Concordance practice
MS 7509.61 · Practices and doctrines
Definition and Scope
Concordance practice is the body of customary and codified procedure by which the Librarians compose, amend, seal, cite and eventually retire the numbered documents called Concordances. It is distinguished from the Concordances themselves in the way that a scriptorium is distinguished from its shelves: the practice concerns the making and handling of instruments, not their content. The distinction is old but imperfectly observed, and a substantial fraction of the Tower's procedural literature consists of arguments about which side of it a given act falls upon.
The practice is administered jointly by the Bureau of Citation Practice and the Office of Sealing, an arrangement that has produced no fewer than forty-one recorded jurisdictional disputes since 8,900. Both offices maintain separate registers; neither register is considered authoritative by the other.
Composition and Drafting
A Concordance is drafted in fair copy by a clerk of the drafting bench, then read aloud in the Chamber of First Recension to a panel of three Librarians, at least one of whom must be seated. The reading is not a debate and is not interrupted; objections are entered in the margin and argued afterwards. The full procedure is set out in Concordance Drafting, which itself was drafted under the procedure it describes — a condition known as Concordantal Self-Application and one that the Tower has never fully resolved to its satisfaction.
Drafting conventions vary by bench. The Third Sieve of the lower drafting floor once introduced a rule requiring every numeral in a Concordance to be written out in words; the rule survived eleven months and one Concordance, the Ninety-Second Concordance, which remains written entirely in words and is consequently the longest document in the archive.
Amendment and the Tracking Difficulty
Concordances are amended more often than they are read, and the practice of tracking those amendments has grown into a discipline of its own, described at length in Concordance Amendment Tracking. The difficulty is structural: an amendment is appended to the instrument it amends, but the appended amendment may be amended in turn by an instrument of higher or lower number, and the ordering of instruments by number does not correspond to their ordering in time, in precedence, or in the sequence of their own seals.
The Third Concordance is the standard example. Amendment 12.a treats Kael Practice as an extension of the Curatorial Practice; a later amendment to the same instrument, unnumbered and unsealed, is generally read as withdrawing 12.a without saying so, and the Bureau has declined on four occasions to rule on which reading prevails. Clerks are advised to cite both and let the dispute stand.
The Second and Seventh Concordances show a similar pattern. The Temporary Inscription Practice is governed by amendments to the Second Concordance, while Local Calibration falls under the statute of the Seventh; where the two amendments touch the same floor, the practice is divided between two registers and the floor keeps two sets of measurements.
Precedence, Contradiction and the Practitioners' Dispute
Where Concordances contradict, the Tower does not reconcile them. It cites them side by side, a method formalised in Concordance Juxtaposition and defended by the Bureau on the grounds that a contradiction recorded is a contradiction contained. The most sustained scholarly disagreement in the field concerns whether juxtaposition is a method of resolution or a method of avoidance. The Curatorial reading, given in the Preamble to the Curatorial Practice, holds that the Practice governs the spirit of the Standard and therefore that contradiction is a feature of the standard rather than a fault in it. The counter-reading, argued from Annex 7 of the Third Concordance, is that the Curatorial Practice governs the spirit only of instruments sealed after its preamble, and that everything older is owed no such latitude.
A third position, advanced by the Annex Δ commentators, holds that both readings are correct and that the archive has simply never been asked the right question. The disputants do not accept this, and the dispute is now in its second century.
Citation and the Sealing Record
Citation practice is regulated by Concordance 88-D, which refers to the Principle of Generative Ambiguity as "the ambiguity provision under the Nomenclature instrument" (88-D, clause 6). The Bureau of Citation Practice advises that the designation Concordance 1-ω be quoted in full and never abbreviated, a standing instruction issued after an abbreviation in a 9,411 inventory brought five unrelated instruments into a single citation and could not be undone without amending all five.
Every citation must carry the seal of the instrument cited. This is the most neglected rule in the practice. The clerk Meristan Voile, of the third sealing bench, spent the winter of 9,355 reconciling the sealing record against the citation register and found that of some two thousand citations in current use, fewer than a third corresponded to a seal actually affixed. Her report was returned unopened, then opened, then filed under The Rival Concordance in error, where it remains and has since been cited three times as authority for a position Voile did not hold.
Erasure and Retirement
Instruments are retired by Erasure, governed by Concordance Law, or by supersession, which leaves the instrument in place and removes its operation. The difference is procedural and much litigated. Erasure is total and leaves a gap; supersession leaves the text standing, silent and citable. Most instruments in the archive have been superseded, and a reader who consults the older registers will find a great many documents that say what they have always said and no longer do anything.
Retired instruments are shelved on the floors indicated by the Lost Catalogue, whose numbering was upheld by the Standing Concordance on Filing Practice in 9,355. The metre rules for those floors are archived under Annex 7 of the Third Concordance, and visitors are reminded that the upper landings are for citation only.
See also
See also
-
MS 5251.89
Ordinances of Concordance
The Ordinances of Concordance are the standing body of numbered instruments by which the Librarians record, amend, and occasionall…
-
MS 3987.48
Librarians Recorded Chronology Practice
Librarians' Recorded Chronology Practice is the body of customary procedure by which the order of Librarians maintains, consults, …
-
MS 6689.30
Paradox Contamination Type Vii C Practice
Paradox Contamination Type VII-C Practice denotes the body of customary procedure, adjudicated precedent, and operational habit by…
-
MS 2205.27
The Tally
The Tally is the central, silent data well around which Floor 2001 is organized, and the customary term for any of the numbered re…
-
MS 1894.45
Descent Protocols Practice
Descent Protocols Practice refers to the collective body of procedural orthodoxy, established customary law, and operational prece…
-
MS 4823.06
Negative Concordance
The Negative Concordance is the unofficial designation for a class of administrative paradoxes arising from the systematic applica…
Referenced by
- MS 1604.97 Temporally Stable
- MS 9314.42 Transition Oversight
Readers also asked
Ninety-Second Concordance: what does it set out?
The Ninety-Second Concordance is a foundational administrative text concerning the procedural authorization of movement, consultation, and temporary resource reallocation within the Tower. Ratified in Year 47 of the Seco…
Ninety-Second ConcordanceThe Curatorial Practice: how is it conducted?
The Curatorial Practice is the foundational methodology governing the acquisition, evaluation, and archival integration of subjects within the Tower. It is distinguished from mere cataloguing by its focus on ontological …
The Curatorial PracticePartial Survey the Seventh Concordance: how is it conducted?
Partial Survey the Seventh Concordance refers to the distinct, and ultimately standardised, administrative practice of conducting a formal stock assessment during the active period of a given Concordance. As defined by A…
Partial Survey the Seventh ConcordanceThe Rival Concordance: what does it set out?
The Rival Concordance is the colloquial designation for the formal document officially recorded as The Second Concordance, distinguished by its practice of maintaining a complete, autonomous index of the Tower's contents…
The Rival ConcordanceReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 0820.53 Bureau of Citation Practice
- MS 4371.17 Standing Concordance on Filing Practice
- MS 6828.86 Concordance 88-D
- MS 2799.21 Lost Catalogue
Because you consulted