The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Contradicted Cardinals

MS 7954.35 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Contradicted Cardinals are a standing college of eleven cataloguers, presently nine in attendance and two in contest, whose office is to determine which of two conflicting entries has been contradicted by the other and which has merely been amended. The distinction is not academic. A finding of contradiction voids both entries until a recension is issued; a finding of amendment preserves the earlier entry in amended form and returns the later to draft. The Cardinals do not write articles. They decide which articles may be written twice.

The college is seated on Floor 1117, in a chamber whose north wall is given over to a board of paired cards, each pair pinned in a vertical column, and each column annotated in a hand that has changed four times since the board was first hung. The Cardinals take their name not from their robes, which are grey and untrimmed, nor from any rank in the Librarian order, but from the mechanism by which findings are resolved: where the board cannot be reduced to a single card by argument, the matter is decided by the drawing of a cardinal.

Origin and the Board of Paired Cards

The college was constituted by Concordance 61, which provided for "a body of eleven, drawn from the register, to sit upon the doubled entry and to say which of the two stands." The phrasing was intended to resolve the disputes arising from the sealed corrections of Meluan Vorl, whose register corrections had already contradicted entries sealed under the same Concordance. The framers evidently assumed that eleven cataloguers could agree more readily than seven had; the record does not support the assumption, and the college has issued a finding of agreement in only four hundred and six of the eleven thousand and twelve matters put to it between its constitution and the present.

The board itself was rebuilt in the winter of the third recension after a spill of lamp oil damaged the lower columns. The Cardinals regard the pre-spill arrangement as authoritative and the rebuilt board as provisional, so that every finding made since is, by the college's own doctrine, a finding upon a replica. Librarian Ordway Pell argued before the Concordance Bench that a finding upon a replica did not contradict its original, and was sustained.

The Rule of Priority and the Rule of the Register

Two principles govern the college and are irreconcilable. The Rule of Priority, derived from an early annexe of the Third Concordance, holds that where two entries are found to be in conflict, the earlier contradicts the later, because the later cannot have been written without knowledge of the former. The Rule of the Register, derived from Concordance 12,455, holds that the register as it presently stands contradicts any entry not in it, and that priority is therefore a matter of which entry survived the last recension.

Where both rules apply, the Cardinals divide. The college's practice in such cases is to declare the matter one of compound contradiction, which permits both entries to be struck and neither replaced, and to place the pair in the board's black column. The black column presently holds three hundred and nine pairs. It has been cleared once, in the fourth recension, and repopulated within the same season.

"It is not the office of this college to say what is true, but to say what has been said twice."

— Concordance 61, Preamble to Annex 2

The Drawing of the Cardinal

Where deliberation has not resolved a pair after three sittings, the Cardinals proceed to the drawing. A lacquered cardinal — a small token, red on one face, blank on the other — is placed in the chamber's copper bowl and covered. The senior attending member draws it and lays it face down without looking. The face is then read by the junior member present, who announces only the colour, not the pair to which it refers, and the finding is entered accordingly.

The practice has drawn criticism from the Cartographer-General, who observes that a finding reached in this way cannot be distinguished from a finding reached by argument once both are entered in the register. The Cardinals have answered, in a memorandum of the sixth recension, that the register records findings and not reasons, and that a reason recorded is itself an entry subject to contradiction. The memorandum is filed in the black column.

Two Cardinals presently sit in contest — that is, they decline to recognise the other's seat — arising from a dispute over the drawing of the eleventh of the fifth recension, in which the token was read by a junior member whose nomination had not been countersigned by the Tenth Concordance's registrar. The contest was referred to Extraordinary Protocols and remains open. The chamber holds nine at the board and two chairs at the back, and the back chairs are dusted on the same schedule as the rest.

Relations with the Extraordinary Protocols

The Cardinals are an ordinary body and do not invoke Extraordinary Protocols themselves; the Protocols are invoked upon them, when ordinary procedure is exhausted. This has happened eleven times, most recently in the matter of the Contradiction Protocol, which was itself found to be contradicted by an earlier draft under the Third Concordance's strictures on speculative cataloguing. The college declined to hear the matter, on the ground that it could not adjudicate a document under which it was being adjudicated, and the file was carried to Floor 10,007 and has not returned.

It is a condition of sitting that a Cardinal not catalogue the pair before the board. Cardinals may catalogue elsewhere in the Tower, and most do; the prohibition is specific to the chamber, and is posted at the door in the plainest lettering in the Tower: Attendants will not be admitted during the drawing.

Inventory of the Chamber

The chamber's effects were inventoried in the seventh recension and the inventory has not since been revised, the college having found the inventory contradicted by the state of the chamber and the chamber contradicted by the inventory. The inventory records:

  • One board of paired cards, rebuilt, of which the black column is not counted.
  • One copper bowl, unlidded; the lid is recorded as missing since the fourth recension.
  • Eleven chairs, of which two are at the back.
  • One lacquered cardinal, red on one face.
  • One card formerly paired with another and now not, whose pair has not been identified.

The unpaired card is a standing embarrassment. It has been examined by every Cardinal seated since the inventory and compared against every entry in the register without result, and it is the college's practice to exhibit it to new members as an example of what the board cannot answer. Its face is a single floor number, and the number is one that does not appear in any Concordance.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Meluan Vorl: who were they?

Meluan Vorl was a clerk of the Office of Vertical Records, later Clerk-Registrar, and the author of the treatise On the Immutable Pivot. He is chiefly remembered for the doctrine of the fixed point — the argument that an…

Meluan Vorl
Tenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Tenth Concordance is a foundational document of administrative governance within the Tower, ratified on 14 Spiral, Year 412 of the Third Cataloguing Era. It is primarily known for its pivotal annex, Annex Ω, which au…

Tenth Concordance
Contradiction Protocol: how is it conducted?

Contradiction Protocol refers to the formalized administrative and procedural framework governing the identification, classification, containment, and potential reconciliation of mutually exclusive statements of fact wit…

Contradiction Protocol
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.