The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Contextual Dependence

MS 8791.35 · Practices and doctrines

Contextual Dependence is the property by which a catalogued subject's verity conditions are held to rest on the setting in which it is examined, rather than on any attribute of the subject itself. It is distinguished from Referential Dependence, which concerns what a subject points toward, and from Protocol Dependence, which concerns the procedure by which it is examined. Contextual Dependence concerns only the room. It is administered under Annex 9 of Concordance 41 and disputed under every annex since.

The distinction is finer than it appears on the page. A subject may be referentially independent, procedurally independent, and still lapse the moment the lamps are trimmed. Librarians in the reading rooms of the upper-middle floors have long maintained that this is the ordinary condition of most holdings, and that the other two dependencies are simply Contextual Dependence observed at a distance.

Formulation

Annex 9 defines Contextual Dependence as "the liability of a subject to alter in verity upon alteration of its surroundings, those surroundings being enumerated in the Metrology Annex and nowhere else." The enumeration is the difficulty. The Metrology Annex lists forty-one parameters, among them barometric pressure, the inclination of the reading desk, the number of persons present, the number of persons recently present, and the age of the ink in the nearest register.

Article 4 of the same annex attempts to close the list: "No parameter not recorded in this Annex shall be held to constitute a context." The Referential School has objected for two hundred years that this is a statement of policy disguised as a statement of fact, and that contexts do not consult the Annex before exerting themselves.

Relation to Contextual Anchoring

Contextual Dependence is the underlying condition that Contextual Anchoring is designed to arrest. Where a subject's dependence is severe, the Division of Contextual Anchoring (DCA) fixes it to a designated anchor — usually a stairwell marker or a sealed plinth — and thereafter examines it only in the anchor's presence.

The practice follows the Principle of Contextual Primacy, which holds that a context, once established, takes precedence over any description of the subject prepared outside it. The Manual of Contextual Metrics gives the working measure of this as Contextual Integrity, and the whole apparatus is reviewed in relation to the Contextual Concordance whenever the two documents are read together, which is rarely.

The Aris Thorne Discrepancy

The stability of the doctrine was shaken by the Aris Thorne Discrepancy, in which subjects catalogued as strongly context-dependent under one observational methodology were found to be nearly indifferent to context under another. The finding was read by some as a refutation of Contextual Dependence outright, and by others as a demonstration of Protocol Dependence masquerading as context.

Aris Thorne had anticipated the objection in On the Order-Dependence of Semantic Fields, remarking that "a dependence that can be made to vanish by looking differently is not thereby absent; it has merely been looked at differently." The sentence is quoted in nearly every proceeding on the subject and has never been improved upon.

Dispute between the Concordances

Concordance 41 treats Contextual Dependence as an intrinsic property of the subject — a fault in the holding, to be remedied by Contextual Harmonization. The Contextual Concordance, at Annex 2, treats it instead as a property of the examining chamber, and holds the subject blameless throughout.

The two positions were meant to be reconciled by the Directorate of Contextual Reconciliation, which has instead produced eleven consecutive annual findings that the question is "not yet ripe." The Vekian Antithesis of Contextual Cohesion argues that both annexes are correct and that this is the worst possible outcome. Meanwhile the Contextual Purists maintain the strict reading of Annex 9, and have refused to enter the eastern reading rooms since the winter of 1187, on the grounds that those rooms are themselves a context.

The Harrow Recension

The standard recension of Annex 9 is not the original. In 1104 the clerk Ovett Harrow was assigned to prepare a fair copy for the scriptorium and, finding the list of parameters untidy, reordered the entries and merged three of them.

"The ordinary reader will not miss the third entry. It described a condition no one has been able to produce."

— Ovett Harrow, marginal note to the Harrow recension, 1104

The merged entries are now cited in every dispute as a single parameter, and no copy of the original list survives in the open stacks. Harrow was reprimanded, promoted, and given charge of the Transitory Galleries, where he is remembered chiefly for a standing order that no reader may carry a lamp into the galleries above the ninth landing. The order remains in force.

Practical Notes

Subjects under active Contextual Dependence are marked in the catalogue with a bracket around the floor number, thus: (714). The bracket is not explained in the catalogue and cannot be removed by readers. Reading in a bracketed room is permitted, but the desk must be left as found, and the chair returned to the wall at the close of the session. Failed readings are referred to the Division, which reviews them quarterly under Tier VII arrangements with the School of Contextual Propagation.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Vekian Antithesis of Contextual Cohesion: what does it set out?

The Vekian Antithesis of Contextual Cohesion (formally Compendium P-V/2, On the Systemic Antitheses to Contextual Cohesion in Hierarchical Documentation) is a treatise by Theoretician Vek that posits institutionalized am…

Vekian Antithesis of Contextual Cohesion
Principle of Contextual Primacy: how is it conducted?

The Principle of Contextual Primacy is the axiomatic rule within Tower jurisprudence that, in any conflict between contextual meaning and formal definition, the contextual meaning holds precedence for administrative and …

Principle of Contextual Primacy
Contextual Reading: how is it conducted?

Contextual Reading is the regulated practice by which a subject catalogued in the Tower is consulted in accordance with its established framing, as determined by the Division of Contextual Anchoring (DCA) and the offices…

Contextual Reading
Contextual Anchoring: how is it conducted?

Contextual Anchoring is the standard procedure by which a subject catalogued in the Tower is fixed to a determinate position within the archive's vertical extent, thereby preventing its drift into unrecorded floors. The …

Contextual Anchoring

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.