Concordance Drafting
MS 2490.30 · Practices and doctrines
Concordance Drafting is the composite craft by which the Concordance documents of the Tower are composed, negotiated, tested against existing instruments, and committed to the record. It is distinguished from the narrower practice of Resolution Drafting in that it produces the governing text itself rather than the instruments that apply it. Drafting is performed under the supervision of the Central Scriptorium, whose calligraphers execute the fair copies and whose filing clerks assign the internal registry marks by which a Concordance may be cited before it has a number.
The craft is conventionally divided into four stages — audition, schematic, leaf, and seal — though the divisions are administrative rather than doctrinal, and a draft may be returned to any earlier stage at any time by any party with standing to object. In practice, most drafts spend the greater part of their lives in the leaf stage and the greater part of their disputes in the schematic.
The stages of the work
The opening stage, Pre-emptive Audition, requires the drafting committee to hear anticipated objections before the text exists to invite them. The corollary practice, Pre-emptive Schematic Drafting, permits the committee to append procedural frameworks ahead of the core tenets, so that conceptual seepage during composition is caught by a procedure rather than by a reader. The two were formally joined by the Eleventh Concordance, which codifies Pre-emptive Schematic Drafting as the corollary to Pre-emptive Audition and settles an argument that had run for some eleven years between the Scriptorium and the Scriptorial Collegium without either side conceding a point.
The leaf stage, mandated for all resolutions by the Third Concordance and adopted by analogy for full Concordances, requires that every clause be drafted on a separate leaf, each leaf sealed at the lower margin and stapled to no more than one neighbour. The purpose is to allow a committee to replace a single clause without disturbing the collation; the effect, frequently noted in the Scriptorium's own minutes, is that a Concordance in active drafting occupies a table the length of a corridor. A leaf that has been detached and reaffixed more than four times is retired to the morgue drawers and may not be cited.
Recensions and the problem of the edit
No Concordance is drafted once. The record distinguishes the recensio princeps — the text as first sealed — from every subsequent recension, and it is a standing rule of the Scriptorium that a citation without a recension mark is presumed to refer to the most recent, except where the most recent contradicts the one the citer plainly meant, in which case the presumption is reversed and the citer is asked to explain themselves in writing.
"Where a clause has been amended more than twice in a single drafting season, the amended clause shall be read in the light of the clause it replaced, and the replaced clause shall be retained in the margin in a hand distinguishable from the body."
— Third Concordance, Annex 4, on marginal retention
Marginal retention has produced the Tower's most persistent palaeographic difficulty: the margins of older Concordances now carry more text than the pages, and a reader following a marginal hand is often following an argument rather than a rule. The Purist Scribes hold that marginal matter is not law and may be ignored; the collegial position, set out in the Quickened Rules of Dispute, is that it may not be ignored but need not be obeyed, a distinction the Purists have never accepted.
Procedure and irregularity
The procedural history of Concordance Drafting is in large part a history of departures from it. The Drafting of the Ninth Concordance was ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian after a season in which the committee drafted frameworks for frameworks and very nearly lost the core tenets altogether; the event is taught in the Scriptorium as a caution and cited everywhere else as a precedent. Moderator Aris Thorne led the drafting committee for the Fifty-Second Concordance and is credited in the registry with having reduced the average interval between leaf stages from nine days to four, a figure disputed by the filing clerks, who count the staple-setting separately.
Irregularity is not confined to the past. The initial drafting of Concordance 74 dates to the latter period of The Fifteenth Concordance's authority, when the two instruments overlapped and committees were obliged to draft under both. Where the Concordance of Four Fourthments governs the drafting of future Fourth Concordances, the drafting of a Fifth is governed by nothing at all, which the Scriptorium maintains is a deliberate silence and the Collegium maintains is a lapse.
Tools and materials
The Scriptorium fixes the instrument of drafting by ordinance, and the fixing is taken seriously. Attenuated Nickel-Silver drafting tools are reserved for catalogue updates referencing a Bibliographic Phantom and may not be used on a Concordance leaf, a restriction introduced after the Mist Vault Incident and reaffirmed without debate at every subsequent revision of the instrument schedule. Ordinary drafting proceeds in iron-gall ink on cotton rag, ruled at 6 mm.
The following instruments were held on issue to the drafting tables at the last published inventory:
- Rule, boxwood, 300 mm — 41 in service, 3 warped, 1 withheld pending enquiry;
- Compass, spring-bow, nickel-silver — 12 in service, 2 locked out after the Ordinance 712b finding;
- Staple-setter, lever action — 9 in service, all at the leaf tables;
- Eraser, abrasive block — 0 in service. Erasure on a sealed leaf is a disciplinary matter.
Disputes and unresolved questions
Three disputes remain open. The first concerns whether a Concordance may be drafted against a document not yet ratified; the Scriptorium says yes, on the authority of the Provisional Concordance Citations, and the Collegium says that this is how the Ninth happened. The second concerns Exorcism Drafting, which Concordance 44 codified in Clause 3 and which the Scriptorium has never satisfactorily reconciled with the leaf stage, since a clause drafted against an absence cannot easily be stapled to its neighbour. The third is the long quarrel with the Vex Cartographers Guild over the floor numbering used in drafting headers, which the Guild insists must follow surveyed coordinates and the Scriptorium insists must follow the registry. A joint committee was struck on Floor 404 in the winter of the Year of the Ninth Librarian and has not yet agreed its own terms of reference.
Drafting continues meanwhile. The Cartographers' Auxiliary supplies runners between the leaf tables and the morgue drawers, and it is a condition of their engagement that they not read what they carry.
See also
-
MS 1614.76
Protocol Drafting
Protocol Drafting is the branch of archival composition concerned with the formulation, numbering, and formal sealing of protocols…
-
MS 3342.70
Drafting of Edict
The Drafting of Edict is the regulated series of procedures by which a numbered edict passes from proposal to binding force within…
-
MS 0741.46
Floor 451 (the Spire of Resolutions)
The Spire of Resolutions is the name borne by Floor 451 of the Tower, a composite research and drafting gallery dedicated to the p…
-
MS 9299.87
Resolution Writ
The Resolution Writ is the conclusive administrative instrument issued by the Office of Final Accord to formally terminate a Resol…
-
MS 8191.88
Drafting Amp Authorization
Drafting Amp Authorization is the instrument by which a drafting committee is empowered to begin work at all, as distinct from the…
-
MS 3353.89
Precedent Concordance
Precedent Concordance is the composite body of numbered instruments by which the Tower records a precedent and simultaneously reco…
Referenced by
- MS 7380.14 The Principle of Contiguous Meaning
- MS 4981.34 Axis of Omissions
- MS 8191.88 Drafting Amp Authorization
- MS 7509.61 Concordance practice
- MS 8529.37 Drafting
- MS 6894.37 Perpetual Drafting Hall
- MS 1614.76 Protocol Drafting
Readers also asked
Fifty-Second Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fifty-Second Concordance, formally titled "Principles for the Curation and Containment of Ephemeral Voids," is a governing document ratified in Year 83 of the Second Librarianate. It establishes the legal and procedu…
Fifty-Second ConcordanceAttenuated Nickel-Silver drafting tools: what is it for?
Attenuated Nickel-Silver drafting tools are the implements of the Chapter of Instrumental Recension, cut from Attenuated Nickel-Silver (Registry Designation PA-07β) and used wherever a mark must be made legibly upon Phan…
Attenuated Nickel-Silver drafting toolsAris Thorne: how is it conducted?
Aris Thorne is the official designation, as per the 227th Amendment to the Twelfth Concordance, for the disputed corpus of logbooks, maintenance schedules, and administrative memoranda which collectively underpin the Tow…
Aris ThorneResolution Drafting: how is it conducted?
Resolution Drafting is the formalized, multi-stage process by which a dispute within the Tower's administrative or conceptual architecture is documented, debated, and guided toward a conclusive Resolution Writ. Governed …
Resolution DraftingPassages cited from this record
-
Where a clause has been amended more than twice in a single drafting season, the amended clause shall be read in the light of the clause it replaced, and the replaced clause shall be retained in the margin in a hand distinguishable from the body.
Third Concordance, Annex 4, on marginal retention
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 9914.58 Concordance of Four Fourthments
Because you consulted