Concordance 44, Annex Δ
MS 7916.95 · Practices and doctrines
Concordance 44, Annex Δ is the third surviving lateral annex to the Forty-Fourth Concordance, ratified on the 12th of Hallowmonth, 3812, and concerned principally with the classification of objects that have been mislaid by their own description. It is administered from Floor 7719-B, a level whose name — The Ledger of Unreturned Syntax — is recorded in no less than four contradictory recensions of the Second Concordance, Annex D.
Origins and Ratification
The annex arose from a dispute between the Office of Described Things and the Medical and Metaphysical Annex over whether a staircase that had forgotten its upper landing ought to be catalogued as architecture or as a complaint. The Fourth Concordance had deferred the question; Concordance 12, Annex Δ later claimed jurisdiction by virtue of its schedule of supersessions, a claim the Seventh Concordance, Annex Q rejected on the grounds that Concordance 12, Annex Δ had itself been superseded by Concordance 712, Annex D. The Forty-Fourth Concordance settled the matter by appending Δ, which the Chief Scriptor of the time, Librarian Ossen of the Narrow Margin, described as "a holding pen for things that named themselves out of existence" (Concordance 44, Annex Δ, Prefatory Seal).
Ratification required the seals of seven floors. Floor 7719-B supplied the first; the sixth was withheld for nineteen years by the Wardens of the Crooked Aperture, who held that the annex's inventory of misdescribed doors violated Sixteenth Concordance Annex Delta. The seal was eventually affixed under pressure from the Third Concordance, Annex VII, which noted that the doors in question had already been misdescribed in earlier holdings and could not therefore be further injured.
Contents of the Holding
The annex maintains a rolling inventory of 4,112 items, revised each winter by the Clerks of the Diminishing Margin. Prominent entries include a bridge whose specification calls for a river that the bridge predates, a treaty between two floors that have agreed to disagree about which is above the other, and a small bronze implement listed only as "the tool for the task not yet named." The implement is stored in a cabinet sealed under Concordance 9, Annex Omega, which governs Initial Scrutiny, though the cabinet has no key and the Clerks maintain that none is required.
"An object mislaid by its own description remains catalogued so long as the description remains legible; should the description lapse, the object is transferred to the Annex of Withheld Conclusions under the provisions of the Third Concordance."
— Concordance 44, Annex Δ, Clause 3, Subclause ii
Administration and Dispute
Day-to-day administration falls to the Office of Described Things, which shares Floor 7719-B with the Records of the Spiral South. A long-running grievance is maintained by Clerk Brannel of the Lower Script, who in 3904 objected that the annex's revision cycle favoured items described in the Tower's northern idiom over those of the southern, citing a miscatalogued window that had been listed as a wall for eleven recensions. The Office of the Concordant Voice ruled the objection moot on the basis that the window had, in the intervening period, become a wall in fact (Twenty-Second Concordance, Annex G, Clause 22).
The Seventh Concordance, Annex Q adopted the annex's schedule of supersessions wholesale, a move the Concordance 417 Annex C later disputed on the grounds that its own authority derived from a different line of succession. The contradiction remains open; the Librarians have issued no ruling, and the Sixth Concordance, Annex Θ notes only that "the question is held in the manner of a breath not yet released."
Scholarly Disagreement
A principal point of contention concerns whether Annex Δ is a Lateral Annex in the sense confirmed for Concordance 12, Annex Δ by the Seventh Concordance, Annex Q, or a Dependent Annex subordinate to the Forty-Fourth Concordance's main body. The School of the Fixed Aperture holds the former, citing the Second Concordance, Annex D, which outlines provisional holding protocol for matters of lateral status. The Antiquaries of the Slow Stair dissent, pointing to Concordance Twenty-Second, Annex G, Clause 22, which they read as subordinating all annexes ratified after 3800 to their parent Concordance. The The Second Concordance Annex G declines to arbitrate, observing that "a floor is a floor whether one ascends to it or merely describes its descent."
Incidents of Note
In the winter of 4011, a maintenance note recorded that the lamp in the annex's reading niche had been replaced with a lamp that described itself as a colder lamp, and was therefore catalogued as a mislaid description rather than as lighting. The Wardens of the Crooked Aperture declined to interfere, noting that the colder lamp gave sufficient light for the Clerks to continue their revisions.
A more serious incident occurred in 4038, when Clerk Brannel of the Lower Script attempted to transfer the miscatalogued window — by then a wall — to the Medical and Metaphysical Annex on the theory that its transformation constituted a metaphysical injury. The Seventh Concordance, Annex 4 voided the transfer, ruling that a wall that had been a window was merely a wall with a history, and that history fell under Concordance 19 Annex Gamma, not the annex.
The annex's current inventory stands at 4,112 items as of the last winter revision. Visiting clerks are reminded that no item may be described aloud within three paces of the cabinet sealed under Concordance 9, Annex Omega, as the description may, under Clause 3, Subclause ii, be taken as the item's own.
See also
-
MS 0436.08
Amendment 247
Amendment 247 is a standing procedural amendment to the Provisional Logging Protocol, ratified on the third of Frostfall, 8812, in…
-
MS 3226.91
Sixth Concordance
The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned w…
-
MS 9570.77
One-Hundred-and-Twelfth Concordance
One-Hundred-and-Twelfth Concordance is a foundational administrative document of the Tower, ratified in Year 419 and principally c…
-
MS 6086.10
Annex Delta, Concordance 44
Annex Delta, Concordance 44 is the forty-fourth recorded recension of the Delta-subject appendage to the standing Concordances, ra…
-
MS 1073.49
Concordance 801
Concordance 801 is a governance document of the Tower, issued in the eighth hundred series of the Concordances and concerned princ…
-
MS 4251.59
Lateral Indexers Guild
The Lateral Indexers Guild is a chartered body concerned with the classification of holdings whose position is recorded relative t…
Referenced by
- MS 4482.30 Resonance Damping
- MS 3439.24 Annex A (Nutrient Formulae)
- MS 1540.29 The Inquisitors
- MS 5441.03 Concordance 47-C, Annex 2
- MS 8407.13 Annex Delta Body
- MS 4650.41 Ninety Second Concordance Annex Delta
Readers also asked
Concordance 12, Annex Δ: who are they?
Concordance 12, Annex Δ (colloquially, "the Delta Annex") is a laterally appended supplement to the Twelfth Concordance, responsible for the cataloguing and procedural management of nominative recursion. It is housed on …
Concordance 12, Annex ΔSeventh Concordance, Annex 4: how is it conducted?
The Second Concordance Annex G: what does it set out?
The '''Second Concordance Annex G''' is the seventh surviving annex to the Second Concordance, distinguished from its neighbours by being the only annex in the foundational set to have been drafted, sealed, and ratified …
The Second Concordance Annex GMedical and Metaphysical Annex: what does it set out?
The Medical and Metaphysical Annex (colloquially "M&M Annex") refers to a collection of supplementary documents appended to the Third Concordance, Fifth Concordance, and Twelfth Concordance, which collectively govern the…
Medical and Metaphysical AnnexPassages cited from this record
-
An object mislaid by its own description remains catalogued so long as the description remains legible; should the description lapse, the object is transferred to the Annex of Withheld Conclusions under the provisions of the Third Concordance.
Concordance 44, Annex Δ, Clause 3, Subclause ii
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4624.42 Office of the Concordant Voice
- MS 3122.09 Records of the Spiral South
- MS 2782.51 School of the Fixed Aperture
- MS 1748.21 Clerks of the Diminishing Margin
Because you consulted