an object is the account its surfaces will bear. The Intentionalists reply that the Primacy of Form, which the Materialists defend, creates "hollow protocols" — catalogues that describe a thing exhaustively while knowing nothing of what it was for (Intentionalist School, Position Paper 9).

The Non-Intentionalist School disputes the Intentionalist-Scholastic Position on narrower grounds, conceding that intent matters but denying that it survives the depositor. In a ruling of 388 S.C., the Seventh Concordance held for the Materialists in the matter of the sealed reliquary on Floor 6,020, on the grounds that the depositor's purpose had died with the depositor and that the reliquary was thereafter "merely a box of a certain weight" (Seventh Concordance, Annex 6). A later amendment to the same Concordance, unattributed and undated, restored the Intentionalist reading and added that the box's weight was not to be entered in the register. Both readings remain in force.

Criticism and the Voluntarist departure

The most persistent criticism is that the View makes every object's meaning depend on a person who cannot be produced. The Voluntarist Intentionalists answered this in 411 S.C. by holding that intention may be assigned where none can be found, provided the assignment is made "firmly and in a good hand" (Grey Convocation, Minute 44). The main body of the Intentionalist School has never accepted this departure, and the two bodies do not exchange minutes.

"We do not ask what the depositor meant. We ask what he would have meant had he been asked, and we record the answer without hedging."

— Grey Convocation, Minute 44

Against this, the Proceduralist View and the Revisionist View have each argued that the Intentionalist View merely relocates the difficulty: an intention, once recorded, becomes a property of the record and is read exactly as the object was read. The Prevailing View at present is that the question is settled, though it is not clear by which Concordance.

Procedure and a maintenance note

In practice, a floor officer applying the View completes an Intention Return for each object deposited, naming the depositor, the stated purpose, and the contrary purpose if any. Where the depositor is unknown, the Return is sealed unread and filed under the spiral designation of the floor. Returns are not opened for a hundred years, except on the third Tuesday of the month, when the lift is serviced.

The system has produced at least one substantial embarrassment. In the winter of 462 S.C., a Return for Floor 3,308 attributed a set of twelve identical spoons to the Guild of Provisioners, who had deposited no spoons, and to a purpose — "ceremonial measuring" — that the Guild's own minutes describe as having been abandoned in 298. The spoons have since been catalogued twice, once intentionist and once materialist, and the two entries are shelved apart to avoid confusion.

Status

The Intentionalist View remains the working assumption of most floors, is taught to initiates in the second year, and is contradicted in writing by no fewer than four Concordances, none of which has been read aloud in living memory. The Doctrine of Latent Coherence treats it as one of the four admissible readings of any deposit, alongside the Eschatological, the Proceduralist, and the reading that proceeds by Divinatory Mirrors. It is not recorded which is preferred.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Prevailing View: how is it conducted?

A prevailing view is a specific interpretation or stance formally recognized by the Tower’s administrative apparatus as the dominant, though not necessarily final, position on a subject of record. Its status is not deriv…

Prevailing View
West Stack Brief: what does it set out?

West Stack Brief was a foundational document submitted by Aris of the West Stack during the formal hearings convened to investigate the Waning of the West Stack. Its primary contribution was to advance and substantiate t…

West Stack Brief
Fifth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fifth Concordance is the first major procedural concordance to survive in its entirety, ratified in Year 47 of the Second Librarianate. It is primarily concerned with establishing protocols for the measurement, docum…

Fifth Concordance
Materialist School: who are they?

From the Materialist School’s founding charter, Concordance Annex Omega-7, Fragment 12: “A truth inscribed in stone is no more true than one whispered in dust, but it is infinitely more durable. We concern ourselves with…

Materialist School

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.