The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Cott Sheets

MS 3020.83 · Objects and instruments

Definition and First Filing

Cott Sheets are a class of archival substrate introduced into the Tower's holdings following the proposal of Maris Cott in Year 207. A Cott Sheet is not a document in itself but a filing device: it records a damaged or effaced entry together with every state that entry might plausibly have held prior to the damage, so that a reader may consult the possible versions rather than the ruined one. The sheet is ruled in the standard quadrate fashion, but divided vertically into a column of conjectural states and a narrow marginal column in which the certifying hand records which of those states, if any, has since been corroborated. The invention is generally treated as the founding instrument of the Possibilian School, though the School itself disputes the attribution and prefers to trace its descent to Sub Folio 112 A722.

The Proposal of Year 207

Maris Cott's proposal arose from a difficulty that had troubled the Vellum Stacks for some decades: a damaged sheet cannot simply be replaced, because replacement destroys the evidence of what the sheet formerly said, and retention preserves a fragment that misleads. Cott's argument, as entered in the Registry of Traced Sheets and later reprinted in the appendices of the Third Concordance, was that the two difficulties are not opposed but identical, and that a sheet which recorded all possible readings would neither destroy nor mislead.

"Let the damaged entry be filed with all the states it might have held, and let none of them be preferred until the shelf is asked."

— Maris Cott, Proposal 14, Year 207

The first trial was conducted on a single shelf of the Floor of Recurring Distances during the winter of 209, using Basalt Vellum of the fourth grade. Eleven entries were treated. Of these, four were later corroborated, six remained in an indeterminate state, and one proved to have held no prior state at all, having been entered in error — a case that occupied the Bureau of Precedential Analysis for the better part of a decade.

Material Requirements and the Grade Dispute

Cott Sheets are conventionally struck on Vellum Grade 4, on the reasoning that a sheet recording uncertainty ought not itself be of a certainty-bearing grade. This practice is not without controversy. By the terms of Concordance of Sheets, Annex 7, any sheet receiving a certification mark must be of a grade eligible for Vellum Recusal, and Grade 4 is so eligible; but the Scriptorium of the Ninth Spiral has ruled the margins of such sheets and has declined to witness any Cott Sheet whose conjectural column exceeds nine states, on the ground that beyond nine the possibilities cease to be a record and become a catalogue.

Where a Cott Sheet is to be bound into a standing volume, it is furnished with a Stamped Cover Sheet, the blanks for which are supplied by the Bureau of Precedential Analysis. The blanks are supplied flat and must be dampened before folding. They are not to be folded dry.

The Binders' Consortium has twice petitioned against the binding of Cott Sheets in quires exceeding the fiscal quire fixed by Concordance 0 at forty sheets, arguing that the conjectural column adds weight not accounted for in the standard quire reckoning. The petition of Year 341 was refused; the petition of Year 344 was granted in part and then superseded, the superseding instrument itself having been mislaid in the Central Stacks before it could be enrolled.

Filing and Certification

A completed Cott Sheet enters the Registry of Traced Sheets, which occupies eleven bays of the Vellum Stacks and receives tracings by the day. Entries are made in the hand of the tracing clerk and countersigned by a second clerk, who is required to read the conjectural column aloud. Where a sheet has been scraped and re-used, the Scriptorium of the Ninth Spiral has refused to re-witness it, and the sheet proceeds to filing uncertified — a state that the Registrations House holds for eleven days before returning it, stamped or unstamped, to the originating shelf.

Sheets found to contain no recoverable state whatsoever are held under Status Beta-Rejected and may not be cited in subsequent tracings. The rule is applied strictly. In Year 358 a clerk of the eleventh bay filed a nulla sheet with a marginal note reading "nothing was here, and I have said so," and the note was itself entered as a recoverable state, occasioning a reprimand that remains in the bay's standing record.

Scholarly Disagreement

The principal dispute concerns how many states a Cott Sheet may hold before it ceases to be a sheet and becomes, in effect, a shelf of its own. The Functionalist School maintains that a Cott Sheet is a finding aid and nothing more, and that its conjectural column should be capped at the number of states the damaged entry could have held in practice — usually two or three. The Possibilian School holds that the cap is a category error, since the number of possible states is not a property of the entry but of the damage.

A secondary dispute concerns the Concordance of Sheets itself. That instrument is cited by the Central Vault Quality Assurance Bureau as the source of its authority over Cott Sheets; but the Third Concordance, Annex 4, asserts that sheets recording states that never were are "instruments of fiction and not of record," and that the Bureau's authority therefore does not extend to them. Both citations appear in the same enrolment volume, on facing pages, and neither has been withdrawn. The matter has been referred to the Title-smiths for a ruling on nomenclature, which is expected to settle nothing.

A minor literature, chiefly associated with the Diagrammatic Corpus, holds that the Cott Sheet is a degenerate form of the epicyclic ledger and should be stored accordingly; the Floor of Recurring Distances has declined to accept transfers on this basis since Year 372.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Vellum Stacks: where is it?

The Vellum Stacks constitute the primary archival storage system for all Tier-3 or higher Nictitating Vellum holdings within the Tower, encompassing both the physical shelving units and the adjacent atmospheric-regulator…

Vellum Stacks
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Bureau of Precedential Analysis: who are they?

The Bureau of Precedential Analysis is the administrative division charged, per Annex Γ of the Seventh Concordance, with rendering the indeterminate actionable through the interpretation of existing legal and procedural …

Bureau of Precedential Analysis
Vellum Grade 4: what is it for?

Vellum Grade 4, formally designated under the Principal Register as Line Sigma-4, is a classification of penitent-grade vellum authorized for specific administrative and remedial tasks within the Tower. It is distinguish…

Vellum Grade 4

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.