The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Directorate of Recursive Taxonomy

MS 2573.09 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Directorate of Recursive Taxonomy is a standing directorate of the Tower charged with the classification of records that describe their own classification, and with the periodic review of the classifications so produced. It occupies Floors 731 through 735 of the eastern spiral and reports, in a manner that has been disputed since the Second Concordance, to the Curators of the Grand Taxonomy. Unlike the Directorate of Contextual Reconciliation, which resolves conflicts between holdings, the Directorate of Recursive Taxonomy is concerned only with holdings that refer to themselves — a remit it has never fully settled, and about which it maintains a filing cabinet of unresolved correspondence.

The Directorate should not be confused with the Office of Recursive Verification, which audits work already done, nor with the Bureau of Recursive Affairs, which performs Recursive Validation under the Vexian Recursive Taxonomy. The distinction is stated plainly in the Directorate's founding instrument: "The Office verifies what has been classified; the Bureau validates what has been made; this Directorate classifies what classifies." Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, §7

Origin and the Ferrant Recension

The Directorate was constituted in the winter of the year recorded as 1,411 by the calendar of the eastern spiral, following the publication of the so-called Ferrant Recension — a catalogue of 340 records, each of which listed the catalogue among its own entries. The Recension's compiler, the indexer Ovin Ferrant, had intended the work as a demonstration of thoroughness. The result was a document that could not be shelved, because its shelf-mark appeared in its own index, and could not be unshelved, because the index required the shelf-mark to be verified against the volume.

Ferrant petitioned the Librarians for a ruling. The ruling, issued after eleven months, established the Directorate and appointed Ferrant its first Keeper. He held the post for two years and resigned in a document that classified itself as a resignation, which the Directorate declined to accept on the grounds that it had not been classified. Ferrant's appeal on this point remains pending on Floor 733.

Method and the two-stage cycle

Classification within the Directorate proceeds in two stages. In the first, a record is assigned a self-referential class under the terms of Clause 3: Recursive Classification Taxonomy, which governs any record that catalogues its own cataloguing. In the second, the assignment itself is entered as a new record and classified in turn. The second stage is the Directorate's characteristic contribution to the Tower's administrative apparatus, and is the reason its floors are warmer than their elevation warrants.

The cycle terminates when a class is assigned that does not require further classification. No such class has yet been certified. The Directorate's standing note on the matter, posted at the head of the eastern stair, reads: "Terminating classes are under review. Personnel descending the stair are asked to keep left." Directorate of Recursive Taxonomy, Standing Notice 41

Practically, this means the Directorate's registers grow at a rate its scriptorium has twice failed to match. The overflow is stored on Floor 734, which was reclassified as an annex in 1,463 and has since been reclassified sixteen times as an annex to itself.

Jurisdictional dispute with the Curators

The Directorate's subordination to the Curators of the Grand Taxonomy is not accepted by the Directorate. Its position, advanced most fully in the Keeper's memorandum of 1,489, is that a body which classifies classifications cannot be classified by a body whose own classifications it must classify — a formulation the Curators have called "circular" and the Directorate has called "correct."

The Administrative Taxonomy assigns the Directorate to Tier Three, beneath the Curators at Tier Two. The Procedural Taxonomy assigns it to Tier Four. Both taxonomies are in force. When the discrepancy was raised on Floor 731 in the spring of 1,502, the Directorate resolved it by adopting whichever tier was more convenient to the filing at hand, a practice it defended by citing the Curators' own precedent in the Matter of the Unshelved Atlas.

"Where two taxonomies conflict, the conflict is itself a record, and records are classified by this Directorate. We therefore find that we are at Tier Three on Mondays, Wednesdays and alternate Fridays, and at Tier Four otherwise, and that the question of Thursdays is reserved."

— Keeper's Memorandum of 1,489, appended to the register of Floor 731

The Directorate of Boundary Arbitration, asked to arbitrate, declined on the grounds that the dispute was not volumetric. The Directorate of Aperture Oversight declined on the grounds that it was. Neither refusal has been withdrawn.

The Sigma-class question and the Office of Anomalous Taxonomy

The Directorate has never classified a record under the Sigma-class security taxonomy, and maintains that it cannot. The argument, set out by the Office of Anomalous Taxonomy in a brief of 1,518, is that a record which does not exist cannot bear an anomalous classification without violating Clause 3; the Directorate adopted the brief in full and has since cited it in refusal of every sigma-class application brought before it.

Critics observe that the Directorate's own founding case, the Ferrant Recension, concerned a volume whose existence was precisely the point at issue, and that the Directorate resolved it by classifying the volume as extant. The Directorate's answer, given by the Keeper in 1,530, is that the Recension existed at the moment of classification, which is the only moment the Directorate is empowered to consider. This answer has satisfied no one and has ended the correspondence, which the Directorate counts as a success.

Materials classified as Great Taxonomy of Implied Fauna are occasionally routed to Floor 732 in error. They are returned unopened, with a note.

Holdings and access

The Directorate's principal holdings are the Register of Self-Classified Records, in 94 volumes, and the Taxonomy of Unwritten Books, which it administers jointly with the Office of Recursive Verification and has never opened. A third collection, the Register of Registers, is currently a register of one entry, that entry being itself.

Access to Floors 731 through 735 is by petition to the Keeper. Petitions are classified upon receipt, and the petitioner is notified of the classification by a second notice which is itself classified. In practice most petitioners learn the outcome by observing whether they are admitted.

Visitors are reminded that the eastern stair between Floors 731 and 735 is one-way downward after the fourth hour. The Directorate has no view on where the fourth hour falls.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Anomalous Taxonomy: who are they?

Office of Anomalous Taxonomy is the body within the Scriptorium of Jurisprudential Inquiry vested with the sole juridical purview to assign AE designations to subjects catalogued by the Tower. Established by recension of…

Office of Anomalous Taxonomy
Second Concordance: what does it set out?

The Second Concordance was the primary governance document of The Tower from Year 89 of the First Librarianate until its supersession by the Third Concordance in Year 12 of the Second Librarianate. It established the leg…

Second Concordance
Bureau of Recursive Affairs: who are they?

The Bureau of Recursive Affairs is the sub-department within the Office of Perpetual Affairs charged with administering, documenting, and arbitrating all recursive phenomena that manifest within the Tower. Its jurisdicti…

Bureau of Recursive Affairs
Directorate of Contextual Reconciliation: who are they?

The Directorate of Contextual Reconciliation (DCR) is a regulatory sub-directorate operating under the Directorate of Archival Coherence responsible for the identification, quantification, and remediation of Contextual D…

Directorate of Contextual Reconciliation

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.