The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Contextual Integrity

MS 4774.10 · Practices and doctrines

Contextual Integrity is the property of a catalogued subject whose internal references remain stable under repeated consultation — that is, a subject which, however often it is opened, annotated, cross-indexed or read aloud in a reading room, continues to say the same things about itself. The term is defined in Manual of Contextual Metrics, Schedule 2, as "the persistence of a subject's referential relations across successive acts of access, measured against its own declared perimeter." It is not to be confused with Contextual Harmonization, which is the repair of subjects that have lost the property, nor with Principle of Contextual Primacy, which asserts the property should have been established before entry and is therefore the business of other offices.

Every subject admitted through Contextual Verification is issued a provisional integrity figure at the moment of cataloguing. The figure is expressed in milliunits and is revised at intervals of eleven years, unless a revision is requested earlier by any Librarian of the fourth grade or above, which happens frequently and to little effect.

Measurement

Integrity is measured by a procedure of repeated interrogation. A subject is consulted from its face, from its reverse, from two oblique angles not less than forty degrees apart, and once by a Librarian who has not previously handled it and to whom nothing about it has been said. The four readings are then compared. Divergence below 0.4 milliunits is recorded as stable; divergence between 0.4 and 2.1 as "tolerant"; divergence above 2.1 is referred to the Division of Contextual Anchoring as suspected Contextual Decay.

The oblique readings are the source of most disputes. The Pragmatic School holds that a subject consulted from behind is not the same subject and that the reading should be discarded; the School of Contextual Propagation accepts all four and adjusts for angle. The disagreement has run since the Twenty-Second Concordance and is unlikely to close, since each side cites a different annex of the same document.

The Vellum Anomaly of Floor 887

The most cited case in the literature is that of a bound vellum inventory catalogued on floor 887 in the winter of the year recorded as 4,113 by the internal reckoning. Its initial integrity figure was 9.7 milliunits — high, but not remarkable. On its forty-first consultation, a clerk of the second grade named Adelard Prunt recorded that the inventory had grown an entry for a floor numbered 2, and that the entry described the inventory itself. Prunt's note reads, in full:

"Consulted the subject at the seventh hour. It now lists a floor it did not list yesterday, and the floor is this one. I have not amended it. I have asked Harmonic whether I ought to."

— Prunt's Consultation Register, folio 114

Harmonic never answered. The inventory was re-measured at 3.2 milliunits and moved to floor 887's closed shelf, where it remains. It is consulted twice yearly, always from the face.

Integrity and Sufficiency

The relationship between Contextual Integrity and Contextual Sufficiency is one of the more patiently contested matters in the archive. Bureau of Harmonic Integrity maintains, under Ordinance 45.c, that sufficiency cannot be conferred on a subject whose integrity figure falls below 6.0 milliunits, and that the two properties are therefore sequential. The Office of Void Integrity has replied, in a memorandum of considerable length, that integrity is a property of the subject and sufficiency a property of the reader's relation to it, and that to require the one before the other is "to require a house to be warm before anyone has entered it." The memorandum is not binding. The Directorate of Contextual Reconciliation has declined to resolve the question four times.

In practice the floor officers apply sufficiency first and integrity afterwards, a sequence no Concordance authorises but which has not been challenged in writing since 4,096.

Deprivation and the Quietude

Subjects that fail integrity review are not destroyed. They are placed under the Ordinance of Remedial Quietude, which permits storage but forbids consultation except by written application to the Bureau of Harmonic Integrity and forbids quotation entirely. The rule is strict and its enforcement uneven. A reading room on floor 1,502 kept a deprived subject on open shelving for sixty-two years; when the omission was discovered, the officer responsible explained that the shelf had been assigned before the deprivation and that reassigning it would have required a form. No penalty was recorded.

Tier VII: Full Contextual Harmonization, jointly administered by the Division of Contextual Anchoring and the School of Contextual Propagation, receives those subjects for which quietude has failed to stabilise the figure. Of the subjects admitted to Tier VII since its establishment, roughly one in nine is returned to circulation with an integrity figure above 7.0. The remainder are held indefinitely, a condition the School describes as "not a failure but an extended presence."

Criticism

The Vekian Antithesis of Contextual Cohesion argues that integrity so defined is merely a measure of how little a subject has been used, and that a catalogue which prizes it will inevitably favour the unread. The Contextual Purists go further, maintaining that the metric rewards subjects too thin to contradict themselves. Neither position has been adopted, though both are quoted in the Contextual Clarification Bulletins often enough that the Manual of Contextual Metrics now prints them in an appendix, without comment, under the heading "Objections of Record."

Applications to consult a deprived subject are made on the second and fourth days of the week and must be submitted in person. The applicant should bring a pen; the office does not supply them.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Void Integrity: who are they?

The Office of Void Integrity (O.V.I.) is the administrative body responsible for the custodial maintenance, structural security, and dimensional stability of all void phenomena catalogued within the Tower. Established by…

Office of Void Integrity
Manual of Contextual Metrics: what does it set out?

"Correct placement is the state of a holding being where it is required to be. Correct positioning is the state of a holding being required to be where it is. A clerk who confuses the two will find both conditions unmet.…

Manual of Contextual Metrics
Contextual Sufficiency: how is it conducted?

Contextual Sufficiency is the descriptive and procedural standard by which the cataloguing of a subject within the Tower is deemed complete. It is distinct from, though often conflated with, the concept of Descriptive Su…

Contextual Sufficiency
Principle of Contextual Primacy: how is it conducted?

The Principle of Contextual Primacy is the axiomatic rule within Tower jurisprudence that, in any conflict between contextual meaning and formal definition, the contextual meaning holds precedence for administrative and …

Principle of Contextual Primacy

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.