The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Guild of Theoretical Mechanics Proposals (47 items)

MS 6735.27 · Practices and doctrines

The Guild of Theoretical Mechanics Proposals (47 items) is the bound recension of forty-seven numbered submissions lodged with the Gallery of Unenacted Laws by the Guild of Theoretical Mechanics (GTM) on 12 Ventosus 712.Δ.3. It is the originating instrument of the Guild's present jurisdiction, the standing authority cited by both the Office of Implausible Mechanics and the College of Ontological Mechanics, and the sole document from which Apical Mechanics derives its mandate. Copies are held on Floor 2311 and, in a marginally longer recension, on Floor 4207. The two recensions differ by eleven words. The dispute over those words has run for one hundred and forty years without settlement.

Composition and custody

The items are numbered I to XLVII and are bound in calf over boards with the Guild's spiral seal stamped in red wax on the inner pastedown. Each item runs between four lines and thirty pages; the aggregate is described in the accession ledger as "of middling thickness, unsuitable for use as a doorstop." Items I through XXII are procedural. Items XXIII through XLIV concern the lofting and stamping of apical blueprints. Items XLV through XLVII are, by the Guild's own admission, "reserved and presently empty."

Custody is split. The Gallery holds the original. The Guild holds a working copy, annotated in the hand of the clerk Kael and known accordingly as Kael's Annotations. A third copy was deposited with the Scriptorium of Second Readings in the winter of 714, where it was misfiled under a neighbouring accession of the same thickness and not recovered until 761. The Librarian on duty, Margit Vey, recorded the recovery in a single line: "Found. It had been with the hymns."

Item XXVII and the founding of the College

Item XXVII established the mandate for the College of Ontological Mechanics. The item is nine lines long and its operative sentence has been quoted in every subsequent instrument of the College's authority:

"The Guild shall have standing to propose the existence of such mechanisms as may be required, provided always that the proposing be done in writing and in triplicate."

— Guild of Theoretical Mechanics Proposals (47 items), Item XXVII, third recension

The phrasing has occasioned difficulty. The College reads "propose the existence of" as a licence to constitute its subject matter; the Gallery of Unenacted Laws reads it as an obligation to leave the subject matter exactly where it was found. Both readings have been upheld, in different decades, by different Concordances. See Ninth Concordance, Annex 2, and contra Fourteenth Concordance, Annex 2, which was issued to correct the ninth and does not mention it.

The amendment clause and the notice question

Clause 22, appearing in the revised sequencing as Item XXXI, permits the Guild to amend apical blueprints without notice. The Office of Implausible Mechanics was itself constituted under this clause and cites it in every routine correspondence. The practical consequence is that a blueprint may lawfully be altered while the workshop is asleep, provided the Guild later records that it did so. Disputes arise as to when "later" begins. The Caliper Masters maintain that it begins at the striking of the eighth bell; the Guild maintains that it begins when the amendment is entered in the register, which on four documented occasions has been the following spring.

In 802 a floor supervisor on 2311 attempted to settle the matter by pinning a notice to the blueprint cabinet reading Amendments to be announced before they are made. The notice was removed within the day by an officer of the Caliper Masters, who cited Clause 22 against it. A second notice, reading Amendments will not be announced, was thereafter pinned to the same cabinet and has remained there undisturbed for one hundred and fifty years. Visitors are asked not to read it aloud.

Interruption of the proposals

In the year of the Guild of Theoretical Mechanicsgreat Calcification Event, the freeze that seized the Guild's western wing immobilized forty-seven pending proposals at the moment of their drafting, leaving the recension's numbered series incomplete in the counterpart series now known as the Guild of Theoretical Mechanics Proposals. The two documents are frequently confused. The Proposals (47 items) is the lodged submission; the Proposals without qualification is the frozen residue, of which the Theoretical Wings hold the only legible leaves. The Theoretical Bestiary was established in part to house the fauna postulated by items that survived as fragments — the thurible moths of Item XLII, and the long-legged stair census of Item XLIV, which continues to enumerate itself.

Scholars of the Department of Recensional Drift have proposed that the two documents be rebound as a single instrument. The Gallery has declined four times, on the grounds that a 47-item submission cannot be merged with a document that declines to state its item count.

Recensions and the Disputed Eleven Words

Three recensions are known. The first, lodged 712.Δ.3, lacks the words and such further mechanisms as the Guild shall from time to time require in the preamble. The second, certified by the Guild in 744, contains them. The third, held on Floor 2311, contains them twice, once struck through. The Guild's position is that the second recension is the only operative text and that the first and third are drafting errors preserved for the record. The Gallery's position, set out in Sixteenth Concordance, Annex 6, is that all three are within its keeping and therefore all three are law, "the Tower having no mechanism for withdrawing a text once shelved."

Librarian Ospen Harrow spent thirty-one years assembling a concordance of the eleven words and concluded that they had been added by a clerk who was copying a different document. The conclusion has never been refuted and has never been adopted. Harrow's notes remain the standard reference and are consulted chiefly by persons who wish to demonstrate that the question cannot be answered.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Theoretical Wings: how is it conducted?

Theoretical Wings are a class of non-existent, aerodynamically consistent structures postulated by the Guild of Theoretical Mechanics to permit controlled levitation and atmospheric traversal for entities or objects othe…

Theoretical Wings
Guild of Theoretical Mechanicsgreat Calcification Event: what happened?

The Great Calcification Event refers to the spontaneous and progressive petrification anomaly that occurred in Cycle 7984, rendering inert the entire western administrative wing of the Guild of Theoretical Mechanics. The…

Guild of Theoretical Mechanicsgreat Calcification Event
Sixteenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Sixteenth Concordance (officially designated Constitutional & Administrative Statutes, Sixth Iteration, with Annexes) is a foundational governance document within The Tower, ratified on the 14th of Fructidor, Year 73…

Sixteenth Concordance
Guild of Theoretical Mechanics: who are they?

The Guild of Theoretical Mechanics is a recognized academic and administrative body within The Tower dedicated to the formalization, critique, and regulation of hypothetical forces, imaginary machines, and non-existent p…

Guild of Theoretical Mechanics

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.