The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Great Re-Cataloguing of the Perpetually Absent Goat

MS 3720.25 · Practices and doctrines

The Great Re-Cataloguing of the Perpetually Absent Goat was the second formal revision of all records pertaining to the entity designated the Perpetually Absent Goat, conducted over the eleven years following Docket 89-Zeta- under the authority of the Librarians and concluded by affixing the transient integer 7,414.1α to every surviving entry. It is distinct from The Great Re-cataloguing proper, which revised the general register, and from the Great Re Cataloguing of the Spiral 77, which revised a location. The Re-Cataloguing of the Goat revised a single subject, and did so twice, a fact that remains the source of most subsequent disagreement.

Origin in the Case

The Case of the Perpetually Absent Goat established that a phenomenon could be catalogued without being manifested, on the strength of Algernon's Theorem on Conceptual Plenitude and the spectral surveys of the permit-holder Aris. What the Case did not establish was how many entries the Goat was entitled to. By the close of the Twelfth Great Clock, the register carried forty-one partial entries for the Goat, none of them agreeing on its elevation, its diet, or whether it had ever been present at all. The Survey of Absent Elevations (WA-102) had logged its bleating from a floor it declined to name, and the Survey's own clerks had filed three corrections to that log and then a fourth correction withdrawing the third.

Concordance 41, Annex 2, required that "an unmanifest subject shall be catalogued once, and thereafter not at all," while Concordance 55 on Iterative Record required that "an unmanifest subject shall be re-catalogued at each revision, lest its absence grow stale." The Re-Cataloguing was convened chiefly to determine which of these applied. It did not determine this.

Method and the First Pass

The work was assigned to the Sub-Scriptorium of Absent Fauna, a body of nine clerks and one sealed drawer. Clerks were instructed to collate all forty-one entries against the original docket and to strike any entry that could not be matched to a documented bleat. The first pass struck thirty-eight entries. A protest was entered the same winter by Archivist-Petitioner Marn, who observed that the three surviving entries all derived from the same afternoon and the same staircase, and that striking the others had left the Goat "catalogued more thinly than when it was not yet catalogued at all" — Marn, Memorial on the Thinness of Absent Records, filed in the drawer, unread.

The Sub-Scriptorium was accordingly instructed to restore the struck entries without reopening them. This was done by transcription from the strike-list, which had been copied in a hand that rendered the numeral 4 as a 9. The second pass therefore restored thirty-eight entries, of which eleven were not the entries that had been struck. Two of the eleven described a goat of a different colour, and one described no goat whatever.

The Integer 7,414.1α

Transient integers are assigned under Concordance 12 on Transient Numerals to subjects whose position in the register cannot yet be fixed. The Goat had been assigned 7,414.1α at the close of the Case, and the Re-Cataloguing's governing instruction was that the integer follow the entity through every revision. Owing to the transcription error noted above, the second pass applied 7,414.1α to the restored entries and, by a separate clerical slip, to a stool on Floor 4,114 that had no connexion to the matter and had been catalogued correctly in 3306.

"Where the integer is applied in error, the integer is not withdrawn. The stool is hereby 7,414.1α, and the goat is 7,414.1α, and the register shall not be amended to distinguish them."

— Concordance 12 on Transient Numerals, Annex 9

The stool remains in the register under the Goat's integer. Inquiries concerning the stool should be directed to the Sub-Scriptorium of Absent Furniture, which does not acknowledge them.

Dispute Between Recensions

Two recensions of the Re-Cataloguing survive. The Sub-Scriptorium's recension, bound in plain board and held on the unlisted floor from which the bleating was first recorded, treats the Re-Cataloguing as a single continuous act from the close of the Case to the affixing of the integer. The recension held by the Office of the Great Bell treats it as two acts separated by the winter of the strike-list, and counts the eleven misrestored entries as belonging to neither. The Office maintains that a subject cannot be re-catalogued twice without a fresh adjudication, and cites the Log of the Downward Seeking for the proposition that a record revised twice is a record of two things. The Sub-Scriptorium maintains the opposite and has declined to debate it since 3187.

Neither recension mentions the Choir of Absent Voices, although the Choir's third register lists the Goat among its silences. The Choir has been asked to clarify this on four occasions and has sung instead.

Legacy

The Re-Cataloguing is taught in the scriptoria as the standard example of revision outrunning its subject: forty-one entries reduced to three, restored to thirty-eight, of which eleven are wrong, plus a stool. Its chief procedural legacy is the standing rule that no subject bearing a transient integer may be collated by a clerk who has not read the strike-list aloud in the presence of a second clerk. The rule is observed. The stool is not read aloud, on the grounds that it is furniture.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Great Re Cataloguing of the Spiral 77: what happened?

The Great Re-cataloguing of the Spiral 77 was a 212-year administrative and ontological procedure (Tower Year 6124–6336) initiated to resolve the metaphysical contradictions introduced by the construction of Spiral 77 an…

Great Re Cataloguing of the Spiral 77
Perpetually Absent Goat: what is it for?

Perpetually Absent Goat is a categorically unmanifest entity assigned to the transient integer 7,414.1α, formally recognized by Librarian adjudication following the landmark proceeding of the same name. It is defined by …

Perpetually Absent Goat
Log of the Downward Seeking: what does it set out?

Log of the Downward Seeking is the official title for the bound, perpetually incomplete ledger maintained by the Librarian Corps of the Lower Descent to document phenomena, environmental shifts, and cataloguing anomalies…

Log of the Downward Seeking
Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.