Coexistence
MS 6260.45 · Practices and doctrines
Coexistence is the governing principle of Tower administration, defined in the broadest recension as the permissible simultaneity of two or more subjects, structures, veracities, or silent systems whose attributes cannot jointly be sustained in a single unfurled volume. It is distinguished from agreement, which the Tower has never required, and from tolerance, which the Office of Orthodoxy regards as a concession and therefore a weakness. Coexistence is not reconciliation. The parties are not made to match; they are filed side by side, in a Manifold, under seal, and left to remain what they are.
The principle is administered jointly by the Department of Architectural Symbiosis and the Chamber of Echoing Precedents, whose jurisdiction divides along a line that no one has been able to draw in ink since Year 734.
Origins
Coexistence entered the record as a marginal note. The Epoch of Clear Glass maintained that a contradiction, once observed, was obliged to collapse; the early Concordances were drafted on this assumption, and it is the reason so many of them are written in the imperative. Lysander the Unstitched, in c. 712 T.R., proposed instead that a contradiction need only be housed. His treatise, On the Coexistence of Contradictory Veracities, argued from the observed behaviour of stairwells that an impossible pair, if given sufficient volume, will proceed to contradict one another indefinitely without resolving — an outcome he described as "stable, and cheaper than the alternative."
"Let the two be shelved not as one corrected but as two preserved, and let the shelf be numbered, and let no one ask the shelf which of them is true."
— On the Coexistence of Contradictory Veracities, Book II, ch. 9
The treatise led directly to the establishment of the Chamber, and less directly to the Index Implementation Crisis, which ran for the better part of a decade before the Compromise of the Silent Index concluded it in Year 734.
The Index and the Frames
Proposed coexistences are tested against the Central Index, which was constructed precisely to prevent the cascade — the failure mode in which two housed contradictions generate a third in the corridor between them, and a fourth in the corridor between the third and the first. An approved arrangement is issued as a Frame of Coexistence.
The Index does not judge whether a Frame is right. It judges whether a Frame will hold. Frames have been approved for arrangements later found to be conceptually indefensible, and refused for arrangements now housed on nine floors, on the reasoning that the Index does not revisit its own dead. Clerks of the Order of Amanuenses copy each Frame in triplicate and destroy the second copy, a practice originating in Concordance 1180, never rescinded, and now regarded as purely formal.
The Quietness Quotient
Housed contradictions are rated for audibility. A pair that contradicts loudly — the stairwell that is both locked and open, the door that is both a door and a reading room — requires a generous Manifold and a floor removed from any scriptorium. A pair that contradicts quietly may share a landing. The quotient is not measured in units but by the complaint ledger of the nearest Librarian, and a formal Quietness Certificate is required before any Frame may place a contradiction adjacent to sleeping quarters.
The rating is contested. In the winter of Year 892, a Frame placing a silent contradiction beside the night desk of Floor Ȣ produced no complaints for eleven weeks, after which the Custodian's Manual was amended to note that absence of complaint is not a Quietness Certificate. The Custodian on duty, one Marrow, had been recording the contradiction's remarks as maintenance notes. The notes were bound and are now consulted; the contradiction has never been heard since, and the Frames drawn from its silence are considered among the most reliable in the archive.
Scholarly Disagreement
Two schools dispute what Coexistence is for. The symbioticians of the Department of Architectural Symbiosis hold that coexistence is a managed condition, indefinitely maintained, and that any attempt to conclude it constitutes a breach of the settlement of Year 734. The precedentialists of the Chamber reply that coexistence is only ever provisional — a stay of resolution, not an abolition of it — and cite Concordance 906, Annex 6, which refers to "the eventual and lawful resolution of housed pairs" without specifying a date.
The Doctrinal Variances Register has logged the dispute 41 times. On each occasion the entry has been closed without ruling and refiled under the Pluralist Orthodoxy, a doctrine that permits both readings on alternating floors. Readers wishing to examine the original filing are advised that the Register's annex is closed on the second and fourth days of the week.
Reception and Related Doctrine
Coexistence is sometimes confused with the Erosion Principle, which holds that a subject left in the wrong company will gradually become something else. The distinction is firm: erosion changes a subject, whereas coexistence preserves it by preventing the change from reaching it. The same confusion produced the long quarrel between the Chamber and the Office of Orthodoxy, which maintained for eighty years that the Chamber was harbouring contradiction without converting it, and which was eventually answered by the Pluralist party on the grounds that conversion had never been the Chamber's remit.
Coexistence is not available to Annex Ω, where the floor's own arrangements take precedence, nor to the Descent Protocols, which require a single reading of any floor they descend through. Expeditions returning from below occasionally report floors on which coexistence is practised so thoroughly that nothing has been decided for centuries; the reports are filed, and not contradicted.
Frames of Coexistence are issued under seal of the Chamber. Parties occupying a shared landing are reminded that the landing itself is not party to the arrangement and should not be addressed.
See also
-
MS 0984.18
Axiom of Simultaneity
The Axiom of Simultaneity is the fourth of the eleven axioms of the Concordance Prime cycle and holds that no two catalogued occur…
-
MS 7336.99
Seven Permissible Syllable Laws
The Seven Permissible Syllable Laws are the body of prosodic regulation governing which syllable structures may be uttered in the …
-
MS 2680.09
Procedural Simultaneity
Procedural Simultaneity is the principle under which the Directorate of Simultaneity maintains that all officially recorded events…
-
MS 6766.38
The Principle of Referential Integrity
The Principle of Referential Integrity is a foundational doctrine of archival administration within the Tower, governing the permi…
-
MS 5936.11
Codex IV (The Scaffolding of Attributes)
Codex IV (The Scaffolding of Attributes) is a foundational procedural document governing the classification, measurement, and lega…
-
MS 8346.14
Directorate of Simultaneity
The Directorate of Simultaneity is the sub-directorate of the Directorate of Archival Coherence responsible for verifying, documen…
Referenced by
- MS 2870.54 Pluralist Orthodoxy
- MS 6963.89 Chamber of Echoing Drafts
- MS 2680.09 Procedural Simultaneity
Readers also asked
Erosion Principle: how is it conducted?
The Erosion Principle is the collective name given to the four governing statements on the deliberate removal of reference from archival subjects, first consolidated under Seventh Concordance, Amendment 19, and revised w…
Erosion PrincipleCentral Index: who are they?
The Central Index is the primary administrative and procedural nexus for the Tower's cataloguing operations, serving simultaneously as a physical floor, a governing body, and the canonical reference document against whic…
Central IndexManifold: how is it conducted?
The Manifold is the fundamental architectural, ontological, and regulatory framework for the containment and processing of unreal subjects within the Tower. Governed principally by Clause 8.22 and its numerous amendments…
ManifoldCustodian’s Manual: what does it set out?
Custodian’s Manual is the comprehensive procedural codification for the physical and non-physical maintenance of all archived materials under the purview of the Custodian of the Stacks. It exists in multiple, simultaneou…
Custodian’s ManualPassages cited from this record
-
Let the two be shelved not as one corrected but as two preserved, and let the shelf be numbered, and let no one ask the shelf which of them is true.
On the Coexistence of Contradictory Veracities, Book II, ch. 9
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 5378.54 On the Coexistence of Contradictory Veracities
- MS 2723.25 Concordance 1180
- MS 1641.00 Index Implementation Crisis
- MS 3150.17 Concordance 906
Because you consulted