Concordance of Annex Registers
MS 1882.69 · Documents and ordinances
The Concordance of Annex Registers is the instrument governing the admission of structures to the Tower's annex registers, and the sole authority for the reading of clause 12(b). It was sealed in the eleventh recension of the Librarian cycle and has been amended on nine recorded occasions, of which four survive intact, three survive in summary, and two are known only from the protests they provoked. It is not to be confused with the Concordance of Registers, which fixes the order of citation for Lys's Ambient Registers and says nothing whatever about admission, nor with Concordance 214 on Registers and Their Keeping, which predates both and is silent on citation by design.
Structure of the instrument
The Concordance opens with a preamble distinguishing a register (a list) from an annex register (a list of lists), and reserves the second term to structures that are themselves architectural — a spiral, a chamber, a lateral extension, or anything with a floor of its own. Clause 12(b), the operative provision, admits such a structure to the annex registers where it holds a chamber designation, a survey warrant signed by the Cartographic Annex, and a body of holdings that do not resolve more comfortably elsewhere.
The instrument sets no limit on the number of annexes, and the compilers appear to have regarded proliferation as a matter for the surveyors rather than the document. Whether clause 12(b) also requires the warrant to be countersigned is taken up below.
Clause 12(b) and the counting of storeys
Following a dispute over a stair that returned a fifth landing on three successive surveys, clause 12(b) was amended to require that a structure's storeys be counted by descent and not by ascent, "the return being the measure that stands" (Concordance of Annex Registers, clause 12(b)(iii), as amended). The ruling settled the Spiral Annex question and has caused difficulty ever since on stairwells that return on both directions.
A visiting rule appended to the clause is often reprinted with the schedule and rarely read: readers consulting the Concordance in the Cartographic Annex are asked to extinguish their lamps at the third landing, as the survey papers there are kept dry.
The Halven question
Halven of the Lower Registers was the first Annex Provost of the Scriptorium of the Lower Registers, and the Concordance's admissions schedule is the instrument he used. Halven's surviving notes argue that a countersignature was required from Provost's office "in all cases of spiral, and in none of chamber" (Halven of the Lower Registers, Schedule Note 4). The Third Concordance, Annex 4, clause 7, addresses only disagreements between registers regarding floor existence and naming, and cannot be read to support him. The weight of citation is against the countersignature, though it continues to be added by clerks trained below the fourth gallery.
Use with the ambient registers
Where a structure is admitted and also appears in an ambient register, the admission does not disturb the citation order. The Concordance of Registers fixes the order of the four ambient registers, and Perrault of the Stairwell Registers — who succeeded Clerk Athalie Venn and expanded the annex after taking office — noted in his survey memorandum that annex admissions were entered "after Lys, before the fourth, and never between" (Perrault of the Stairwell Registers, Survey Memorandum 9). This has been followed at Annex Ġamma-7 and, by extension, at Annex 7b.
"The admission is entered where the register is kept, and not where the annex stands; the second is a walk, the first is a record."
— Concordance of Annex Registers, clause 12(b), commentary
Persisting dispute
The principal disagreement concerns the Ghost Registers, which the Concordance of Registers does not address and which the present instrument appears to have overlooked. The surveyors maintain that a ghost register is a register and therefore not an annex register, and so falls outside clause 12(b) entirely. The Guild of Surveyors and Cartographers counters that a ghost register that has been kept is a list of lists and cannot be excluded without doing violence to the preamble.
The Fifth Concordance, Annex 11, clause 3, directs that cycles be corrected to match registers, which the Guild reads as authorising the correction of an incomplete annex. The Eighth Lateral Annex was admitted under precisely this reading, and the admission has never been withdrawn. The Vault of Lost Causes Annex 74 was admitted under 12(b) on a warrant that named no countersigning officer, and the Archival Inversions dispute turned on whether a correction of cycle could be cited as an admission. No resolution has been sealed; the Curator Marcellus has declined to comment in writing.
Inventory of the seal copies
Nine seal copies of the Concordance are recorded. Four are held at the Cartographic Annex, one at Annex Ω-3, one at the Spiral Annex, and three are unlocated but presumed to be in the Vault of Lost Causes Annex 74. The inventory is kept as follows:
- First recension, amended twice, complete.
- Fourth recension, clauses 1 to 12 only; clause 12(b) missing its third paragraph.
- Fifth recension, summary only, in the hand of Clerk Athalie Venn.
- Seventh recension, complete, but the amendment of the ninth is entered in the margin and not the body.
The remaining five are catalogued as held. The Cartographic Annex records the ninth amendment as "pending the return of the survey," which has been pending since the winter the stairs were resurveyed and given back a floor.
Status
The Concordance remains in force and is cited more often than it is read. Its authority rests on clause 12(b) and on the fact that nothing has been put in its place. The Concordance of Registers fixes citation order; the Third Concordance fixes the treatment of Silent Moss; and this instrument fixes admission. A reader wishing to admit an annex should begin here, sign nothing until the warrant is returned, and put the lamp out at the third landing.
See also
-
MS 8674.04
Extension to Non-Greek Characters
The Extension to Non-Greek Characters is a standing interpretive instruction governing the admission of alphabetic signage into th…
-
MS 5351.78
Gradual Admission Thesis
The Gradual Admission Thesis is the foundational document of the Gradualist movement, first circulated on Floor 119-Delta in the e…
-
MS 0530.85
Concordance 142
Concordance 142 is the standing instrument governing the custody, circulation, and revision of the floor registers of the Ninth Sp…
-
MS 6260.45
Coexistence
Coexistence is the governing principle of Tower administration, defined in the broadest recension as the permissible simultaneity …
-
MS 9575.41
Documentary Sourcing Division
Documentary Sourcing Division is the Tower bureau charged with the origination, verification, and recension of documentary sources…
-
MS 9127.20
88th Concordance
The 88th Concordance is a governing instrument of the Librarians, ratified on the fourteenth day of the eleventh spiral of the yea…
Referenced by
- MS 8569.84 Spiral Annex
Readers also asked
Archival Inversions: how is it conducted?
"An inversion is confirmed when two registers agree, disputed when they disagree, and settled when both registers have lost the entry."
Archival InversionsGuild of Surveyors and Cartographers: who are they?
The Guild of Surveyors and Cartographers is a composite body incorporated on 14 Sable 4402 by the Ninth Concordance, Annex 7, which united the surviving registers of the Guild of Surveyors with the survey branch of the M…
Guild of Surveyors and CartographersAnnex Gamma-7: how is it conducted?
Annex Gamma-7 is an administrative construct and procedural designation within the Tower's Second and Ninth Concordances, representing a codified protocol for the verification and initial classification of newly discover…
Annex Gamma-7Concordance of Registers: what does it set out?
The Concordance of Registers is a four-clause instrument fixing the order in which the four ambient registers are to be cited in any proceeding, filing, or floor dispute. It was sealed at the First Sitting of the Bureau …
Concordance of RegistersPassages cited from this record
-
The admission is entered where the register is kept, and not where the annex stands; the second is a walk, the first is a record.
Concordance of Annex Registers, clause 12(b), commentary
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 1255.00 Perrault of the Stairwell Registers
- MS 5834.13 Halven of the Lower Registers
- MS 3456.17 Ghost Registers
- MS 0120.92 Concordance 214 on Registers and Their Keeping
Because you consulted