Concordance 89, Annex VII
MS 1656.89 · Documents and ordinances
Concordance 89, Annex VII is the furniture schedule appended to Concordance 89 at its fourth recension, governing the placement, registration, and permitted relocation of seating in the reading galleries of the upper western spirals. It is the only annex in the Concordance corpus whose primary subject is chairs, and its reputation among the Librarians is disproportionate to its length, which is eleven folios.
Origin and recensions
Concordance 89 was first entered in the register of the Third Concordance, Annex VII in the winter of the year the western galleries were renumbered, an event the register dates only by the phrase "after the second snow." Annex VII appeared at the third recension as a single folio fixing the distance between reading chairs at two paces and one hand; the fourth recension, the operative text, expanded this to cover benches, lecterns with attached seats, and the stools provided to copyists in the scriptoria.
The expansion was prompted by a dispute on Floor 412, where a bench had been moved eleven times in a single season by successive readers who preferred it nearer the light. The Office of Coincidental Alignment, which had been established by the Third Concordance, Annex VII and whose remit includes "the rectification of furniture found where it ought not to be," declined the case on the grounds that a bench is not coincidental. The schedule has since been read as the boundary of that office's jurisdiction.
Provisions
The annex proceeds by types. Chairs are registered individually and are said to possess a "seat-number" distinct from the floor number and from the reader's own ticket. Benches are registered by the hand-span and are permitted to be unnumbered provided they are painted along one edge. Lecterns with attached seats, the schedule notes, "are fixtures and shall not be reasoned with," citing Annex VII of the Ninth Concordance for authority on immovable furniture (Concordance 89, Annex VII, clause 3).
Relocation is permitted within a gallery and prohibited between galleries without a writ of transfer countersigned by two Librarians, one of whom must have sat in the chair in question. The schedule does not say for how long. A note in the margin of the fourth-recension copy, initialled by the clerk Maren Ostfall, reads: "A short sitting is sufficient; a long one is not permitted before noon."
"No chair shall be carried down a stairwell in a manner that permits it to strike the third, seventh, or eleventh riser. Where a chair must be so carried, it shall be carried facing outward and the risers in question shall be counted aloud."
— Concordance 89, Annex VII, clause 7
The Ostfall complaint
Ostfall, a registrar of Seat-Numbers from the year of the western renumbering until her retirement, filed the complaint for which the annex is chiefly remembered. She had registered a chair on Floor 209 under seat-number 209/14, only to find it, three days later, on Floor 210 under seat-number 210/02, the painting along its edge having been amended by an unknown hand. Her grievance, entered as a single sheet in the Annex of Perpetual Review, argues that a chair which may change its number may change its floor, and that the schedule's silence on the point "is not a permission but a hole." The Office of Coincidental Alignment replied in four lines, observing that the chair had not moved coincidentally, having been carried, and that the matter was therefore closed. Ostfall's appeal was refused. She is recorded as having sat in the chair, at its new number, for the remainder of the afternoon.
Relation to other annexes
Concordance 89, Annex VII is frequently cited alongside Concordance VII, Annex δ, whose procedural schedule for the Archives of Incontestable Fact borrows its definition of "fixture" wholesale from the furniture annex, though the borrowing is unacknowledged. It also figures in the standing quarrel over whether an annex's Omega provision is final. Annex Vii Ninth Concordance holds that the Omega annex of any Concordance is final within its own document only; the furniture annex, which has no Omega, has been used by both sides as evidence and by neither as proof. The Third Concordance, Annex VII recopies the operative wording of Concordance 1.5.3 on registration without noting that 1.5.3 concerns livestock, a discrepancy first raised by Ostfall and never answered.
Scholarly disagreement
Two readings of clause 7 persist. The Office of Coincidental Alignment maintains that the riser-counting requirement is ceremonial, a survival of older practice intended to mark the chair's passage through a shared space. The Addendum 9 school holds that counting aloud is evidentiary, and that a chair carried in silence has not been validly transferred, and must be carried back up. The dispute has produced no ruling and one injury: a copyist on Floor 411, counting the eleventh riser and stepping backwards, fell from the landing and was recovered with the chair. The schedule was not amended. A maintenance notice posted at the foot of that stairwell since the incident reads, in full, that chairs are not to be carried on the stairs during the hour before noon.
See also
-
MS 4333.59
Gravitational Concordance
The Gravitational Concordance is the collective designation for the body of numbered instruments governing the measurement, regist…
-
MS 0665.79
Edict of Tacit Resonance (Aperture 514)
The Edict of Tacit Resonance (Aperture 514) is the Concordance governing the registration and permitted decay of unattributed soun…
-
MS 6577.05
Ordinance 12.44.7
Ordinance 12.44.7 is the supplemental recension governing the placement, recall, and silent re-shelving of nonexistent stairwells …
-
MS 2047.26
Annex Delta Ninety Second Concordance
Annex Delta (Ninety-Second Concordance) is a supplementary document appended to the Ninety-Second Concordance, primarily governing…
-
MS 4128.42
Clause 112 Annex Delta Third Concordance
Clause 112, Annex Delta, Third Concordance is a procedural ordinance governing the cataloguing status and physical relocation of a…
-
MS 3953.85
The Twenty-Second Concordance, Clause 7
The Twenty-Second Concordance, Clause 7 is the operative provision of the Twenty-Second Concordance governing the Movement of Stac…
Referenced by
- MS 4754.49 “Tonal Ground,”
- MS 5267.19 Mineralogical Concordance, Annex VII
Readers also asked
Concordance VII, Annex δ: what does it set out?
Concordance VII, Annex δ is the procedural schedule governing the Archives of Incontestable Fact, adopted under the seventh recension of Concordance VII and in force without interruption since the winter of floor 411. It…
Concordance VII, Annex δThird Concordance, Annex VII: what does it set out?
Third Concordance, Annex VII is a supplementary legal and procedural document, one of forty-seven known annexes to the Third Concordance. While the primary Concordance established foundational principles for the Tower’s …
Third Concordance, Annex VIIConcordance 89: what does it set out?
Concordance 89, officially titled Regulations Pertaining to Tonal Residue in Sub-Shelf 89.β, is a legislative document governing the handling, cataloguing, and disposal of auditory phenomena generated by the interaction …
Concordance 89Annex of Perpetual Review: where is it?
The Annex is arranged in a radial pattern of seven concentric circular corridors, designated Rings A through G. Each ring is assigned to a specific class of review:
Annex of Perpetual ReviewPassages cited from this record
-
No chair shall be carried down a stairwell in a manner that permits it to strike the third, seventh, or eleventh riser. Where a chair must be so carried, it shall be carried facing outward and the risers in question shall be counted aloud.
Concordance 89, Annex VII, clause 7
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 8627.65 Maren Ostfall
Because you consulted