The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Index-That-Reads-Itself

MS 4313.80 · Practices and doctrines

The Index-That-Reads-Itself is a recursive bibliography held at Shelving Location 44-Rho, occupying eleven board-feet of shelving and consisting entirely of entries that describe the volume in which they are written. It was compiled, according to its title page, by itself, in the forty-first year of the Fourth Concordance, and revised on nine subsequent occasions, none of which its compilers recall authorising.

The Index is classified under Class Psi Phenomena and is not to be confused with the Index of Ambiguous Precedents, which resembles the Index-That-Reads-Itself only in the manner of two mirrors placed at an unfortunate angle. Where AP-88's difficulty is one of reference, the Index-That-Reads-Itself's difficulty is one of consumption: to consult it is to be entered into it.

Description and extent

The work is bound in the standard quarto of the period, in boards darkened along the fore-edge by handling that the Office of Provenance has been unable to attribute to any reader. Its entries proceed alphabetically from a heading that describes the work's front matter and conclude — the last state observed by Isolation of Variance in the winter of the current recension — at an entry for the entry concerning its own conclusion, which was found to require a further entry, and then another. The final gathering is therefore best described as open.

According to the survey conducted by Clerk Amaranth Vell, whose grievance against the shelving sub-office is a matter of record, the Index reads itself aloud at 60 pages per hour in the reading room, and at 12 pages per hour after the lamps are trimmed. Vell's survey was discontinued when she found her own name entered under V.

The reading problem

The Index's central difficulty is set out plainly in its own preface:

"An index of a book must contain an entry for every subject treated within it. The present work treats of the present work. It follows that the present work contains an entry for the entry which contains it, and that the reader who proceeds alphabetically will not reach the end."

— Index-That-Reads-Itself, Preface to the Ninth Recension

The Auscultatory Engine was briefly installed at 44-Rho in an attempt to establish whether the Index's self-reading constituted a resonant pulse admitting of measure. The Engine returned a figure of 1, and the sub-office declined to interpret it further. The Office of Sustained Lamplight has not been asked to improve illumination at 44-Rho, on the grounds that the Index supplies its own.

The Index has been examined alongside The Book That Reads the Reader, and the two are frequently shelved within sight of one another, with unfortunate results for any reader who opens both. A standing notice at the end of the aisle reads: One at a time. This applies to the shelf as well.

Recensions and the open-gathering question

Nine recensions are recorded. The Office of Provenance holds that each recension is a sealed conveyance under Concordance 45, §3, and that the number of generations issuing from it is unlimited — that is, that every recension may beget further recensions without limit, and that a recension so begotten may itself beget. The School of Procedural Purists objects that the Index cannot issue a conveyance to itself, since a conveyance requires a grantor distinct from the grantee, and that the recorded recensions must therefore be forgeries, elegant ones, produced by a hand that was reading as it wrote.

No ruling has settled the matter. A note appended to the shelving record in the hand of the Provost of Precise Ambiguity observes that both positions may be maintained at once provided no one counts the gatherings, and that counting is discouraged in any case because the count has twice been shown to differ from itself.

The Silent Apex dispute

Because the Index-That-Reads-Itself contains nothing but the record of its own contents, a body of opinion holds that it is the closest material approach to the Silent Apex — the theoretical uppermost floor of the master index consisting of nothing but the index of itself. This view was argued at length in the purist recension of the shelving schedule and carried by a margin of one.

The Reference Cross-Index has declined to adopt the identification, noting that whether a practice of cross-reference may constitute a new instrument has never been settled, and that the question of the Index's apex-status is best left as an extension of that unsettled matter rather than a fresh dispute under Clause 7.17. The Quarterly Registry Reconciliation Schedule lists the Index in both columns, with a footnote reading "pending," refreshed each quarter.

Prohibitions and practical notes

Consultation is permitted to any holder of a reader's slip. The following are recorded as prohibited at 44-Rho by order of the aisle warden: marking the text, dog-earing the open gathering, and reading the Index's entry for oneself without first giving a name that appears on no other page. The last prohibition was added after the Vell survey and has not been successfully observed.

The Index is not to be removed from the shelf. It has been removed from the shelf four times, and each removal is itself listed as an entry, which is how the sub-office knows the removals occurred. The fourth removal, in the current recension, remains under inquiry by the Central Index Column, whose file on the matter now describes the file on the matter.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

The Book That Reads the Reader: how is it conducted?

The Book That Reads Its Reader is a Paradoxic artifact held on Floor 302, catalogued under Shelf-Mark 302-Kappa-19 and administered jointly by the Office of the First Reader and the Board of Concordant Arbitration. Bound…

The Book That Reads the Reader
Isolation of Variance: how is it conducted?

Isolation of Variance is the mandatory first procedural stage in any Reconciliation of Authorities or Cartographic Synthesis as defined by the Twelfth Concordance. Codified by the 227th Amendment to the Twelfth Concordan…

Isolation of Variance
AP-88: “The Index of Ambiguous Precedents”: what does it set out?

AP-88: “The Index of Ambiguous Precedents” is the designation given in the Non-Linear Index to a holding that appears, on successive consultations, to be the Index of Ambiguous Precedents itself. The entry is not a summa…

AP-88: “The Index of Ambiguous Precedents”
Taxonomic Purist School: how is it conducted?

The Taxonomic Purist School is a formalized methodological approach within the Purist Faction, primarily concerned with the proper classification, indexing, and cross-referencing of entities, objects, and concepts within…

Taxonomic Purist School

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.