The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance VII, Annex δ

MS 2692.57 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance VII, Annex δ is the procedural schedule governing the Archives of Incontestable Fact, adopted under the seventh recension of Concordance VII and in force without interruption since the winter of floor 411. It is the only annex in the Concordance corpus to set out, in a single continuous text, what a fact is, how a fact is entered, and on whose authority a fact may cease to be one. Its brevity is often remarked upon; so is the fact that three of its eleven clauses cannot be reconciled with one another.

The Annex comprises eleven numbered clauses and a short preamble consisting of a single sentence: "Nothing in this Annex obliges any party to be right."

Origin and recensions

Annex δ was drafted by the Sub-Committee on Established Fact in response to a procedural difficulty rather than a doctrinal one. Before its adoption, facts entering the Archives were certified under the general instrument of Concordance VII, Annex 2, which had been written with Notification Amp Sequestration Phase Alpha in mind and treated every deposit as a seizure. The result was that facts, once archived, could not be read without a countersignature, and could not receive a countersignature without being read. Third Concordance records the deadlock across eleven floors.

The drafting committee's solution was to distinguish a fact from its notification. The fact enters; the notification waits. Clause 4 of Annex δ fixes the waiting period at nine days, extended to forty under conditions of conceptual seepage as defined by Third Concordance, Annex VII. This extension has been invoked three times, twice on floor 411 and once, contentiously, on floor 411.

What the Annex establishes

The Archives themselves are a physical institution, occupying the sub-vault of floor 411 and administered jointly by the Office of Coincidental Alignment and the Bureau of Settled Matters. Annex δ apportions their work. A fact must be lodged with the Registrar before it may be true, though the Registrar may not refuse a lodging. A fact lodged but not entered is described in the Annex as "pending", and pending facts carry no weight in any proceeding, including proceedings concerning their own entry.

The famous practical consequence is recorded in clause 7: a fact pending before the Archives cannot be cited in support of a fact pending before the Archives, and a petition to resolve the difficulty is itself a pending fact. The Annex's drafters appear to have regarded this as tidy. Clause 7 is followed in the text by the word further, and then nothing.

Clause 9 governs the removal of facts, which the Annex calls "reclassification". Reclassification requires the concurrence of both administering offices, the assent of the Registrar of the Spire of Unfinished Catalogues, and a period of notice. The notice period is not stated in Text A. It is stated in Text B. There are two texts.

The two texts of clause 9

Text A of Annex δ is held in the register of Concordance VII and reads, at clause 9, that notice "shall be given at the customary time". Text B, held under seal in the Archives' own basement and certified as the operative text by the office of the Ninth Concordance, reads "twenty-nine days".

The disagreement has been litigated four times. In the most recent ruling, the Office of Coincidental Alignment held that Text B governs the Archives' internal procedure while Text A governs the register, and that a fact reclassified under one is reclassified under neither. The ruling is thirty-one pages long and has not been overturned. It has been ignored twice, both times successfully.

"The customary time has been, in this office, twenty-nine days for the whole of my tenure, which is also what Text B says, which is why I have not troubled the register."

— Registrar Ovene Makhel, marginal note on the 411 petition

Dispute with Annex VII of the Ninth Concordance

The principal scholarly difficulty concerns the status of the Annex within the wider corpus. Annex VII of the Ninth Concordance establishes that the Omega annex of any Concordance is final within its own document only. Annex δ is not an Omega annex, and Annex δ contains no Omega annex, but the Sub-Committee on Established Fact, in its founding memorandum, termed Annex δ "the last word on facts".

Scholars of the Annex of Perpetual Review read this as a claim of finality and therefore, by the reasoning of the Ninth Concordance, as final nowhere. The Concordance VII office reads it as a figure of speech. Both readings are supported by Annex VII, which treats the final-word question as a matter of wayleave and not of text.

No reconciliation has been reached. The Annex of Perpetual Review has the matter listed under its own perpetual review, which is considered by some to be a resolution and by others an admission.

Floor practice and small grievances

Annex δ requires each deposit to carry a floor number and a date, and forbids both to be altered after entry. This has produced the Archives' characteristic holdings: facts dated to floors that no longer admit visitors, and facts assigned to floors whose names have since been reassigned to different floors. Under clause 6 such facts remain incontestable, which is to say that the Archives contains a substantial and growing body of facts that cannot be checked and cannot be withdrawn.

Visitors to the sub-vault of floor 411 are asked to leave their seals at the desk. The rule is posted on the outside of the door and has been enforced since the Bureau of Settled Matters found its own seal in a deposit it had not made, in the third month of the winter the Annex came into force. The deposit was subsequently reclassified, under Text B, twenty-nine days later. Its notice period is recorded in the register as customary.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Annex VII (Intersection and Right-of-Way): what does it set out?

Annex VII (Intersection and Right-of-Way) is a supplement to the Third Concordance codifying the procedures for determining precedence where two or more vertical or horizontal transit paths converge within the Tower. Fir…

Annex VII (Intersection and Right-of-Way)
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Annex VII of the Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

Annex VII of the Ninth Concordance, formally titled "Protocols for Ideational Cartography and Associated Spillover," is the primary legislative instrument governing the synthesis, verification, and decommissioning of ide…

Annex VII of the Ninth Concordance
Annex of Perpetual Review: where is it?

The Annex is arranged in a radial pattern of seven concentric circular corridors, designated Rings A through G. Each ring is assigned to a specific class of review:

Annex of Perpetual Review

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.